Marlins at Braves
O/U 9 · RL Braves -1.5
Braves ML-146
CONF 65%
WCashedFinal 2-4
The read
Tuesday night in Atlanta, first pitch just after seven, and the Braves come home to face a division rival they've already beaten in five of their seven meetings this year. Atlanta has won five in a row and just swept Washington out of their own ballpark over the weekend. Miami's playing well too — they've won six of their last seven, and Alcantara shut them out on Sunday. The Braves are the favorite, and you'll have to lay a bit extra to back them.
The market's paying for the wrong thing. It's looking at the two starters' run prevention numbers on paper, seeing a wide gap, and pricing that in. That gap isn't real. Look at the kind of contact each guy actually gives up and they're basically the same pitcher — Holmes has been getting better results than he's earned for two months now, Gusto worse. So I'm not betting the starter matchup. I'm betting who's coming to the plate and what happens once the starters are out. Gusto has real trouble with left-handed hitters — they've been hammering him all year — and Atlanta is going to run Baldwin, Olson, Harris, Yastrzemski, Smith and Jarvis at him, plus Albies, who can bat from whichever side suits him. Olson has homered three games in a row and in four of his last six. That's a brutal lineup to face with that kind of weakness, and Gusto has only made it out of the fifth inning once in his last six starts. Miami has to bridge the middle innings with a bullpen that lost pieces at the trade deadline.
The other half is the lineup Miami actually wrote out tonight. This isn't the group that won six of seven — Edwards isn't in it, Hernandez has basically stopped hitting and is swinging through everything, Caissie has barely batted in the big leagues at all, and the bottom of the order hands out free outs. Holmes leans on a slider he throws a ton and gets a lot of swings and misses with, and tonight he gets to throw it at hitters who chase. Behind him he's got Iglesias, Dodd, Lee and Fuentes, all fresh after an off day Monday. Atlanta's been very good at home this year; Miami's been below .500 on the road. I won't oversell the price — it's fair, not a steal, and the line has already nudged toward Atlanta since this morning. But the reason to be here is the matchup underneath the price, not the price itself. Braves, moneyline.
The full analysis
Tuesday night in Atlanta, first pitch at 7:15, and the Braves come home to a division rival they've already handled five times in seven tries this year. Atlanta's won five straight and swept Washington out of Truist over the weekend. Miami rolls in hot too — six wins in their last seven, Alcantara's shutout ball on Sunday still fresh — and the board says Braves minus 146.
The market is paying for the wrong thing here. It's pricing the ERA on the marquee: Holmes at 3.88, Gusto at 5.31, and calling that a run and a half of separation. It isn't. Dig into the contact each one actually allows and they're the same pitcher — Holmes has been outrunning his own peripherals for two months, Gusto has been running behind his. So I'm not buying this ticket on the starter gap. I'm buying it on who steps in the box and what happens after the fifth. Gusto has a left-handed problem — lefties are hitting near .300 with an .842 OPS against him — and Atlanta is going to send Baldwin, Olson, Harris, Yastrzemski, Smith and Jarvis at him, with Albies turning around from whichever side he likes. Olson has gone deep in three straight games and four of the last six. That's the wrong lineup to see when your platoon split reads like that, and Gusto has cleared five innings once in his last six turns. Miami is covering the middle innings with a bullpen that got lighter at the deadline.
The other half is the lineup card Miami actually posted. This isn't the group that won six of seven — Edwards isn't in it, Hernandez has one hit in his last eighteen swinging through everything, Caissie has three big-league at-bats to his name, and there's a bottom third that gives outs away. Holmes lives off a slider he throws better than a third of the time and misses bats with at a 36 percent clip, and he gets to throw it to hitters who chase. Behind him: Iglesias, Dodd, Lee, Fuentes, all rested off Monday. Atlanta is 36-20 in this park, Miami is 24-32 away from theirs. I won't oversell the number — minus 146 is a fair price, not a gift, and the line already moved a few cents toward Atlanta since morning. But the reason to be here is the matchup underneath the price, not the price itself. Braves, moneyline.
Props on this game
3Matt OlsonOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+320
LActual 0
Thirty-one homers, tied for fourth in the league, and he's not cooling off — four in his last six games, three straight before Sunday's finale against Washington. His own manager said it plainly this week: he changes the game in the box. The split that jumps out is night versus day — .928 OPS under the lights against .781 in daytime, and this one goes at 7:15 under Truist's lights.
He's faced Ryan Gusto before too: 2-for-5 with a homer. Gusto's the story here as much as Olson is. Lefties have hit .293 with an .842 OPS against him this year, righties barely clear .600 OPS — that split is enormous, and Olson bats left.
Add in that Gusto's allowing hard contact on 45 percent of balls in play, the worst mark of either starter tonight, and this is about as clean a home run setup as the board offers.
Kyle StowersOVER 1.5 Total Bases Total Bases+115
LActual 1
Stowers is running as hot as anyone in this lineup — three home runs in his last seven games, four over his last fifteen, and his exit velocity has climbed right along with it, sitting near 94 mph average with three barrels in his last eighteen balls in play. He does his damage against right-handers specifically: .854 OPS and fifteen of his sixteen homers have come against them, and Gusto throws right-handed while getting hit hard all season — a 45 percent hard-hit rate allowed. Getting plus money on a hitter in this kind of form to clear a total base and a half is a number worth taking, even though the head-to-head history with Gusto himself is thin.
Grant HolmesUNDER 4.5 Strikeouts Strikeouts+100
LActual 5
The market has Holmes at a coin flip to clear four and a half strikeouts, but he's actually gone under that number in six of his last eight starts, and his last three outings have averaged fewer than four punchouts each. Part of it is workload — he's been capped around five innings a start lately, which only gives him so many hitters to work through. Part of it is who he's facing: Otto Lopez and Javier Sanoja, both in tonight's lineup, have been putting the bat on the ball at a high rate in their recent games, and Holmes will see that stretch of the order more than once if he goes deep. His slider still misses bats when everything's working, but the recent innings totals and the contact-oriented parts of this lineup point toward staying under the number, not clearing it.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.
Download on the App Store