Diamondbacks at Guardians
O/U 8.5 · RL Guardians -1.5
Arizona Diamondbacks ML+120
CONF 62%
WCashedFinal 4-1
The read
Deadline day in Cleveland, first pitch a little after seven, and the flags at the ballpark are blowing straight in from center — that means fly balls die out there tonight. The Guardians just got home from a road trip that almost sank them. They lost six of seven through Tampa and Cincinnati, got shut out three times in the middle of it, and only saved face by winning the rubber game against the Reds on Wednesday. Arizona shows up having won two in a row in Pittsburgh, winners of six of their last ten, with a lineup that's been hanging big innings on people. The betting market looked at the two starting pitchers, made Cleveland a pretty heavy favorite, and then pushed that price even further in Cleveland's direction as the morning went on. I'm going the other way.
I'm not going to pretend Mitch Bratt is good — his run prevention has been ugly and he puts way too many guys on base, and Tanner Bibee is the real, established starter here. But here's the thing: the way you beat Bratt is by hitting the ball over the fence. He's given up a bunch of homers in very few innings, he lives in the air, and hitters square him up a lot. Tonight he faces a Cleveland team that barely homers, does its damage on the ground and with its legs, and has to play in a wind that knocks balls down in center. Cleveland's way to score is stringing hits together with runners on — and that's exactly the thing this offense can't do. They're hitting for a low average, scoring barely three and a half runs a night over the last two weeks, and their two most important spots with men in scoring position have been close to automatic outs. Five of the nine guys in tonight's lineup are ice cold: Ángel Martínez and David Fry are both in the middle of long hitless stretches, and Hoskins has barely scratched out a hit in a couple weeks. And Bibee isn't the wall his numbers suggest — most of his pitches are getting hit hard, he's allowing loud contact at a heavy clip, and the underlying stuff says he should be giving up meaningfully more runs than he has. Carroll has already handled him, with hits in half his career at-bats against him.
Arizona is just the better offense right now, and it's not close — they're scoring nearly six a game over the past two weeks to Cleveland's three and a half. Carroll is absolutely crushing the ball, hitting it hard and squaring it up over and over, and his batting average simply hasn't caught up to how well he's hitting. Moreno is scorching with a pile of runs driven in over the last two weeks. Kepler, Waldschmidt and Del Castillo are all swinging it too. And the thing that was actively costing this team games got fixed two days ago: Sewald is out of the closer's role, and Lovullo is now mixing and matching late with García, Morillo, Loaisiga and Clarke — all four of them have been excellent. Both bullpens had yesterday off, so nobody's gassed. I'm getting paid a plus price to take the team playing better baseball, with the hotter bats, against a beatable starter, on a night when the wind erases the one thing that could actually hurt me. Give me the Diamondbacks to win.
The full analysis
Deadline day in Cleveland, 7:10 at Progressive, and the flags are pointing straight in from center. The Guardians come home off a road trip that nearly buried them — 1-6 through Tampa and into Cincinnati with three shutouts in the middle of it — and salvaged the whole thing with an Ohio Cup rubber match on Wednesday. Arizona rolls in having won two straight in Pittsburgh, 6-4 over the last ten, and riding a lineup that's been putting up crooked numbers. The market took one look at the starting pitchers, made Cleveland a solid chalk, and then pushed the number further their way as the morning went on. I'm going the other direction.
Mitch Bratt has a 6.32 and a WHIP near two, and Tanner Bibee is the established arm — I'm not pretending otherwise. But look at what actually beats Bratt: the ball leaving the yard. Four home runs in fifteen and two-thirds, a heavy flyball tilt, barrels north of nine percent. Tonight he draws a Cleveland club that hits under a homer a game, gets its damage on the ground and on the bases, and has to play in a wind knocking everything down in center. The Guardians' path to runs is stringing knocks together with men on, and that is precisely the thing this offense cannot do — .230 as a team, 3.6 runs a night over two weeks, Ramírez hitting .200 with runners in scoring position, Hedges .154. Five of the nine on tonight's card are stuck: Ángel Martínez hasn't had a hit in fifteen at-bats, David Fry in thirteen, Hoskins is 3-for-23. And Bibee isn't the wall his ERA implies. Three of his five pitches sit above a .350 expected wOBA, he's surrendering forty percent hard contact, and the underlying number says closer to four and a half. Carroll has already gotten to him — three hits in six career tries.
Arizona is the better offense right now and it isn't close: 5.8 runs a game over the last two weeks against Cleveland's 3.6. Carroll is averaging 95-plus off the bat with four barrels in his last two dozen batted balls and the average simply hasn't caught up. Moreno is at .340 with thirteen driven in over fifteen days. Kepler, Waldschmidt and Del Castillo are all swinging it. And the thing that was actively costing this team games got fixed two days ago — Sewald is out of the ninth, and Lovullo is running matchups back there with García, Morillo, Loaisiga and Clarke, every one of them carrying an ERA in the twos. Both pens had yesterday off, so nobody's running on fumes. I'm being paid plus money on the club playing the better baseball, with the hotter bats, against a beatable starter, on a night when the wind takes the opposing rookie's one fatal flaw off the table. Give me the Diamondbacks on the moneyline.
Props on this game
5Ryan WaldschmidtOVER 0.5 Hits Hits-125
Not yet graded
Waldschmidt's at .379 with a .987 OPS over his last 15 games, and the week before tonight has been even louder — 6-for-11. That's a hitter already locked in walking into a soft matchup: a right-handed bat against a left-hander in Bratt, who's letting right-handed hitters hit .279 with an .891 OPS off him this year.
His whiff rate the last two weeks sits at 17 percent and he's chasing at 25 percent, both perfectly normal numbers for a guy squaring the ball up the way he has been. Bratt's fastball sits 91-and-a-half and is getting hit at a .333 clip, his sinker's at .375 against, and there's no real swing-and-miss weapon in the arsenal outside the slurve.
I don't need Waldschmidt to do anything more than keep doing what he's already doing.
Steven KwanOVER 0.5 Hits Hits-195
Not yet graded
Kwan doesn't chase and he doesn't miss — 17 percent whiff, 17 percent chase over his last two weeks, and those are skills that travel from game to game. He's got a hit in 13 of his last 15 and he's hitting .391 in that stretch. Put a contact bat like that in front of a rookie left-hander who's getting hit at a .333 clip on the fastball and .375 on the sinker, with almost nothing in the arsenal that misses bats, and the short price is short for a reason. This is the floor play of the night.
Gabriel MorenoOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+850
LActual 0
Moreno's been the best bat on either roster for two weeks running, and it isn't an empty .950 OPS — the underlying contact backs it up, and by the expected numbers there's still a little more slug owed to him, not less. He hits right-handers well over the course of a season, and his power hasn't dropped off on the road the way it should worry me tonight as the visiting bat. Bibee's sinker is one of the pitches hitters have done the most with against him this year, and it's a pitch Moreno already squares up. I don't need a new version of him to show up — just the one that's already been running hot for two weeks.
Chase DeLauterOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+650
LActual 0
Bratt hasn't figured out how to keep two of his most-used pitches in the yard — his fastball and his slider have both gotten hit hard all season, and between them that's over half of everything he throws. DeLauter is one of the rare left-handed bats who's actually better against left-handed pitching, and his numbers against both a fastball and a slider specifically are loud — real slugging, not just empty contact. His exit velocity the last couple weeks has been sharper than his batting average lets on, so the swing is in a good place even with the average still catching up. When the way a rookie pitcher is getting hit lines up this cleanly with what the hitter already does well, that's the kind of night I want a piece of.
Corbin CarrollOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+500
LActual 0
Carroll's contact quality the last two weeks is the loudest on this whole board — exit velocity up, barrels up, the kind of contact that turns into homers whether the batting average has caught up yet or not. He's got a real power track record against right-handed pitching for his career, and in a small sample against Bibee specifically he's hitting .500 with three hits in six career at-bats. The one mark against it is that his power at home has been noticeably better than his power on the road this year, and tonight he's the visitor. I'm still in — recent contact like this is loud enough that I think it travels.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.
Download on the App Store