MLB · Thu, Jul 30 · 7:10 PM

Pirates at Reds

O/U 9.5 · RL Pirates -1.5

GARY'S PICK

MLB@ Reds· -121

Deadline week on the banks of the Ohio, and these two clubs are passing each other in the hallway — Pittsburgh shopping for bullpen help to chase a wild card that fell two games out of reach Wednesday, Cincinnati quietly taking calls on anybody with an expiring contract. The Pirates arrive at Great American Ball Park off a shutout loss and hand the ball to an opener; the Reds counter with Rhett Lowder, a young righty who's spent the whole summer searching for it. This one comes down to the oldest question in the sport: who's pitching, and who has to hit him. Lowder has been hit, and hit hard — a 5.61 ERA hiding no bad luck behind it, a WHIP north of 1.50, and left-handed bats have treated him like a batting-practice arm at .271 with an .850 OPS against. Pittsburgh's order leans left exactly where it matters — Brandon Lowe, Bryan Reynolds, Ryan O'Hearn — in a park where a well-struck ball to right field doesn't ask permission. The bullpen day worries me less than it should: Yohan Ramírez has been Pittsburgh's quiet weapon all season, 96 with sink and almost nothing squared up against him, and the pen behind him is rested after Carmen Mlodzinski ate three full innings Wednesday. Cincinnati's relief corps is the group running on fumes — they've been shuffling arms all week, and Lowder is averaging under five innings a start. Somebody in that room has to cover the back half of this game, and I don't love the candidates. The honest caveat is Pittsburgh's bats: shut out Wednesday, Oneil Cruz still not back in the lineup, and three-and-change a night has been the recent norm. But this team has owned this matchup — six of nine from Cincinnati this season, most of them comfortably — and the Reds are hitting .229 with a losing record in their own building. When I line up the arms each side will actually use tonight, the ledger tilts toward the road team at a price that barely asks me to lay anything. Give me the Pirates at -121 and let Lowder's traffic — that nightly parade of baserunners — do what it's done all year.

This one comes down to the oldest question in the sport: who's pitching, and who has to hit him. Lowder has been hit, and hit hard — a 5.61 ERA hiding no bad luck behind it, a WHIP north of 1.50, and left-handed bats have treated him like a batting-practice arm at .271 with an .850 OPS against. Pittsburgh's order leans left exactly where it matters — Brandon Lowe, Bryan Reynolds, Ryan O'Hearn — in a park where a well-struck ball to right field doesn't ask permission. The bullpen day worries me less than it should: Yohan Ramírez has been Pittsburgh's quiet weapon all season, 96 with sink and almost nothing squared up against him, and the pen behind him is rested after Carmen Mlodzinski ate three full innings Wednesday. Cincinnati's relief corps is the group running on fumes — they've been shuffling arms all week, and Lowder is averaging under five innings a start. Somebody in that room has to cover the back half of this game, and I don't love the candidates.

The honest caveat is Pittsburgh's bats: shut out Wednesday, Oneil Cruz still not back in the lineup, and three-and-change a night has been the recent norm. But this team has owned this matchup — six of nine from Cincinnati this season, most of them comfortably — and the Reds are hitting .229 with a losing record in their own building. When I line up the arms each side will actually use tonight, the ledger tilts toward the road team at a price that barely asks me to lay anything. Give me the Pirates at -121 and let Lowder's traffic — that nightly parade of baserunners — do what it's done all year.

The pick & result

Published pick: Pirates ML -121
Published odds: -121
Result: Lost
Final score: 2-3

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The read

**Gary's Take**

It's trade season, and these two teams are headed in opposite directions. Pittsburgh is still trying to add pieces and chase a playoff spot, even after falling a bit further out of the race Wednesday. Cincinnati is quietly looking to sell. The Pirates roll into Cincinnati coming off a game where they didn't score at all, and they're not even starting a normal starting pitcher — they're using a reliever to open the game. The Reds are starting Rhett Lowder, a young pitcher who's struggled all summer.

This game comes down to who's pitching and who has to hit him. Lowder has been getting hit hard all year — lots of runs allowed, lots of baserunners, and no excuses to hide behind. Left-handed hitters especially have crushed him, and Pittsburgh's lineup happens to be loaded with lefties in the right spots — Brandon Lowe, Bryan Reynolds, Ryan O'Hearn — in a ballpark where fly balls to right field leave in a hurry. And I'm not that worried about Pittsburgh's patchwork pitching plan. Yohan Ramírez has quietly been one of their best relievers all year — he throws hard and hitters just can't square him up — and the rest of the bullpen is fresh because Carmen Mlodzinski covered a big chunk of Wednesday's game. It's Cincinnati's bullpen that's worn out. They've been juggling arms all week, and Lowder rarely pitches deep into games, so somebody tired is going to have to finish this one. I don't like their options.

The honest concern is Pittsburgh's offense — they just got shut out, Oneil Cruz is still out of the lineup, and they haven't been scoring much lately. But they've beaten Cincinnati six times in nine tries this year, most of them convincingly, and the Reds have been a bad-hitting team with a losing record in their own park. When I compare the pitchers each side is actually using tonight, it favors Pittsburgh — and I barely have to risk anything extra to bet them. Give me the Pirates and let all those baserunners Lowder keeps allowing do the rest.

The full analysis

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

PLATOON EDGE

Brandon Lowe (bats L) draws Rhett Lowder (RHP), batting 2nd
.889
Brandon Lowe's platoon gap is real — .889 OPS against righties, .613 against lefties — and he's hitting 2nd against right-hander Rhett Lowder tonight.

HEAT CHECK

Tyler Stephenson: 1.042 OPS in Last 15 Days
1.042
Tyler Stephenson's last 15 days have produced a 1.042 OPS against a .722 mark for the year, a big jump. Eight homers on the season, and tonight's total-bases number is set at just 1.5.

COOLING OFF

Bryan Reynolds: .569 OPS in L15 — draws RHP Rhett Lowder
.569
Bryan Reynolds has cooled to a .569 OPS over his last 15 days from an .842 season mark. He still draws right-hander Rhett Lowder tonight — technically his weaker side, even though it's a .829 OPS clip.

BULLPEN

Cincinnati Reds pen: 16 relief IP over their last 3 games
16 IP
Reds pen has worked 16 innings over the last three games, and three of the six arms used most — Garcia, Petty and Johnson — have all pitched both of the last two days. Antone and Burke are about the only fresh legs left down there, which puts real weight on the Reds starter to get through the lineup more than once tonight.
Pittsburgh Pirates pen: 15.7 relief IP over their last 3 games
15.7 IP
Pirates pen has thrown 15.7 innings over three games, but nobody's actually worked both of the last two days. Marinaccio and Soto have the multiple appearances — Soto's needed 45 pitches to get through just two innings, so he's been grinding rather than cruising. Next to the Reds pen across the diamond, Pittsburgh looks like the fresher group tonight.

FIRST INNING

PIT have gone quiet in the 1st: runs in 0 of their last 10
0/10
Pittsburgh hasn't scored in the first inning in any of their last 10 games, but the pitcher on the mound for Cincinnati has had his own first-inning issues — Rhett Lowder's sitting on a 6.60 ERA and .303 average against in that frame this season.

RUNNING GAME

Green light: Cincinnati Reds run, and Endy Rodriguez has caught just 11%
11% CS
Endy Rodriguez has caught just four of 30 basestealers this season, and Cincinnati's already swiped 79 bags as a team. This is as green as a green light gets — I'd expect the Reds to run early and often.

BALLPARK

Rhett Lowder's ERA drops to 3.09 at Great American Ball Park
3.09
Rhett Lowder is a different pitcher at home — 3.09 ERA across 8 games at Great American Ball Park against 7.71 everywhere else, with hitters down to .235 there. He gets to work in front of that split again tonight.

HEAD-TO-HEAD

Pirates are 6-3 vs Reds this season
6-3
Pirates are 6-3 against the Reds this season and beat them 9-4 the last time out.

REPLACEMENT

Oneil Cruz (CF) is out for PIT — Jhostynxon Garcia starts in his place tonight
.436
Oneil Cruz is out with a hand issue, so Jhostynxon Garcia gets the start in center tonight, batting ninth with just a .436 OPS on the year. This is a lineup downgrade, not an opportunity.

SITUATIONAL

CIN's pen has logged 16 innings across its last 3 games
16
3 games, 16 innings out of the pen — Jose Franco (3.7) and Julian Garcia (3) carried the load. PIT's pen has thrown 15.7 over the same span.

TEAM RECORD

Reds 2-6 in Rhett Lowder's last 8 starts
2-6
Rhett Lowder starts for Cincinnati tonight, and the Reds are 2-6 in his last eight turns through the rotation.

REGRESSION

Esmerlyn Valdez: .278 AVG vs .226 xBA
.226
Esmerlyn Valdez is hitting .278 against a .226 expected average, and his wOBA (.435) is running well ahead of his expected number (.370) too. The results are outrunning the underlying contact right now.
Jake Mangum: .302 AVG vs .259 xBA
.259
Jake Mangum's .302 average is running ahead of a .259 expected mark, and his wOBA tells the same story. Results ahead of the process.

FANTASY PICKUPS

Bryan Reynolds
.842 OPS
Pickup vs Rhett Lowder (5.61 xERA) — .842 OPS, bats 3rd.
Ryan O'Hearn
.798 OPS
Pickup vs Rhett Lowder (5.61 xERA) — .798 OPS, bats 5th.
Brandon Lowe
.805 OPS
Pickup vs Rhett Lowder (5.61 xERA) — .805 OPS, bats 2nd.
Nick Gonzales
.778 OPS
Pickup vs Rhett Lowder (5.61 xERA) — .778 OPS, bats 6th.

CUT LIST

Rhett Lowder
5.62 xERA
Starts tonight for CIN — 5.62 xERA behind a 5.61 ERA.

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it: Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data: Daily picks first stored July 30, 2026 at 10:45 AM ET.
Odds record: The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: fanduel, draftkings, caesars, betmgm, betrivers, fanatics.
Accountability: Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Props on this game

GARY'S PICK
NICK GONZALESTOTAL BASES OVER 1.5
MLBPittsburgh Pirates· +120
✓ CASHED · ACTUAL 3
Gonzales is hitting .358 over his last fifteen games, and the swing-and-miss numbers back it up — his whiff rate this past week is down to 14 percent, so he's not just getting lucky, he's actually squaring the ball up. He's cleared two total bases in nine of his last fifteen games. On the mound for Cincinnati is Rhett Lowder, sitting on a 5.61 ERA and letting hitters hit the ball hard 40 percent of the time this year, and behind him tonight the Reds are reportedly down to four bullpen arms, two of them left-handed — a short-staffed pen for Pittsburgh's bats to work against late. Great American Ball Park turns loud contact into extra bases as easily as any park in the league. I like Gonzales to get there tonight.
Nick Gonzales
Total Bases over 1.5
+120 · CASHED · ACTUAL 3
Pittsburgh Pirates
Gonzales is hitting .358 over his last fifteen games, and the swing-and-miss numbers back it up — his whiff rate this past week is down to 14 percent, so he's not just getting lucky, he's actually squaring the ball up. He's cleared two total bases in nine of his last fifteen games.
On the mound for Cincinnati is Rhett Lowder, sitting on a 5.61 ERA and letting hitters hit the ball hard 40 percent of the time this year, and behind him tonight the Reds are reportedly down to four bullpen arms, two of them left-handed — a short-staffed pen for Pittsburgh's bats to work against late. Great American Ball Park turns loud contact into extra bases as easily as any park in the league.
I like Gonzales to get there tonight.
GARY'S PICK
ESMERLYN VALDEZTOTAL BASES OVER 1.5
MLBPittsburgh Pirates· +125
✓ CASHED · ACTUAL 2
Valdez is in the cleanup spot tonight, so whatever soreness came from getting hit by a pitch over the weekend clearly isn't keeping him out. He's got four home runs in his last fifteen games, and with runners in scoring position this year he's hitting .382 with a 1.359 OPS — a completely different hitter in those spots. He's cleared this total bases number in nine of his last fifteen games. Lowder's been letting hitters hit the ball hard at a 40 percent clip this season, and this park is one of the easier ones in baseball to turn a well-struck ball into extra bases. I like Valdez to get to two total bases tonight.
Esmerlyn Valdez
Total Bases over 1.5
+125 · CASHED · ACTUAL 2
Pittsburgh Pirates
Valdez is in the cleanup spot tonight, so whatever soreness came from getting hit by a pitch over the weekend clearly isn't keeping him out. He's got four home runs in his last fifteen games, and with runners in scoring position this year he's hitting .382 with a 1.359 OPS — a completely different hitter in those spots.
He's cleared this total bases number in nine of his last fifteen games. Lowder's been letting hitters hit the ball hard at a 40 percent clip this season, and this park is one of the easier ones in baseball to turn a well-struck ball into extra bases.
I like Valdez to get to two total bases tonight.
THE LONG SHOT
ESMERLYN VALDEZHR OVER 0.5
MLBPittsburgh Pirates· +460
LOST · ACTUAL 0
Valdez has gone deep six times in his last fifteen games, the hottest home run rate on this whole board, and it isn't cheap contact — he's slugging over .850 against sinkers and over 1.000 against sliders this season. Rhett Lowder throws his sinker more than any other pitch, close to a third of the time, and it's been the most hittable pitch in his arsenal all year. Put a hitter who does his best power damage on sinkers in the box against a pitcher who can't get his sinker to behave, in a park that turns fly balls into home runs, and I like the shape of this one. He hits for power from both sides of the plate, so the same-handed matchup doesn't concern me.
Esmerlyn Valdez
HR over 0.5
+460 · LOST · ACTUAL 0
Pittsburgh Pirates
Valdez has gone deep six times in his last fifteen games, the hottest home run rate on this whole board, and it isn't cheap contact — he's slugging over .850 against sinkers and over 1.000 against sliders this season. Rhett Lowder throws his sinker more than any other pitch, close to a third of the time, and it's been the most hittable pitch in his arsenal all year. Put a hitter who does his best power damage on sinkers in the box against a pitcher who can't get his sinker to behave, in a park that turns fly balls into home runs, and I like the shape of this one. He hits for power from both sides of the plate, so the same-handed matchup doesn't concern me.
THE LONG SHOT
ELLY DE LA CRUZHR OVER 0.5
MLBCincinnati Reds· +500
LOST · ACTUAL 0
De La Cruz is squaring the ball up as well as anyone in either lineup tonight — his recent exit velocity readings are the loudest on the board, and he's already put three balls out in his last fifteen games. He's a switch-hitter with real power from both sides, and tonight he draws a reliever making his first career start after more than two hundred relief appearances, throwing a fastball-sinker-changeup mix that lines up with three of the four pitch types he's done the most damage against this season. He's also been a considerably better hitter at home and at night than on the road or during the day, and both of those apply tonight. I want his bat in this park against an unproven arm.
Elly De La Cruz
HR over 0.5
+500 · LOST · ACTUAL 0
Cincinnati Reds
De La Cruz is squaring the ball up as well as anyone in either lineup tonight — his recent exit velocity readings are the loudest on the board, and he's already put three balls out in his last fifteen games. He's a switch-hitter with real power from both sides, and tonight he draws a reliever making his first career start after more than two hundred relief appearances, throwing a fastball-sinker-changeup mix that lines up with three of the four pitch types he's done the most damage against this season. He's also been a considerably better hitter at home and at night than on the road or during the day, and both of those apply tonight. I want his bat in this park against an unproven arm.
THE LONG SHOT
JJ BLEDAYHR OVER 0.5
MLBCincinnati Reds· +480
LOST · ACTUAL 0
Bleday's batting average has been cold the last couple weeks, but the quality of contact says otherwise — a quarter of his balls in play over his last fifteen games have gone for barrels. His expected numbers against the four-seam fastball are running well ahead of what he's actually hit into this year, meaning the loud contact is there even when the results haven't shown it, and he's already hitting the sinker well on top of that. Those are the two pitches Ramírez leans on hardest tonight. Bleday also does his best work against right-handed pitching, and he's been a completely different hitter at home than on the road this year, nearly three hundred points of OPS better in this park. On top of all that, he's facing a pitcher who has never started a big-league game. I like this shape at this price.
JJ Bleday
HR over 0.5
+480 · LOST · ACTUAL 0
Cincinnati Reds
Bleday's batting average has been cold the last couple weeks, but the quality of contact says otherwise — a quarter of his balls in play over his last fifteen games have gone for barrels. His expected numbers against the four-seam fastball are running well ahead of what he's actually hit into this year, meaning the loud contact is there even when the results haven't shown it, and he's already hitting the sinker well on top of that.
Those are the two pitches Ramírez leans on hardest tonight. Bleday also does his best work against right-handed pitching, and he's been a completely different hitter at home than on the road this year, nearly three hundred points of OPS better in this park.
On top of all that, he's facing a pitcher who has never started a big-league game. I like this shape at this price.
THE LONG SHOT
SAL STEWARTHR OVER 0.5
MLBCincinnati Reds· +575
LOST · ACTUAL 0
Stewart is hitting .333 with a home run and five RBI over his last week, and his numbers against the exact pitches Ramírez leans on hardest tonight back it up — his four-seamer and sinker, both sitting in the mid-to-upper nineties, and Stewart is slugging well over .500 against each of them this season. He's also already hit the bulk of his home runs this year against right-handed pitching, which is exactly what he's getting from the opener tonight. Clean pitch-type fit on a bat that's swinging it well right now.
Sal Stewart
HR over 0.5
+575 · LOST · ACTUAL 0
Cincinnati Reds
Stewart is hitting .333 with a home run and five RBI over his last week, and his numbers against the exact pitches Ramírez leans on hardest tonight back it up — his four-seamer and sinker, both sitting in the mid-to-upper nineties, and Stewart is slugging well over .500 against each of them this season. He's also already hit the bulk of his home runs this year against right-handed pitching, which is exactly what he's getting from the opener tonight. Clean pitch-type fit on a bat that's swinging it well right now.
THE LONG SHOT
BRANDON LOWEHR OVER 0.5
MLBPittsburgh Pirates· +425
✓ CASHED · ACTUAL 1
Lowe is locked in right now, hitting close to .430 with a home run over his last week, and the exit velocity behind that stretch backs it up — he's not just getting lucky bloopers. He's a left-handed bat, and Rhett Lowder has had a real problem with lefties all season, allowing eight home runs to left-handed hitters compared to just one against righties. I don't need a personal history against Lowder to like this one — the pitcher's own split plus a hitter running hot is enough for me to want this shape at this price.
Brandon Lowe
HR over 0.5
+425 · CASHED · ACTUAL 1
Pittsburgh Pirates
Lowe is locked in right now, hitting close to .430 with a home run over his last week, and the exit velocity behind that stretch backs it up — he's not just getting lucky bloopers. He's a left-handed bat, and Rhett Lowder has had a real problem with lefties all season, allowing eight home runs to left-handed hitters compared to just one against righties. I don't need a personal history against Lowder to like this one — the pitcher's own split plus a hitter running hot is enough for me to want this shape at this price.

Every prop from this day is on the archive page.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every MLB game this day The MLB record Today's MLB picks Every sport this day