Red Sox at Dodgers
O/U 7.5 · RL Dodgers -1.5
Red Sox ML+149
CONF 62%
WCashedFinal 3-2
The read
Saturday night in Los Angeles, the two-time champs just got hammered at home the night before, and their best pitcher takes the mound to stop the slide. That's the story everyone's telling. Here's what actually caught my eye: the price on the Dodgers this morning was a lot cheaper than it is right now, and it moved a long way in a single day. Willson Contreras took a fastball off the helmet Friday and he's out — that's real news and it deserves some of that move. It doesn't deserve all of it. When a price runs way past the news behind it, the extra is people paying for a big name and a bad night, and I'm happy to sell them both.
Start with the pitchers, since that's what this price is really about. Yamamoto's overall numbers are gorgeous, but they're not the numbers he puts up in this ballpark — he's been noticeably worse at home across ten starts, much better on the road, and the underlying stuff backs up the home version, not the pretty one. That's half a season telling you which guy shows up here. Now the rookie, Payton Tolle: his plain earned-run number looks worse, but underneath it he's actually been better than the ace by the measures that predict what comes next, with mid-nineties heat from the left side and a strikeout for nearly every inning. The market is paying top dollar for the résumé and getting a discount on the kid because his surface number looks ordinary. There's a real gap between these two tonight — just nowhere near as big as the one I'm being charged for.
I'll admit the honest part: Boston's lineup is banged up and cold. The leadoff man can't buy a hit, another guy can't square anything up, two more are in deep slumps. That's why they're the underdog. But look at the other side — two of their best bats aren't even playing tonight, one guy's in an ugly slump swinging through everything, another hasn't had a hit in five games, and another isn't hitting the ball hard at all. Both teams are short-handed. Only one of them got handed a big price bump for it. Then the late innings: Boston burned two arms last night but has its two best relievers rested and sharp, while the Dodgers dumped a full workload out of one arm, a chunk out of another, and lost a third to the injured list this morning. Boston also runs wild — nearly twice as many steals — and their catcher's been throwing runners out. I think this one's still tight in the seventh, and if it is, I want the underdog price and the better bullpen. Red Sox to win outright.
The full analysis
Saturday night at Chavez Ravine, the two-time champs coming off a nine-spot dropped on them in their own yard, and the best arm on the property takes the ball to stop the bleeding. That's the broadcast. Here's the part that actually interests me: this game was Los Angeles -156 before the sun came up and it's -181 now. Twenty-five cents in one day. Willson Contreras took a 95-mph fastball off the helmet Friday, he's in protocol, he's off the card — that's fresh, that's real, and that's worth something. It is not worth twenty-five cents. When a number runs that far past its news, the extra distance is reputation and recency, and both of those are things I'm happy to sell.
Start with the arms, because that's what the price says this game is about. Yamamoto's 2.72 is a beautiful number and it isn't the number that shows up in this building — he's 3.27 at Dodger Stadium across ten starts and sixty-three innings, 2.17 everywhere else, and his expected mark of 3.19 sits right on top of the home figure, not the shiny one. That's not a slump, that's half a season of evidence about which version pitches here. Now the kid: Payton Tolle carries a 3.32, but underneath it is a 2.91 expected ERA and a .266 opponent xwOBA — better than the ace's on both counts — with 96 from the left side and 103 punchouts in 95 innings. The market is paying full freight for a Cy Young résumé and buying a rookie's ERA card at a discount. The gap between these two tonight is real but it is nothing like the gap I'm being charged for.
I'll be honest about what I'm buying: this Boston lineup is thin. Seigler is 1-for-14 on the week hitting leadoff, Abreu can't find a barrel, Duran has a .506 OPS over fifteen days, Wong is at .148. That's the reason it's a dog. But look across the diamond — no Betts on this card, no Tucker either, Muncy is 2-for-20 with a 42 percent whiff rate, Rojas is hitless in his last five, Teoscar's average exit velocity is under 83. Both dugouts sent out something less than their best, and only one of them got a 25-cent gift for it. Then the ninth inning: Boston used two arms last night and has Chapman at 1.72 and Whitlock at 2.02 sitting fully rested, while Los Angeles emptied 102 pitches out of Irvin, 39 out of Klein, and put Stewart on the shelf this morning. Boston runs — 81 bags to 44 — and Rushing has thrown out ten of thirty. This one gets to the seventh inning tight, and if it does, I want the plus money and the better bullpen. Red Sox moneyline at +149.
Props on this game
2Payton TolleOVER 5.5 Strikeouts Strikeouts+116
WActual 7
Tolle's on a workload leash as a rookie, but nobody's put a leash on his swing-and-miss stuff. He's gone over 5.5 strikeouts in six of his last eight turns, and it hasn't depended on length — 7 strikeouts in just 3.2 innings against the Mets, 5 in 3 innings against Washington the start before that.
The cutter and curveball get whiffs even on nights his pitch count runs short. This Dodgers lineup will chase, and Tolle doesn't need six innings to get to six punchouts.
I like the number and I like the price.
Shohei OhtaniOVER 1.5 Total Bases Total Bases+109
LActual 1
Ohtani's been the best hitter in this series — two homers and a .381 average over his last seven games — and tonight he draws a lefty he's never faced who has an actual problem with left-handed bats. Tolle's been more hittable by lefties than righties all season; the slugging gap against him from that side is real.
It's a warm, clear night at Dodger Stadium with the wind blowing out to center, none of the marine layer that usually knocks fly balls down there. Ohtani's swing is hot at the same time the matchup and the conditions line up for him.
This only needs one extra-base hit or a two-hit night, and I'm getting plus money for it.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.
Download on the App Store