Pirates at Marlins
O/U 7 · RL Pirates -1.5
The pick & result
- Published pick
- Marlins ML +103
- Published odds
- +103
- Result
- Won
- Final score
- 0-2
Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.
The read
Tuesday night in Miami, and the big story is Paul Skenes on the mound. The betting shops are still making Pittsburgh the favorite basically because of his name — the guy won the award for best pitcher in the league. But I've watched him over the last month, and this isn't the same arm. His fastball has lost noticeable speed from last season, he hasn't hit his old top gear all year, and in his last three starts he's been handing out way too many free passes while giving up runs at an ugly rate. He can still make hitters swing and miss, but when a pitcher can't put the ball where he wants against a lineup that works long, patient at-bats, that's how a famous name gets pulled early and leaves his team in trouble.
Meanwhile, Miami is sending out Eury Pérez, who has quietly been the better pitcher for the last six weeks. He barely gave up anything through July, he's pitched deep into the game six starts in a row, and his fastball is still coming in scorching hot. Here's what really decides it for me: Pérez shuts down left-handed hitters — they barely get hits off him, let alone anything hit hard. And almost all of Pittsburgh's offense right now comes from Brandon Lowe and the other lefty bats around him. Take those guys away and you're left with a bottom of the lineup that's been chasing pitches it can't hit, an outfield missing Ryan O'Hearn, and a team that's lost seven of its last ten games while barely scoring. I don't trust that group against a guy throwing this well.
Yes, Miami loses Kyle Stowers today, and that hurts — he'd been their best hitter for two months. But this lineup is deeper than people think: Griffin Conine is on a serious home-run tear, Sanoja and Marsee are both hitting the ball hard, and this team has been dominant at home since late May, winning about two out of every three games in this park. When the hotter pitcher, the hotter offense, and the home-field edge all point the same way — and the bookies are paying you a little extra just because the other side has a star name on the mound — you don't overthink it. I'm taking the Marlins to win the game outright.
The full analysis
Tuesday night in Miami, roof shut tight, and the marquee says Paul Skenes. The books are still charging admission for the name — Pittsburgh sits at -110 behind a guy who won the Cy Young — but I've watched the last month, and the arm they're pricing isn't the arm that's showing up. The fastball has lost a tick and a half off last season, he hasn't scraped triple digits all year, and over his last three trips he's walked ten men in a hair over fourteen innings with an ERA north of eight. The strikeouts are still there, the stuff still flashes, but the command wobbles are real, and wobbly command in this building against a lineup that grinds at-bats is how a marquee name gives you five innings and a hooked ballgame.
Meanwhile the other dugout is running out Eury Pérez, who's quietly been the better pitcher for six weeks. He carried a 1.69 ERA through July, has gone five or more in six straight, and the fastball is sitting 98 with life. Here's the part that decides this game for me: Pérez buries left-handed hitters — under .200 against with barely any slug — and Pittsburgh's entire offensive pulse right now runs through Brandon Lowe and the lefty bats around him. Take those away and what's left is a bottom third that's been swinging at ghosts, an outfield missing Ryan O'Hearn, and a club that's dropped seven of ten while scoring under four a game. That's not a group I trust to solve a guy throwing this well.
The research
The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.
STARTER FORM
Paul Skenes: 8.16 ERA over his last 3 starts
8.16Paul Skenes' command has come apart the last three times out — a WHIP pushing past 1.70 says he's missing the zone, not just running into tough luck on balls in play. The season ERA still reads like a frontline arm, but it hasn't caught up to a stretch that's come with shorter outings and real damage. Miami gets whichever version shows up tonight, and lately it hasn't been the one on the season line.
PLATOON EDGE
Griffin Conine (bats L) hits 3rd against Paul Skenes (RHP)
.989Griffin Conine hitting third against a right-hander is the exact matchup that's given pitchers trouble all year, and Skenes is throwing from the side that plays right into it. That's a real advantage sitting in the middle of Miami's order tonight.
Brandon Lowe (bats L) draws Eury Perez (RHP), batting 2nd
.909Brandon Lowe hitting second against a right-hander is a full season of proof, not a hot week, and the two-hole means he's getting extra looks at Perez before the game settles into any kind of pattern. If Perez isn't sharp early, Lowe's the hitter built to make him pay for it more than once.
HEAT CHECK
Jakob Marsee: .984 OPS in Last 15 Days
.984That .984 OPS spans the last 15 days (34 PA) against a .637 season baseline, a 0.347 swing. His total-bases line tonight: 0.5.
COOLING OFF
Esmerlyn Valdez: .465 OPS in L15 — draws RHP Eury Perez
.465Esmerlyn Valdez's cold stretch is thin enough — under 40 plate appearances — that it could just as easily be bad luck as a broken swing, but tonight doesn't hand him an easy way out of it. Eury Perez was already a tough matchup for him before the slump started.
Otto Lopez: .580 OPS in L15 — draws RHP Paul Skenes
.580Otto Lopez's trouble against right-handers was already real before the last two weeks turned cold — 353 at-bats worth of a genuine weakness — and Skenes landing on the schedule tonight makes it worse timing, not better. When a slump overlaps with the one pitcher type that's always given a hitter trouble, neither problem cancels the other out.
HR THREAT
Griffin Conine
+630Gary's Take Conine is running the hottest power stretch on either roster right now — five home runs and a .968 OPS over his last fifteen games, capped by a two-homer night his last time out. He's not just hot in a part-time role, either.
BULLPEN
Pittsburgh Pirates pen: 15 relief IP over their last 3 games
15 IPYates working both of the last two days is the clearest fatigue flag in Pittsburgh's pen, and Sisk isn't far behind at 61 pitches across his two outings this stretch. Doval and Soto are the freshest arms in the group, one look apiece in the 20-pitch range, so a close game against Miami tonight is more likely to run through them.
RUNNING GAME
Miami Marlins like to run — Henry Davis (48% caught) is the wrong catcher to test
48% CSThis is a fight neither side backs down from — Davis has the arm to make Miami pay for testing him, and Miami's speed is good enough to make him prove it anyway. Every stolen base is a free trip into scoring position, every runner he throws out kills a rally before it becomes a run.
REGRESSION
Jake Mangum: .303 AVG vs .257 xBA
.257349 plate appearances in and Mangum's average still hasn't come back down to what his contact quality says it should be. That's too big a sample to call a hot streak — I'd expect the number bleeding toward .257 before it stops.
Spencer Horwitz: .269 AVG vs .231 xBA
.231Horwitz is hitting .269 with the batted-ball profile of a .231 hitter, and 321 plate appearances is too much runway for that gap to just be noise. The power's mostly earned — the wOBA gap is much tighter — but the average is carrying more than the contact underneath it has paid for.
About this analysis
- Who made it
- Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
- Published data
- Daily picks first stored August 11, 2026 at 5:13 PM ET.
- Odds record
- The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: fanduel, draftkings, caesars, betmgm, betrivers, fanatics.
- Accountability
- Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
Props on this game
4- GARY'S PICKPAUL SKENESPITCHER OUTS UNDER 17.5
This asks Skenes to finish six innings, something he hasn't done in any of his last three starts. Those outings totaled only 14.1 innings, and the ten walks are the real warning sign: even when he misses bats, the command problems keep driving up his pitch count.
Miami has enough patient contact bats to extend him. Xavier Edwards and Jakob Marsee aren't chasing much, Javier Sanoja rarely swings through a pitch, and the lineup has scored 19 runs across its last two games. Skenes can pitch well and still leave after five; at plus money, under 17.5 outs is my play.
- GARY'S PICKEURY PEREZK'S OVER 6.5
Pittsburgh strikes out 9.46 times per game, and this particular lineup gives Pérez several paths to seven. Brandon Lowe and Bryan Reynolds have both been swinging through more than 40 percent of their recent pitches, while Esmerlyn Valdez just struck out four times Sunday.
Pérez can attack that weakness with more than velocity. His slider owns a 43 percent whiff rate, his sweeper is at 38.5 percent, and his changeup is at 40 percent. He's reached nine strikeouts twice in his last four starts, and the even-money price gives me enough room to back another ceiling outing.
- THE LONG SHOTGRIFFIN CONINEHR OVER 0.5
Conine is running the hottest power stretch on either roster right now — five home runs and a .968 OPS over his last fifteen games, capped by a two-homer night his last time out. He's not just hot in a part-time role, either. With Stowers now on the injured list, Conine is locked into the middle of Miami's order tonight, batting third, so the at-bats are guaranteed.
The matchup adds to the case: Paul Skenes has been hammered for thirteen earned runs across his last three starts, a stretch that already includes a two-homer outing, and the two pitches he leans on to put hitters away — the sinker and the splitter — are both getting hit hard across the league this year, with the splitter alone allowing a .333 average against. Miami is reportedly loading the lineup with left-handed bats tonight specifically to take advantage of how Skenes has struggled lately, and Conine is the one in that group who's already swinging it well. The exit velocity and barrel numbers behind his recent homers say this is real contact, not a stretch of well-placed hits.
At plus-630, I think the form and the matchup put him ahead of what that price implies.
- THE LONG SHOTBRANDON LOWEHR OVER 0.5
Lowe's power is real right now — four home runs in his last fifteen games, an average exit velocity over 94 miles an hour on his recent contact, and a couple of genuine barrels mixed into a small sample. That's loud contact, not just a hot stretch of bloops falling in. The swing-and-miss has crept up alongside it, and the matchup itself isn't clean: Eury Perez has actually been tougher on left-handed hitters than right-handed ones this season, holding lefties under .200.
That's a real mark against the pick. It's a full-season, league-wide number rather than anything built on history with Lowe specifically, though, and the one pitch that has given Perez trouble this year is his sinker — hitters are batting .300 against it. That's a pitch a hitter running this hot can do damage on if he gets it.
I'm less confident here than I'd like given the platoon split, but the power he's carrying into tonight is legitimate, and plus-480 is paying well past what his recent rate suggests it should.
Every prop from this day is on the archive page.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.
Get Gary on the App StoreEvery MLB game this dayThe MLB recordToday's MLB picksEvery sport this day