NBA · Thu, Dec 25 · 11:59 PM

Cleveland Cavaliers at New York Knicks

Madison Square Garden

GARY'S PICK

NBAvs Cavaliers· -112

TALE OF THE TAPE New York Cleveland Record 20-9 ← 17-14 Off Rating 121.9 ← 116.1 Def Rating 113.2 → 112.1 Net Rating +8.7 ← +4.0 Key Injuries Brunson (Q) Mobley (Q) Gary's Take Christmas at Madison Square Garden brings out a different level of intensity, and the New York Knicks have turned MSG into a fortress this season with a 14-2 home record. While Jalen Brunson's status is the headline to watch, the structural mismatch here exists regardless of who runs the point. The Knicks possess a massive efficiency advantage, boasting a 121.9 offensive rating that ranks among the league's elite, compared to a Cleveland squad that has been leaking oil defensively. The decisive factor in this matchup is physical dominance on the glass. New York is grabbing nearly 30% of their own misses—an astonishing offensive rebounding rate that demoralizes opponents. Cleveland, meanwhile, is one of the worst rebounding teams in the metric. With Karl-Anthony Towns stretching the floor and Josh Hart crashing the boards, the Cavaliers' interior defense is going to be under constant siege. This is compounded by Cleveland's recent form; they just surrendered 136 points to the Bulls and 132 to the Hornets. Their defense has vanished at the worst possible time. Even with the injury clouds hovering over Brunson and OG Anunoby, the Knicks have enough firepower in Towns and Mikal Bridges to exploit a soft Cavs defense that struggles to get stops on the road. New York's ability to generate second chances and control possession will wear Cleveland down by the fourth quarter. I expect the Garden crowd to fuel a comfortable win. Give me the Knicks -5.5 to handle business at home.

The pick & result

Published pick: Knicks -5.5 -112
Published odds: -112
Result: Lost
Final score: 124-126

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The read

TALE OF THE TAPE

New York Cleveland Record 20-9 ← 17-14 Off Rating 121.9 ← 116.1 Def Rating 113.2 → 112.1 Net Rating +8.7 ← +4.0 Key Injuries Brunson (Q) Mobley (Q)

Gary's Take Christmas at Madison Square Garden brings out a different level of intensity, and the New York Knicks have turned MSG into a fortress this season with a 14-2 home record. While Jalen Brunson's status is the headline to watch, the structural mismatch here exists regardless of who runs the point. The Knicks possess a massive efficiency advantage, boasting a 121.9 offensive rating that ranks among the league's elite, compared to a Cleveland squad that has been leaking oil defensively.

The decisive factor in this matchup is physical dominance on the glass. New York is grabbing nearly 30% of their own misses—an astonishing offensive rebounding rate that demoralizes opponents. Cleveland, meanwhile, is one of the worst rebounding teams in the metric. With Karl-Anthony Towns stretching the floor and Josh Hart crashing the boards, the Cavaliers' interior defense is going to be under constant siege. This is compounded by Cleveland's recent form; they just surrendered 136 points to the Bulls and 132 to the Hornets. Their defense has vanished at the worst possible time.

Even with the injury clouds hovering over Brunson and OG Anunoby, the Knicks have enough firepower in Towns and Mikal Bridges to exploit a soft Cavs defense that struggles to get stops on the road. New York's ability to generate second chances and control possession will wear Cleveland down by the fourth quarter. I expect the Garden crowd to fuel a comfortable win.

Give me the Knicks -5.5 to handle business at home.

Injuries noted

Cleveland Cavaliers: Evan Mobley (Questionable) — Dec 24: Mobley (calf) is listed as questionable for Thursday's game against the Knicks.; Larry Nance Jr. (Out) — Dec 21: Nance (calf) will not play Monday against the Hornets and remains week-to-week.; Max Strus (Out) — Dec 21: Strus (foot) won't play Monday against the Hornets and remains without a timetable to return.; win over New Orleans (Out); effectively managing the offense when Brunson (Questionable)

New York Knicks: Miles McBride (Out) — Dec 24: McBride (ankle) is out for Thursday's game against the Cavaliers.; Guerschon Yabusele (Day-To-Day) — Dec 24: Yabusele (illness) is listed as questionable for Thursday's game against the Cavaliers.; Landry Shamet (Out) — Dec 24: Shamet (shoulder) is out for Thursday's game against the Cavaliers.; Jalen Brunson (Questionable); OG Anunoby (Questionable); Starting if Brunson (Out)

About this analysis

Who made it: Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data: Daily picks first stored December 25, 2025 at 12:35 AM ET.
Odds record: The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Source names were not retained with this pick.
Accountability: Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Props on this game

GARY'S PICK
JALEN BRUNSONAST OVER 6.5
NBANew York Knicks· -132
LOST · ACTUAL 4
Jalen Brunson is going to be living on the court today with the Knicks' backcourt depth absolutely decimated. Without Miles McBride or Landry Shamet to spell him, Brunson is likely looking at upwards of 40 minutes as the primary floor general. When he gets that kind of run, his playmaking naturally takes a leap because the offense flows entirely through his hands for almost every possession. The Cavaliers are a tough defense, but they're dealing with their own frontcourt issues, which should open up passing lanes for Jalen to find guys like Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges. I'm expecting him to act as the ultimate facilitator while trying to keep the Knicks' offense in rhythm for the full four quarters. This assist total feels a bit low given the massive workload he's about to shoulder as the only true point guard available.
Jalen Brunson
Ast over 6.5
-132 · LOST · ACTUAL 4
New York Knicks
Jalen Brunson is going to be living on the court today with the Knicks' backcourt depth absolutely decimated. Without Miles McBride or Landry Shamet to spell him, Brunson is likely looking at upwards of 40 minutes as the primary floor general.
When he gets that kind of run, his playmaking naturally takes a leap because the offense flows entirely through his hands for almost every possession. The Cavaliers are a tough defense, but they're dealing with their own frontcourt issues, which should open up passing lanes for Jalen to find guys like Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges.
I'm expecting him to act as the ultimate facilitator while trying to keep the Knicks' offense in rhythm for the full four quarters. This assist total feels a bit low given the massive workload he's about to shoulder as the only true point guard available.
GARY'S PICK
JOSH HARTREB OVER 8.5
NBANew York Knicks· -102
LOST · ACTUAL 5
Josh Hart is the heart and soul of this Knicks roster, and today he's going to have to do even more work on the glass than usual. With Evan Mobley out for Cleveland, the Cavaliers lose their length and most versatile rebounder, leaving a massive void in the paint that Hart is famous for filling. We know Tom Thibodeau doesn't like to take Hart off the floor, especially with their bench currently thin, so he'll have plenty of chances to hunt down boards. He consistently outworks bigger players for positioning, and without Mobley to contend with, he’s going to have a much easier time cleaning up misses on both ends. Hart plays with a motor that most guys just can't match, and in a physical matchup against Cleveland, I expect him to be everywhere on the defensive glass. He's one of the best rebounding guards in the league for a reason, and tonight is the perfect setup for him to dominate the boards.
Josh Hart
Reb over 8.5
-102 · LOST · ACTUAL 5
New York Knicks
Josh Hart is the heart and soul of this Knicks roster, and today he's going to have to do even more work on the glass than usual. With Evan Mobley out for Cleveland, the Cavaliers lose their length and most versatile rebounder, leaving a massive void in the paint that Hart is famous for filling.
We know Tom Thibodeau doesn't like to take Hart off the floor, especially with their bench currently thin, so he'll have plenty of chances to hunt down boards. He consistently outworks bigger players for positioning, and without Mobley to contend with, he’s going to have a much easier time cleaning up misses on both ends.
Hart plays with a motor that most guys just can't match, and in a physical matchup against Cleveland, I expect him to be everywhere on the defensive glass. He's one of the best rebounding guards in the league for a reason, and tonight is the perfect setup for him to dominate the boards.

Every prop from this day is on the archive page.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NBA game this day The NBA record Today's NBA picks Every sport this day