Red Sox at Blue Jays
O/U 7.5 · RL Red Sox -1.5
The pick & result
- Published pick
- Red Sox ML -138
- Published odds
- -138
- Result
- Won
- Final score
- 7-0
Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.
The read
Gary's Take Day baseball at Rogers Centre, with Toronto lining up the brooms and Boston trying to stop a five-game skid. One rookie power lefty, one future Hall of Famer, and no shortage of pressure in the getaway game.
Payton Tolle is the separator. Toronto owns a .628 OPS against left-handed pitching and is sending out a heavily right-handed lineup without two of this series’ productive bats in Alejandro Kirk and Brett Bateman. Tolle has held righties to a .620 OPS, and his fastball, cutter and curve give him several ways to miss bats. Max Scherzer has stabilized lately, but Boston’s left-handed bats can attack a fastball that has been hittable all season.
I’m paying the -138 instead of getting greedy with the run line. Toronto has played too many close games, and its late-inning combination of Tyler Rogers and Louis Varland can keep any deficit tight. Boston has the starting-pitching advantage and enough fresh relief behind Tolle to protect a lead. One unit on the Red Sox moneyline.
The research
The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.
STARTER FORM
Max Scherzer: 2.57 ERA over his last 3 starts
2.57Forget the ugly season line — over his last three starts Scherzer's missed bats, kept his WHIP under 1.25, and looked like anyone's top-of-rotation arm. If the price still reflects the bad version of him, that's the gap I want.
HEAT CHECK
Wilyer Abreu: 1.081 OPS in Last 15 Days
1.081Abreu already had the best season line in this group, and now he's topping it at 1.081 over 47 plate appearances. 21 homers is the most power anyone on this board is carrying into tonight, so this isn't empty contact. Keep trusting the barrel.
Ceddanne Rafaela: .978 OPS in Last 15 Days
.97862 plate appearances is the biggest sample in this group, and the jump off his season mark is the smallest — he hasn't spiked so much as leveled up and held it for two-plus weeks. A .791 season OPS and 16 homers say the pop underneath was already real. Steadiest bet on the board tonight.
Andres Gimenez: .775 OPS in Last 15 Days
.775The most modest uptick of the group, real but not explosive, with eight homers already showing some pop behind it. Good news is the total bases number only sits at 0.5 — even a quiet hot streak clears that tonight.
COOLING OFF
Ernie Clement: .469 OPS in L15 — draws LHP Payton Tolle
.469Lefties have been the tougher assignment for Clement all year, even if the gap is modest. He's running well below even that weaker-side number lately, which says this is more of a general cold spell than a Tolle-specific problem.
Nathan Lukes: .464 OPS in L15 — draws LHP Payton Tolle
.464A .375 OPS against lefties is a real hole for Lukes, not a minor dip, and Tolle puts him right back into it tonight. The slump and the platoon issue point the same direction, so there's no favorable angle pulling him out of this one.
HEAD-TO-HEAD
Blue Jays are 9-5 vs Red Sox this season
9-5Nine wins in fourteen tries is a real sample, and Toronto backed it up with a 6-4 win last time these two played. Boston hasn't shown me anything this season to suggest they've solved this matchup, home or away.
REPLACEMENT
Nick Sogard (.771 vs RHP) replaces Isiah Kiner-Falefa at 2B tonight
.717Sogard's leading off tonight, not just filling in, so he sees the most pitches on the roster and sets the tone before the order turns over against Scherzer. His work against right-handers actually runs ahead of his season line, so the fit's legitimate. With two other regulars out of this lineup too, every time he reaches base carries extra weight.
Ernie Clement (.688 vs LHP) replaces Lenyn Sosa at 2B tonight
.712Rough draw for Clement to inherit — Tolle's a lefty, exactly where his production falls off, and he's hitting second instead of down the order. Toronto's banking on volume to cover the tough matchup rather than hiding him, which puts more weight on the top of the order to finish innings.
Jarren Duran (.635 vs RHP) replaces Roman Anthony at LF tonight
.617Duran slides into left and the seven-hole, right where a lineup either extends an inning or hands the pitcher a clean out. The matchup favors him — his work against right-handers runs ahead of his season line over a real sample, so this lineup gets a better version of him against Scherzer than his year-long number suggests. Same-day move, and the third regular out of position in this lineup tonight.
Nathan Lukes (.375 vs LHP) replaces Addison Barger at RF tonight
.689Lukes taking over in right is a real step down against lefties for Toronto — his numbers there are well off his season line, and Tolle gives him nothing to work with tonight. Batting ninth limits the exposure some, but Toronto's already light against left-handed pitching up the order, so the top of the lineup is carrying more weight than usual. Barger's been out over two weeks, so this is the settled look, not an improvisation.
Andruw Monasterio (.674 vs RHP) replaces Trevor Story at SS tonight
.780Monasterio's at shortstop and hitting eighth, low-pressure on paper, but he's the one turning the lineup over to the pitcher's spot most innings, which affects how many extra chances the top of the order gets. The matchup's the rough part — his work against right-handers sits well below his season line, and Scherzer's exactly the arm that split shows up against. A week out for the guy he's replacing means he's had time to get real reps in the role.
STREAK
BOS have lost 5 straight
L5BOS have lost 5 straight and been outscored by 10 over the run. Last 10: 5-5.
TEAM RECORD
Red Sox 7-1 in Payton Tolle's last 8 starts
7-1Boston just wins on Tolle's day, seven times out of eight, and I don't need to overthink why. The one thing giving me pause is they're dragging a five-game losing streak into Toronto, so I'd like to see them shake that off before I lean on the trend blind.
Blue Jays 2-6 in Max Scherzer's last 8 starts
2-6Toronto's offense has gone missing on Scherzer's turns, 2-6 tells the story, but I don't think that's on him — he's been the best version of himself his last few times out. That's a team problem more than a pitching problem.
REGRESSION
Max Scherzer: 7.25 ERA vs 5.43 xERA
5.43A 7.25 ERA is scaring people off, but the way he's actually pitching says something closer to mid-fives, and the gap is mostly hitters running hot on balls in play against him. I'll take that discount against Boston tonight.
Ceddanne Rafaela: .286 AVG vs .251 xBA
.251The wOBA is the number that matters more here than the average — a 54-point cushion over expected is the widest gap anywhere in this group, stacked up over 484 plate appearances, basically a full season. That's a year of extra-base pop the underlying contact hasn't fully supported. Wouldn't pay a premium expecting more of the same tonight.
Ernie Clement: .282 AVG vs .250 xBA
.250His overall production is running even further ahead of its expected mark than his average alone, which points to the power side of his line carrying more of the hot-streak residue than the hits themselves. Total-base markets look shakier here than a straight hits number tied to his average.
CLOSER WATCH
Aroldis Chapman
27 SVAroldis Chapman owns the ninth for the Red Sox — 27 saves this season (next closest: Erik Miller with 4).
FANTASY PICKUPS
Wilyer Abreu
.793 OPSPickup vs Max Scherzer (5.43 xERA) — .793 OPS, bats 3rd.
Ceddanne Rafaela
.791 OPSPickup vs Max Scherzer (5.43 xERA) — .791 OPS, bats 2nd.
CUT LIST
Charles McAdoo
0.626 OPSA .206 average and a .626 OPS aren't numbers to build around, but he's leading off tonight — the most at-bats and run-scoring looks on the roster — and that OPS, ugly as it is, is still the best of this group. Thin case, but there's marginally more use left in him than in the other two. Hold, for the at-bats alone — but he's on the shortest leash on the roster.
Max Scherzer
5.43 xERAStarts tonight for TOR — 5.43 xERA behind a 7.25 ERA.
About this analysis
- Who made it
- Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
- Published data
- Daily picks first stored August 13, 2026 at 11:41 AM ET.
- Odds record
- The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: fanduel, draftkings, caesars, betmgm, betrivers, fanatics.
- Accountability
- Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
Props on this game
2- GARY'S PICKPAYTON TOLLEK'S OVER 5.5
Tolle has cleared this number in seven of his last eight starts, including six straight, and just generated 14 strikeouts on 84 pitches. His fastball, cutter and curveball all miss bats, giving him multiple put-away options against Toronto’s six right-handed starters.
The Blue Jays generally make contact, but this lineup also includes several hitters running elevated whiff rates. Even if Boston continues managing Tolle’s workload, he has shown he can reach six strikeouts without pitching deep. I’ll lay -125 on the over.
- GARY'S PICKMAX SCHERZERK'S UNDER 4.5
Scherzer has exceeded four strikeouts in only one of his last eight starts. He has 27 strikeouts across 36 innings this season, while his fastball and slider have produced modest whiff rates compared with the versions of those pitches that once drove his strikeout ceiling.
Boston can make him work, and Scherzer has completed six innings only twice in nine starts. With five strikeouts requiring both improved swing-and-miss and enough length, I’m backing the under despite the heavier price.
Every prop from this day is on the archive page.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.
Get Gary on the App StoreEvery MLB game this dayThe MLB recordToday's MLB picksEvery sport this day