Athletics at Reds
O/U 9.5 · RL Reds -1.5
The pick & result
- Published pick
- Reds ML -161
- Published odds
- -161
- Result
- Won
- Final score
- 2-3
Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.
The read
It's eighty-seven degrees by the river tonight with a light breeze blowing across the field, and a team that hasn't won a game in over a week is walking into the easiest place to hit in the league. Oakland's dropped six straight and just got swept at home by Detroit, including one afternoon where they got shut out badly enough that it looked like they'd already given up. Cincinnati won the opener Tuesday when a couple of pitches got away from the Oakland catcher in the eighth, and now they get game two against that same shaky bullpen.
Start with lefty-righty. Terry Francona is putting eight right-handed hitters in the lineup against Jacob Lopez, and righties have absolutely feasted on him all year — that's where every bit of the damage against him comes from. The underlying numbers say he's pitched better than his results, I won't argue that, but he walks too many guys and he never gets deep into games — his last six starts have all ended somewhere in the fourth, fifth or sixth at the latest, and a couple didn't even get that far. Call it five innings and gone, which dumps the rest of the game on a bullpen where the only two arms Mark Kotsay actually trusts, Hogan Harris and Elvis Alvarado, have both pitched two days in a row. Harris is the guy whose wild pitches lost Tuesday's game. Cincinnati's relievers, meanwhile, each threw a quiet inning last night and everybody's fresh.
Rhett Lowder's overall season numbers don't look good and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. But he's been a completely different pitcher at home than on the road, and his worst outing of the year came in the thin air of Colorado — take that one away and his last two starts have been excellent. The lineup facing him is missing four of its best bats in Brent Rooker, Nick Kurtz, Shea Langeliers and Zack Gelof, and it's barely scoring three runs a night while losing nine of its last ten. At this price I need to win a little more than six times out of ten to profit, and a righty-heavy lineup against the wrong-handed starter, a short outing, and a gassed bullpen in a ballpark that makes you pay for mistakes gets me there with room to spare. Reds to win.
The full analysis
**Gary's Take — Athletics at Reds, 6:40 ET, Great American Ball Park**
Eighty-seven degrees on the river, a three-mile-an-hour breeze drifting from right to left, and a team that hasn't won since the calendar turned rolling into the friendliest yard in the National League. The Athletics come in on a six-game skid, freshly swept out of Sacramento by Detroit — including an 11-0 afternoon that read more like a resignation letter than a box score. Cincinnati took the opener Tuesday on a pair of wild pitches in the eighth, and now gets game two with the same bullpen problem sitting across the diamond.
Start with the handedness. Terry Francona is sending eight right-handed bats at Jacob Lopez, and right-handed hitters have hit .294 with an .890 OPS and ten home runs off him in 201 at-bats this season — the entirety of his damage lives on that side of the plate. His peripherals are better than his ERA, I don't dispute that, but he walks better than five per nine and he does not finish innings: his last six turns went 3.2, 2.0, 1.2, 4.1, 5.0, 5.1. Call it five and out, which hands roughly four innings to a relief corps whose only two arms manager Mark Kotsay actually trusts, Hogan Harris and Elvis Alvarado, have both worked each of the last two days — and Harris is the one who threw the three wild pitches that decided Tuesday. Cincinnati's pen, by contrast, gave Sam Moll, Julian Garcia and Emilio Pagán a clean inning apiece last night and has everybody available.
Rhett Lowder's season-long line is unattractive and I'm not going to dress it up. But he has a 3.07 ERA over forty-one innings in this ballpark against 7.71 everywhere else, and the ugliest start on his ledger came at altitude in Colorado — strip that one out and his last two turns are eleven innings and four earned. Standing in against him is a lineup missing Brent Rooker, Nick Kurtz, Shea Langeliers and Zack Gelof that has scored 3.1 runs a game while losing nine of ten. I need a shade over 61 percent to make this price work, and the combination of a right-handed lineup against the wrong-handed arm, a short starter, and a burnt-out bullpen in a park that punishes mistakes gets me past it comfortably enough. **Reds moneyline at -161.**
The research
The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.
STARTER FORM
Jacob Lopez: 1.84 ERA over his last 3 starts
1.84Three starts, 14.7 innings, three earned runs — a 1.84 ERA that looks nothing like his 5.79 season number. This isn't coming out of nowhere either: his expected numbers had been saying he was better than his results all year.
Rhett Lowder: 8.10 ERA over his last 3 starts
8.10Thirteen and a third innings, twelve earned runs — an 8.10 ERA his last three that's nearly three runs worse than his season mark, even though his WHIP in that stretch (1.43) is actually a touch better than his season number. That's a guy giving up more damage, not more baserunners — and the home split everyone's citing only helps tonight if this start looks like his other home starts and not his last three.
RUNNING GAME
Green light: Cincinnati Reds run, and Jonah Heim has caught just 16%
16% CSJonah Heim is catching tonight at 16% on the season (7-for-45 throwing), and Cincinnati Reds attempt 1 steals a game. The track meet is on.
BALLPARK
Rhett Lowder's ERA drops to 3.07 at Great American Ball Park
3.07Rhett Lowder at home is basically a different pitcher — 3.07 ERA at Great American Ball Park against 7.71 anywhere else. That split matters tonight because he's actually pitching at home, which is the one thing working in his favor after a brutal last three starts.
STREAK
OAK have lost 5 straight
L5Oakland's lost five in a row and been outscored by 28 runs doing it — 1-6 over the last seven. They send out Jacob Lopez tonight, though, and he's actually looked like a different pitcher than his season line the last three times out.
REGRESSION
Jacob Lopez: 5.79 ERA vs 3.69 xERA
3.69The season number says 5.79, but Lopez's expected ERA is 3.69 — a 2.1 run gap that's had him getting hit harder than his actual stuff deserved. His last three starts look like that gap is finally closing.
CUT LIST
Noelvi Marte
0.579 OPSStill hitting 5th for CIN — 0.579 OPS, 0.192 AVG from the 5-hole.
About this analysis
- Who made it
- Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
- Published data
- Daily picks first stored August 5, 2026 at 12:45 PM ET.
- Odds record
- The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: caesars, draftkings, betmgm, fanduel, betrivers, fanatics.
- Accountability
- Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
Props on this game
3- GARY'S PICKELLY DE LA CRUZWALKS OVER 0.5
De La Cruz has walked in eleven of his last fifteen games. That's not a small sample fluke, that's a switch-hitter seeing the ball well from both sides of the plate right now.
The pitcher on the mound tonight has issued forty-two walks in seventy innings this season — 5.4 per nine — and that number didn't correct itself even during his best recent outings; his last three starts covered fourteen and two-thirds innings and he still walked eight hitters. Command problems don't fix themselves against a patient hitter on a hot on-base stretch.
I'll take the walk.
- GARY'S PICKSAL STEWARTRBI OVER 0.5
Stewart has sixteen RBIs and four home runs over his last fifteen games — a legitimately hot bat — and he's driven in a run in ten of those fifteen. He hits second behind Elly De La Cruz, who's reaching base at a high clip right now, and he's facing a pitcher that right-handed hitters have torched for a .890 OPS and ten home runs across 201 at-bats this season.
Stewart bats right-handed. The lineup slot, the man on base in front of him, the arm on the mound — it all lines up.
The price is treating this like he drives in a run less than half the time. His last two weeks say otherwise.
- THE LONG SHOTSAL STEWARTHR OVER 0.5
Stewart's carrying real thunder into this one — four home runs and 16 RBI over his last 15 days, a .938 OPS in the last week, and the exit-velo readings back it up: 91.7 mph average, two barrels on his last 15 balls in play. He's hitting second tonight, so he's getting full run through the lineup and more looks than a bottom-of-the-order bat gets.
The matchup points the same way. Jacob Lopez has been a different pitcher to right-handers than to lefties this season — righties are hitting .294 with an .890 OPS and ten home runs in 201 at-bats against him, more than triple his homer rate against left-handed hitters. Stewart bats right-handed. Lopez's cutter and changeup are also the two pitches getting hurt hardest by opposing hitters this year, both giving up extra-base contact at a high rate.
Great American Ball Park plays small with the ball carrying well, which only helps a right-handed pull hitter.
The price is +310, needing this to land a little better than one in four. Stewart's cleared that bar close to one in three times over his last two weeks. I'll take that gap.
Every prop from this day is on the archive page.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.
Get Gary on the App StoreEvery MLB game this dayThe MLB recordToday's MLB picksEvery sport this day