Guardians at Reds
O/U 9 · RL Guardians -1.5
Guardians ML-136
CONF 68%
WCashedFinal 6-1
The read
Summer twilight is settling in as Cleveland and Cincinnati play the deciding game of this series after yesterday's grueling doubleheader. Cincinnati sends Brady Singer to the mound, and while his recent overall results look impressive on the surface, he has a glaring weakness that fits Cleveland perfectly. Singer gets hit hard by left-handed batters and gives up a ton of power to them, so Cleveland is taking direct aim by filling their order with lefties and switch-hitters. On top of that, Jose Ramirez has completely dominated Singer over his career, and Kyle Manzardo has hit him with ease as well. Cleveland starter Joey Cantillo has struggled with his own pitch control, but Cincinnati's lineup remains thinned out without Spencer Steer and Matt McLain.
The biggest difference maker in this matchup is in the late-inning pitching. Cincinnati was forced to burn through their bullpen yesterday, using relief pitcher after relief pitcher across both games and losing Jose Franco to elbow discomfort in the process. Cleveland comes in with far more rested arms, boasting strong late-game options in Hunter Gaddis and Colin Holderman to bridge the gap to Cade Smith, who leads the major leagues in saves. I am backing Cleveland to use their matchup advantages and superior pitching depth to take the series finale.
The full analysis
Summer twilight settles over Great American Ball Park as the Guardians and Reds meet for the deciding rubber match of this three-game series following Tuesday’s doubleheader split. Cincinnati sends Brady Singer to the mound in what feels like a trade-deadline showcase, while Joey Cantillo takes the ball for a Cleveland team trying to cap off a grueling seven-game road trip. With the deadline just two days out and both clubs feeling the strain of yesterday's marathon, the stage is set for a tight getaway game under clear 80-degree skies in Cincinnati.
While Singer’s 2.77 ERA in July looks impressive on the surface, his underlying profile contains a glaring vulnerability that fits Cleveland's lineup like a glove. Singer has been hit hard by left-handed batters all season, surrendering a .864 OPS and 15 home runs to lefties. Cleveland’s card takes direct aim at that flaw, featuring seven left-handed or switch-hitting batters in the order. Jose Ramirez has completely dominated Singer over his career, hitting .414 with three homers in 29 at-bats, while Kyle Manzardo is 5-for-7 against him. Cantillo has had his own control issues, but Cincinnati's order remains thinned out without Spencer Steer and Matt McLain.
The defining separator in this matchup sits in the respective bullpens. Cincinnati was forced into a heavy relief day on Tuesday, cycling through nine bullpen appearances across both ends of the doubleheader and losing Jose Franco to right elbow discomfort in the process. Cleveland enters with a far more rested setup, boasting high-leverage weapons in Hunter Gaddis and Colin Holderman to bridge the gap to Cade Smith, who leads the majors with 30 saves. Back Cleveland's matchup advantages and superior depth to take the series finale.
Props on this game
5Brady SingerOVER 16.5 Pitcher Outs Pitcher Outs-101
LActual 13
Cincinnati's bullpen is completely spent. Yesterday they threw a bullpen game in Game 2 of a doubleheader, eating through five different relievers to complete the shutout.
On top of that, Jose Franco — their call-up who was supposed to eat innings — went down with an elbow injury. Singer has been dealing as he auditions for a trade deadline deal, going 6.2, 7.0, and 7.1 innings in his last three starts.
The Reds desperately need him to pitch deep into this one. At 5.2 innings to hit the over, getting this at near even money is a tremendous spot.
Jose RamirezOVER 1.5 Total Bases Total Bases+104
WActual 2
Some batters just see certain pitchers well, and Ramirez has Singer's number on speed dial. In 29 career at-bats against the righty, Ramirez has 12 hits, including three homers, good for a .414 average and a 1.334 OPS. While J-Ram's bat has been a little quiet this past week, a matchup against Singer in the hitter-friendly confines of Great American Ball Park is exactly what he needs to wake up. At plus money, I'm happily backing the history here.
Elly De La CruzOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+475
LActual 0
Cantillo's a different pitcher depending on who's standing in the box. He's given up a .774 OPS and ten home runs to right-handed hitters this year, against a .701 OPS and three homers to lefties — and De La Cruz swings right-handed against a left-hander, which puts him on the side of that split that's done the damage. It also happens to be his strong side regardless of who's pitching: 1.061 OPS with eight home runs in 95 at-bats against left-handed pitching this season.
He's the hottest bat in this lineup right now, thirteen hits in his last 44 at-bats with three homers, and the quality of contact backs it up — 93 mph average exit velocity and four barreled balls in his last eighteen batted balls. His expected slugging is actually a shade higher than what he's already produced, so the loud contact hasn't even fully cashed in yet. Cantillo's also been leaking oil his last two starts, nine earned runs combined.
Everything here points the same way.
Kyle ManzardoOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+320
WActual 1
Singer's platoon split is about as clean as you'll see on a given night — .864 OPS and fifteen home runs allowed to left-handed hitters this season, .715 OPS and six to righties. Manzardo hits left-handed, and he's a five-for-seven career hitter off Singer specifically. He put a grand slam into the seats last night, and it wasn't an accident — over his last ten balls in play he's averaging 95.9 mph off the bat with two barreled balls, both the best marks on this roster right now. This is the shortest price on the board tonight, so the market's clearly seeing the same shape, but the underlying swing quality is real enough that I still want a piece of it.
Eugenio SuarezOVER 0.5 Home Runs Home Runs+550
LActual 0
Suarez sat the nightcap yesterday and steps back into the middle of the order tonight, having gone deep in six of his last fifteen games. Cantillo has been a much different pitcher against right-handed bats than lefties all season — ten home runs allowed to righties against three to lefties, a real gap on a real number of at-bats.
He also leans on his fastball more than a third of the time, and it's been the pitch that's gotten him hit hardest all year, a .311 average and the highest expected damage of anything in his mix. A right-handed bat in the middle of a power stretch, facing a pitcher who throws his most hittable pitch most often and has already shown he's homer-prone to that side.
I like the shape of this one.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.
Download on the App Store