Mets at Guardians
O/U 8 · RL Mets -1.5
Mets ML+101
CONF 61%
WCashedFinal 6-5
The read
Wednesday night in Cleveland, first pitch a little before seven, and the Guardians come to the park needing to even up the series against a team that really shouldn't be beating them. The Mets have lost a lot more than they've won, sold off pieces at the trade deadline, and are running out a fill-in manager and a lineup full of guys most fans wouldn't recognize. Cleveland has won about as often as they've lost and is still technically in the race. And the betting market says this game is a coin flip. That got my attention. What got it more is who's pitching.
Christian Scott is the best arm in the building tonight, and not a single Cleveland hitter has ever faced him. Not one at-bat, top to bottom of the order. He misses bats at a serious rate with a heavy fastball and a breaking ball hitters flail at constantly, and he's been especially tough on lefty bats — which matters, because Cleveland's card tonight is stacked with left-handed hitters in Kwan, DeLauter, Lowe, Bazzana and Halpin, plus three switch-hitters at the bottom. That group has barely scratched out runs for two weeks. Tonight they're without Jose Ramirez again, Gabriel Arias was cut loose this morning, and Angel Genao just got called up from the minors to hit last and play third. That's a lineup asked to solve a live arm it's never seen, on a night it can least afford to be short-handed. Meanwhile, Tanner Bibee's shiny run prevention number is hiding a lot: he doesn't strike many out, hitters barely swing and miss against him, they've been squaring him up hard all summer, and left-handed bats have taken him deep over and over. The Mets will send Ewing, Benge, Young and Baty up from that side, and they lift the ball as well as anyone.
I won't pretend the late innings don't worry me. Scott's been on a short leash all year coming back from elbow surgery — four to six innings and he's done — and the Mets shipped out half their relief help a few days ago. Whatever lead he hands over gets carried by Lavender, Duarte, Senga in his brand-new one-inning job, and a closer who walks too many guys. Cleveland's relief group is deeper, Cade Smith is the best reliever who'll pitch tonight, and the home team gets the last swing. That's a real risk, and it's why I'm not betting this bigger. But you have to actually score to use any of that, and I don't see where Cleveland's runs come from. Give me the better starter, the short-handed opponent, and a little extra payout on the side I already wanted. **Mets moneyline, +101.**
The full analysis
Wednesday night on the shores of Lake Erie, first pitch at 6:40, and Cleveland comes to the ballpark needing to even a series against a team that has no business beating them. The Mets are 48-66, gutted at the deadline, running out an interim manager and a lineup card full of names most of the country couldn't pick out of a crowd. The Guardians are .500 and still nominally alive. And the market has this one dead even. That's the first thing that got my attention — the second is what's actually taking the ball tonight.
I'm not going to pretend the back end doesn't scare me. Scott has been on a leash all year coming off the elbow surgery — four to six innings and out — and the Mets traded away half their bullpen four days ago. Whatever lead they hand off gets carried by Lavender, Duarte, Senga in his brand-new one-inning role, and a closer walking too many people. Cleveland's pen is deeper, Cade Smith is the best reliever in the game tonight, and the home team hits last. That's a real risk and it's the reason this isn't a bigger number for me. But you have to score to use those advantages, and I don't see where Cleveland's runs come from. Give me the better starter, the shorthanded opponent, and plus money on the side I wanted anyway. **Mets moneyline, +101.**
Props on this game
5Christian ScottOVER 5.5 Strikeouts Strikeouts+125
WActual 7
Christian Scott has punched out twenty hitters across his last fifteen and a third innings, better than a strikeout an inning, and his whiff rates over that stretch have sat in the mid-20s to low-30s on the fastball and sweeper both. He's cleared this number in six of his last eight starts.
Nobody in Cleveland's lineup tonight has ever faced him — not a single at-bat of history in that dugout — and the middle of their order is stacked with left-handed bats he's handled all year. A short pitch count caps his innings, not his swing-and-miss rate per inning.
I'll lay the plus money and take the over.
Steven KwanOVER 1.5 Total Bases Total Bases+150
LActual 1
Steven Kwan doesn't need to solve anything about Christian Scott, he just needs to keep doing what he's done for two weeks — put the bat on the ball. He's hitting .391 over his last fifteen games and .500 over his last week, and the plate-discipline numbers behind that are exactly the profile you want against a swing-and-miss arm: a twelve percent whiff rate and a chase rate under a quarter of pitches out of the zone.
Scott has been tough on left-handed bats as a group all year, but that number is built on hitters who expand the zone against him, and Kwan simply doesn't do that. This total has gone over in nine of his last fifteen games.
At plus money, that's underpriced.
Francisco LindorOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+404
LActual 0
Lindor's the best number on the board for me tonight. He's carrying real momentum into this one — three home runs and nine RBI over his last fifteen games, an OPS pushing .900 in that stretch, so this isn't a name I'm picking on reputation alone.
He's a switch-hitter, which means he sees Tanner Bibee from the left side, and that's exactly the side Bibee has struggled with this season — fourteen home runs allowed to left-handed hitters, well ahead of what he's given up to righties. Put a hot bat on the side of the plate where a pitcher has already shown he's hittable, and I like my chances.
The board agrees too — this is the shortest homer price on the entire Mets roster tonight, and I don't need to fight the market to make a case here. I'm in.
Carson BengeOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+600
WActual 1
Carson Benge is swinging a hot bat right now, and he's already proven it in this exact building. He hit a ball 451 feet off this Guardians pitching staff on Tuesday night — the longest home run at Progressive Field all season — and he's carried that into a .346 average and a .909 OPS over his last week.
That's not a one-swing fluke, that's a rookie seeing the ball well right now. He's left-handed, and Bibee's numbers against lefties this year are the softer half of his platoon split.
I like a hot hand walking back into the same park where he just did it, against a pitcher who's had trouble keeping the ball in the yard against that side.
Chase DeLauterOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+509
LActual 0
Chase DeLauter's underlying swing has looked good beyond just the box score lately — his average exit velocity has been sitting near 94 miles an hour over his recent stretch, and his whiff and chase numbers say he's controlling the zone, not just running hot off mistakes. He's left-handed, and Christian Scott's actual split this year cuts against his overall polish — Scott's been considerably tougher on right-handed hitters than lefties, and most of the home runs he's allowed have come from the left side of the plate. DeLauter fits that profile, he's seeing the ball well right now, and I think that combination is worth the price.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.
Download on the App Store