Mets at Guardians
O/U 16.5
New York Mets ML+114
CONF 71%
WCashedFinal 13-6
The read
One-ten in the afternoon at Progressive Field, sun on the third-base line, and Cleveland comes out for the last game of a long homestand already down two in this series. The Mets flew in with a losing record and have spent two days making the standings look like a typo — six runs Tuesday, six more Wednesday in extras. Now they get the getaway game and the market is paying me to take them. Fine by me.
Start with Cleveland's starter. Foster Griffin's run prevention looks shiny, but that number is doing a lot of lying — everything under the hood says he's been getting away with it. Hitters have stopped missing his pitches; the swing-and-miss was there in his first start and has fallen off a cliff since. He's barely striking anyone out lately and Atlanta hit him around his last time out. He's a lefty whose real problem is right-handed bats — they hit him, they hit him for power — and New York is running out a lineup that's almost entirely righties and switch hitters. Across from him, Nolan McLean is throwing the best ball of his year: big fastball, piling up strikeouts over his last three, six innings every single time out since June, and no more than two runs allowed in six straight.
Then look at who Cleveland has to score with. This is one of the lowest-scoring teams in the league and they've barely scratched runs across lately, and today they're missing Kwan and Adell on the back end of a night game. José Ramírez is playing but still finding his hands after wrist surgery — almost nothing to show for his last handful of at-bats and weak contact when he does connect. Behind the starter, the Cleveland bullpen has been leaking runs all week, Cade Smith is coming off heavy back-to-back workload and a blown save, and Festa wore the loss last night. The Mets' relievers have given up one run in three games. I've got the better starter, the better bullpen, the lineup matchup in my favor, and a team that's already proven this week it can score in this ballpark — and I'm getting paid extra to take it. Mets to win.
The full analysis
**Gary's Take — Mets ML +114**
Start with the man on the mound for Cleveland. Foster Griffin is carrying a 3.06 ERA into his first start in a Guardians uniform, and that number is doing a lot of lying. His expected ERA sits at 4.07, the swing-and-miss has drained out of him — thirty-nine percent whiffs in one start, then sixteen, sixteen, eighteen — and he's got seven strikeouts in his last nineteen innings while getting knocked around for six earned by Atlanta in his last time out. He's a left-hander whose problem is right-handed hitters: .246 against, thirteen home runs, a .690 OPS. New York is sending eight righty or switch bats up there today. Across from him, Nolan McLean is throwing the best ball of his year — ninety-six with the four-seamer, twenty-three punchouts across his last three starts, six innings every single time he's taken the ball since June. He hasn't allowed more than two earned runs in six straight.
Then look at what Cleveland has to score with. This is a club sitting near the bottom of the league in runs, averaging 3.3 over its last ten, and today's card is missing Kwan and Adell on the back end of a night game. José Ramírez is in there but he's still finding his hands after the hamate surgery — one hit in his last ten at-bats and soft contact when he does connect. Behind the starter, the Cleveland pen has coughed up thirteen runs in twenty-four innings this week, Cade Smith is coming off sixty pitches in two days and a blown save, and Festa took the loss last night. The Mets' relievers have surrendered one earned run in three games. I've got the better arm, the better pen, the lineup with the platoon in its favor, and a team that's already proven this week it can score in this ballpark — and I'm getting paid to take it. Mets moneyline, plus 114.
Props on this game
2Nolan McLeanUNDER 2.5 Pitcher Earned Runs Pitcher Earned Runs-150
LActual 5
McLean gets the day game off the best stretch of pitching he's thrown all year. Over his last three starts he's worked 18.1 innings and allowed four earned runs — a 1.96 ERA — with 23 strikeouts against six walks, and he hasn't allowed more than two earned runs in any of his last six turns, a run that stretches back to June 30. July alone was a 1.78 ERA across five starts.
He's also a strict six-innings-and-out pitcher right now, exactly 6.0 innings in five of his last six outings, which caps how much damage he can even allow in a start by design. The lineup he's facing today has no recorded at-bats against him and is playing without Steven Kwan and Jo Adell for the getaway game. I'm not betting against that form.
Nolan McLean, under 2.5 earned runs, minus 150.
Nathaniel LoweOVER 1.5 H+R+RBI H+R+RBI+115
WActual 6
Nathaniel Lowe was still a Cincinnati Red on Monday. Cleveland got him ahead of the deadline, activated him Tuesday, and he has been the best bat in this lineup since he put the uniform on — nine-for-25 with six RBI over his last week, .340 across his last fifteen games with eight RBI in that stretch.
He's a left-handed bat, and Nolan McLean has actually been the more hittable pitcher against lefties than righties this year — a .701 OPS and nine home runs allowed in 271 at-bats, against a .549 mark facing right-handers. Lowe's also been a strong day hitter by track record.
Hot bat, favorable platoon, day game — getting to two combined hits, runs, and RBI looks more likely than not. Over 1.5 hits, runs, and RBIs, plus 115.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.
Download on the App Store