Skip to content
GARY A.I.Get the app
NFL · Thu, Oct 1 · 8:15 PM

Pittsburgh Steelers at Cleveland Browns

O/U 37.5 · SPREAD Pittsburgh Steelers -2.5 · Cleveland Browns Stadium

GARY'S PICK
Browns +2.5
NFLvs Steelers· -102

Browns
+2.5

-102 · CASHED · PIT 24 · CLE 27

Steelers

The pick & result

Published pick
Cleveland Browns +2.5 -102
Published odds
-102
Result
Won
Final score
24-27

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The line

BETMGM · 44 moves
MarketOpened
Sep 27 7:32 PM
Close
Oct 1 8:06 PM
Move
SPREADPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-112)Pittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)+½
TOTAL38 (-110)38 (-108)Price
MONEYLINEPittsburgh Steelers -145Pittsburgh Steelers -155−10
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENSep 27 7:32 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-112)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 27 7:42 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-112)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 27 8:23 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-112)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 27 8:53 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-110)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 27 10:23 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-110)38 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 28 6:00 AMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-112)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -140 · Cleveland Browns +115
Sep 28 1:46 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 2:16 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 4:47 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-118)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 5:15 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 5:25 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 5:35 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 6:45 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 7:15 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 28 7:25 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-118)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 29 7:30 AMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-118)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 29 10:01 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-105)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 29 1:04 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-105)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 29 6:08 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-115)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 29 8:09 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-105)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 30 10:31 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +120
Sep 30 11:32 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Sep 30 11:35 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-105)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 7:00 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-105)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 8:00 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 9:00 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 9:31 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 10:31 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 11:02 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 11:32 AMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)37.5 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 1:33 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+105)38 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 2:34 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 3:04 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)38 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 4:04 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+105)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 5:15 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 5:55 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+105)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 6:05 PMPittsburgh Steelers -2.5 (-125)38 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 6:35 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 6:45 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -145 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 6:55 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 7:05 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+105)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 7:26 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)38 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 7:45 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (+100)37.5 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -150 · Cleveland Browns +125
Oct 1 7:56 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38 (-110)Pittsburgh Steelers -155 · Cleveland Browns +130
CLOSEOct 1 8:06 PMPittsburgh Steelers -3 (-102)38 (-108)Pittsburgh Steelers -155 · Cleveland Browns +130

The read

My main reason is that Pittsburgh's offense has been the weakest unit in this game, and tonight it goes on the road against the kind of defense that already shut it down once. Over three games the Steelers rank 29th in EPA per play (-0.169, per DraftKings Network). Rodgers has a 42.4 QBR and averages 5.9 yards per attempt when throwing to wide receivers, which is last in the league. The only other road trip was a 3-20 loss at New England, where the team's own recap blamed pressure, fumbles and execution, and Freiermuth said New England's physical play was the problem. The 30-27 win over Cincinnati gets the most attention, but it had help: a roughing-the-punter penalty and a muffed punt kept Pittsburgh drives alive, and the game ended on a strip-sack, not on the offense running out the clock. Rodgers himself warned against reading too much into either game. Cleveland's defense is the bad matchup for an offense like this. It ranks 3rd in pressure rate and 4th in quick-pressure rate, and quick pressure is the thing that hurts a quick-release quarterback most. Mason Graham has 4 sacks on 5 charted pressures from the interior, and he faces a Pittsburgh right side that has started together once: rookie Max Iheanachor made his first start at right tackle last week, and Brock Hoffman moved to right guard. Pittsburgh's red-zone offense has also gone nowhere so far, at 0.65 yards per play on 17 snaps. That's a small sample, but it fits the rest of the picture.

Second, the price fits the game. The total is 37.5, and in a game this low, 2.5 points is worth a lot. I'm getting them on a home underdog in a division game at -102, while backing Pittsburgh costs -120. That -120 showed up Wednesday morning, before any of this week's injury news, and the spread never moved off 2.5. Cleveland's kicker is 6-for-6. Pittsburgh's is 6-for-8 and has missed twice from 50+. In a close, low-scoring game that could matter.

The strongest case against this pick is Cleveland's interior line, and I take it seriously. Center Elgton Jenkins played every snap in Week 3 and has been ruled out with a concussion. That news broke Wednesday night, so it's new information. Luke Wypler is expected to start at center next to rookie Austin Barber, on a short week, against a front that leads the league with an 11.8% sack rate when rushing four or fewer. Watt and Highsmith have 6.5 sacks between them. Cleveland can't run the ball well (0.6 yards before contact per carry), its offense throws short, and it has converted 3 of 19 third-and-7-or-longer chances. Watson also left last week's game briefly after a hit. On the other side, Jaylen Warren and the improving Pittsburgh run game face a run defense that ranks 22nd in DVOA and has allowed 13 explosive runs. Pittsburgh winning by exactly 3 is the result that beats me.

Still, both offenses face a line mismatch tonight, and Cleveland has been the better offense per play this season (-0.06 vs -0.169 EPA). In a game I expect to be ugly and decided late, I'd rather take the 2.5 points at home with the cheaper price than pay -120 for a road offense that has had one good game in three. Cleveland has also won its last two by finishing drives late. A note on availability: safety Grant Delpit (100% of snaps last week) and cornerback Tyson Campbell are questionable, and I couldn't confirm their game-day status, so I haven't assumed either one plays. That uncertainty is part of why this pick is small.

Injuries noted

Pittsburgh Steelers: Daequan Hardy (IR) — Undisclosed; Cole Burgess (IR) — Undisclosed; Donte Kent (PUP-R) — The Steelers placed Kent (undisclosed) on the reserve/PUP list Monday, Teresa Varley of the team's official site reports.; Logan Lee (IR) — ir; Jack Driscoll (IR-R) — The Steelers placed Driscoll (undisclosed) on injured reserve Monday with a designation to return, Teresa Varley of the team's official site reports.; DeShon Elliott (IR-R) — ir; Joey Porter Jr. (Out) — Porter (back) has been ruled out ahead of Thursday's game against the Browns, Brooke Pryor of ESPN.com reports.; Gennings Dunker (IR) — The Steelers placed Dunker (knee) on injured reserve Saturday, Tom Pelissero of Netflix reports.; Rico Dowdle (Out) — The Steelers ruled Dowdle (toe) out for Thursday's game in Cleveland, Brooke Pryor of ESPN.com reports.; Brandin Echols (Questionable) — Echols (concussion) is listed as questionable ahead of Thursday's game against the Browns, Alan Saunders of SteelersNow.com reported Wednesday.; Jalen Ramsey (Questionable) — Ramsey (wrist) is expected to play Thursday against the Browns, Jeremy Fowler of ESPN reports.; Yahya Black (Questionable) — The Steelers added Black to their injury report and list him as questionable for Thursday's game against the Browns due to a personal matter.

Cleveland Browns: Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah (PUP-R) — out; Kendrick Green (IR) — ir; Damarri Mathis (IR) — Undisclosed; Elijah Chatman (IR) — The Browns reverted Chatman (quadriceps) to IR on Monday, per the NFL's transaction log.; Kalia Davis (IR) — The Browns placed Davis on injured reserve Tuesday due to a quadriceps injury.; Dillon Gabriel (IR-R) — ir; Joe Royer (NFI-R) — The Browns placed Royer (personal) on the reserve/non-football illness list Sunday, Scott Petrak of the Elyria Chronicle-Telegram reports.; Edefuan Ulofoshio (IR) — Ulofoshio (biceps) reverted to the Browns' IR on Monday, per the NFL's transaction log.; Alex Wright (IR) — The Browns placed Wright on injured reserve Sunday due to a ruptured Achilles, Adam Schefter of ESPN reports.; Teven Jenkins (Out) — Jenkins (back) is officially listed as out for Thursday's game versus Pittsburgh.; Dylan Sampson (IR) — Sampson (knee) was placed on injured reserve Tuesday.; Elgton Jenkins (Out) — Jenkins (concussion) is officially listed as out for Thursday's game versus the Steelers.; Tyson Campbell (Questionable) — Campbell (knee) was estimated as a limited participant in Monday's practice, Adam Caplan of SiriusXM NFL Radio reports.; Grant Delpit (Questionable) — Delpit (shoulder) was estimated as a limited participant in Monday's practice, Adam Caplan of SiriusXM NFL Radio reports.; Tytus Howard (Questionable) — questionable; Tylan Wallace (Out) — Wallace (knee) has been ruled out for Thursday's game against the Steelers.

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Aaron Rodgers is the projected starting quarterback for PIT

    6.2 Y/A

    Through 3 games in 2026, Aaron Rodgers threw for 700 passing yards, completed 58.4% of his passes and averaged 6.2 yards per attempt. Last season over 16 games he threw for 3322 yards, completed 65.7% and averaged 6.67 yards per attempt, 24-7 touchdowns to interceptions. This season's 4-2 touchdown-to-interception line is 3 games in.

  • Deshaun Watson is the projected starting quarterback for CLE

    7.16 Y/A

    Through 3 games in 2026, Deshaun Watson threw for 587 passing yards, completed 68.3% of his passes and averaged 7.16 yards per attempt. His 5-1 touchdown-to-interception line rounds out the current sample without turning an early-season profile into a settled one.

TRENCHES

  • PIT: 4.27 yards per rush attempt to CLE's 3.43

    0.83 Y/C

    Pittsburgh runs for 4.27 a carry over 3 games, almost exactly its 4.26 from last season, so that number looks real. Cleveland is at 3.43, down from 3.9, which is a 3-game dip that could bounce back some. The Steelers look like the team that can lean on the ground game and control the tempo, while the Browns may get pushed toward passing on schedule.

PASS RUSH

  • CLE: 17.3 sack yards lost per game to PIT's 25.7

    8.3 YDS

    PIT is at 25.7 sack yards lost per game over 3 games; CLE is at 17.3 over 3 games. Those are this season's games through Sep 30. Last season PIT was at 14.8 over 17 games and CLE at 20.3 over 17 games.

PACE & SCRIPT

  • PIT @ CLE carries a 38.5 market total

    38.5

    At 38.5, this game sits 7 points under the 45.5 slate median, so the market expects a slow game settled by field goals and a couple of long drives. The sheet gives no injury, pace or scoring history, so the number is the only evidence. For that low total to crack, one side needs short fields from turnovers or a defensive score. A bettor can ask how many points one extra touchdown moves this game, since 7 points is the whole gap to the median.

  • PIT: 63.3 offensive plays per game to CLE's 55.7

    7.7 PLAYS

    PIT is at 63.3 offensive plays per game over 3 games; CLE is at 55.7 over 3 games. Those are this season's games through Sep 30. Last season PIT was at 58.1 over 17 games and CLE at 60.6 over 17 games.

  • PIT: 20 points allowed per game to CLE's 23.7

    3.7 PPG

    PIT is at 20 points allowed per game over 3 games; CLE is at 23.7 over 3 games. Those are this season's games through Sep 30. Last season PIT was at 22.8 over 17 games and CLE at 22.3 over 17 games.

TURNOVERS

  • PIT: 2 takeaways per game to CLE's 0.67

    1.33 TO

    Pittsburgh is forcing 2 takeaways a game, Cleveland 0.67, over three games each. Takeaways are among the most random stats week to week, so both numbers are likely to move toward the middle. For PIT @ CLE, the gap favors Pittsburgh in turnover margin, but it's a thin edge to lean on alone.

RED ZONE

  • PIT: 33.3% red-zone scoring allowed to CLE's 44.4%

    11.1 PP

    PIT is at 33.3% red-zone scoring allowed over 3 games; CLE is at 44.4% over 3 games. Those are what each defense has allowed in this season's games through Sep 30.

COVERAGE

  • PIT: 192.7 passing yards allowed per game to CLE's 224

    31.3 YPG

    Pittsburgh allows 192.7 passing yards a game over three games, Cleveland allows 224. Passing totals depend on which quarterbacks a defense faced and how often opponents had to throw from behind, so three games leaves a lot to schedule. Pittsburgh's pass defense has held up better so far, and Cleveland's coverage looks like the more attackable side in this game.

  • PIT: 33.3% third downs allowed to CLE's 39%

    5.7 PP

    Pittsburgh holds opponents to 33.3% on third down over three games, Cleveland allows 39%. Both are solid marks, and three games is a short sample that rides on the offences faced. Pittsburgh has been the better unit at getting off the field, which points toward shorter drives for Cleveland's offence in this game.

HEAD-TO-HEAD

  • PIT and CLE are even since 2025

    1-1 SERIES

    Both meetings last season were low-scoring and the home team won each time: Pittsburgh beat Cleveland 23-9 in October, then managed only 6 points in a 13-6 loss in Cleveland on Dec 28. That is two games, so it says more about how these defenses travel than about either offense. Cleveland held Pittsburgh to 6 at home last time, and this one is in Cleveland, so a grinding, low-total game is the shape these meetings have taken.

REPLACEMENT

  • Drew Allar (QB) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    Allar is inactive by coach's decision for Thursday's game at Cleveland, with no injury involved. He will not play, so he has no effect on this game's numbers.

  • Will Howard (QB) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    Howard is inactive by coach's decision for Thursday at Cleveland, with no injury involved. He is Pittsburgh's emergency quarterback, so he only sees the field if the starter and backup both go down.

  • Taylen Green (QB) is inactive for CLE

    INACTIVE

    Green is inactive by coach's decision for Thursday against the Steelers, with no injury involved. He is Cleveland's emergency quarterback, so he only plays if both quarterbacks ahead of him go down.

  • Brandin Echols (CB) is questionable for PIT

    QUESTIONABLE

    Pittsburgh cornerback Brandin Echols is questionable for Thursday at Cleveland with a concussion. A concussion requires clearing the league protocol, and the short week gives him little time. If he sits, the Steelers need another corner in coverage, though the sheet does not name one.

  • Jamel Dean (CB) is questionable for PIT

    QUESTIONABLE

    Dean (ankle) has been ruled out from returning to Thursday's matchup versus Cleveland, Ray Fittipaldo of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reports. Reported Oct 2.

  • Yahya Black (DE) is questionable for PIT

    QUESTIONABLE

    The Steelers added Black to their injury report and list him as questionable for Thursday's game against the Browns due to a personal matter. Reported Oct 1.

  • Tyson Campbell (CB) is questionable for CLE

    QUESTIONABLE

    Campbell (knee) was estimated as a limited participant in Monday's practice, Adam Caplan of SiriusXM NFL Radio reports. Reported Sep 29.

  • Jalen Ramsey (CB) is questionable for PIT

    QUESTIONABLE

    Ramsey has a wrist injury and remains listed as questionable, but is expected to play Thursday against the Browns. That makes questionable here mostly a formality. Bettors can plan on Ramsey being in the Pittsburgh secondary unless the news changes.

  • Mason Graham (DT) is questionable for CLE

    QUESTIONABLE

    Graham (knee) has been ruled out for the remainder of Thursday's Week 4 matchup versus Pittsburgh, Chris Easterling of the Akron Beacon Journal reports. Reported Oct 2.

  • Derrick Harmon (DT) is questionable for PIT

    QUESTIONABLE

    Harmon (foot) has been ruled out from returning to Thursday's clash versus Cleveland, Nick Farabaugh of PennLive.com reports. Reported Oct 2.

  • Grant Delpit (S) is questionable for CLE

    QUESTIONABLE

    Delpit (shoulder) was estimated as a limited participant in Monday's practice, Adam Caplan of SiriusXM NFL Radio reports. Reported Sep 29.

  • Tylan Wallace (WR) is inactive for CLE

    INACTIVE

    Wallace (knee) has been ruled out for Thursday's game against the Steelers. Reported Sep 30.

  • Tytus Howard (OT) is questionable for CLE

    QUESTIONABLE

    CLE lists Tytus Howard as questionable on the injury report. Reported Sep 28.

  • Elgton Jenkins (C) is inactive for CLE

    INACTIVE

    Jenkins (concussion) is officially listed as out for Thursday's game versus the Steelers. Reported Oct 1.

  • Rico Dowdle (RB) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    PIT lists Rico Dowdle as inactive on the injury report. Reported Oct 1.

  • Eli Heidenreich (RB) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    PIT lists Eli Heidenreich as inactive on the injury report. Reported Oct 1.

  • Teven Jenkins (G) is inactive for CLE

    INACTIVE

    Jenkins (back) is officially listed as out for Thursday's game versus Pittsburgh. Reported Oct 1.

  • Gabriel Rubio (DE) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    PIT lists Gabriel Rubio as inactive on the injury report. Reported Oct 1.

  • Gennings Dunker (G) is on injured reserve for PIT

    IR

    The Steelers placed Dunker (knee) on injured reserve Saturday, Tom Pelissero of Netflix reports. Reported Sep 26.

  • Justin Jefferson (LB) is inactive for CLE

    INACTIVE

    CLE lists Justin Jefferson as inactive on the injury report. Reported Oct 1.

  • Kevin Jobity Jr. (DT) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    PIT lists Kevin Jobity Jr. as inactive on the injury report. Reported Oct 1.

PRACTICE REPORT

  • Tylan Wallace

    Out

    Knee · Did not practice · Out

  • Teven Jenkins

    Out

    Back · Limited practice · Out

  • Elgton Jenkins

    Out

    Concussion · Did not practice · Out

  • Rico Dowdle

    Out

    Toe · Did not practice · Out

  • Joey Porter Jr.

    Out

    Not injury related - other, Back · Limited practice · Out

  • Yahya Black

    Questionable

    Not injury related - personal matter · Questionable

  • Jalen Ramsey

    Questionable

    Limited practice · Questionable

  • Brandin Echols

    LP

    Limited practice

  • Tytus Howard

    FP

    Full practice

  • Tyson Campbell

    FP

    Full practice

  • Grant Delpit

    FP

    Full practice

  • Gennings Dunker

    LISTED

    Knee

SITUATIONAL

  • PIT: 49.3 penalty yards per game to CLE's 69.7

    20.3 YDS

    Cleveland is giving away 69.7 penalty yards a game over 3 games, way up from 49.4 last season, while Pittsburgh is steady at 49.3 against 47.2. Three games is a small sample, and Cleveland's jump looks more like noise than a new identity. If the Browns keep handing out free yards at home, it extends Pittsburgh drives and kills their own, which matters most in a tight, low-margin divisional game.

  • PIT: 207.7 team passing yards per game to CLE's 178.3

    29.3 YPG

    PIT is at 207.7 team passing yards per game over 3 games; CLE is at 178.3 over 3 games. Those are this season's games through Sep 30. Last season PIT was at 202.4 over 17 games and CLE at 165.2 over 17 games.

  • PIT (2-1) at CLE (2-1), a division game

    -10 PT GAP

    Both teams are 2-1 with negative point totals, Pittsburgh at -7 and Cleveland at -17. Both records flatter the play. Cleveland has won two straight and is 1-0 at home, while Pittsburgh lost its one road game. A division game between two teams winning close or getting blown out once leans toward a tight spot, not a mismatch.

  • PIT is on a short week

    4d vs 4d

    Pittsburgh and Cleveland both come in on 4 days, so neither side gets a rest edge. Short weeks tend to mean simpler game plans and less practice time for both. That can favor a lower-scoring, conservative game, but schedule alone gives no side an advantage.

AFTER GARY

  • CLE +2.5 → +2.5

    NOW +0.5PP

    Gary's number was 2.5; the same book now shows 2.5.

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Daily picks first stored October 1, 2026 at 4:37 PM ET.
Odds record
The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: draftkings, caesars, fanduel, betrivers, fanatics, betmgm.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Props on this game

2
  • GARY'S PICK
    MICHAEL PITTMAN JR.RECEPTIONS UNDER 3.5
    NFLPittsburgh Steelers· -135

    Michael Pittman Jr.
    Receptions under 3.5

    -135 · CASHED · ACTUAL 2

    Pittsburgh Steelers

    Michael Pittman Jr. under 3.5 receptions at -135. The price is heavy, and I'm paying it because the number moved up while his role stayed small. Against Cincinnati last Sunday he was set at 2.5 catches and finished with 2 on 5 targets. This week the book raised him to 3.5. In two games with Pittsburgh he has 5 catches on 8 targets, and he is third among the wide receivers for looks. DK Metcalf has drawn 24 targets and Roman Wilson 18, and Pat Freiermuth and Jaylen Warren are each drawing more per game than Pittman too. He played about three quarters of the snaps against Cincinnati and saw 5 targets, while Wilson saw 6 playing well under half. His snaps aren't turning into volume.

    The matchup squeezes it further. Rodgers is averaging 5.9 yards per attempt throwing to wide receivers, the worst mark in the league, against 8.8 when he throws to tight ends. Cleveland ranks 3rd in pressure rate and 4th in quick pressure, and when Rodgers has to get the ball out early, the reads that have worked for him this year go to Freiermuth, Darnell Washington and Warren. With the total at 37.5, I don't expect enough Pittsburgh dropbacks for the fourth or fifth option in the passing game to pile up catches. To get to four, Pittman probably needs six or seven targets, and he hasn't seen more than five in a Steelers uniform.

    The best case against me is who Pittman has been. In Indianapolis last season he averaged 4.5 catches over the 10 games on his sheet, with games of 8 and 9 in there, and a big possession receiver fits the quick, underneath throws a pressured quarterback leans on. Cleveland has also allowed 31 catches to wide receivers in three games, and corner Tyson Campbell is questionable. Pittsburgh throws more than its situations call for, so if the Steelers fall behind, the volume could find him. Two games is a thin read on his role in this offense, and the -135 already asks a lot.

  • GARY'S PICK
    MICHAEL PITTMAN JR.RECEIVING YARDS UNDER 32.5
    NFLPittsburgh Steelers· -115

    Michael Pittman Jr.
    Receiving Yards under 32.5

    -115 · CASHED · ACTUAL 15

    Pittsburgh Steelers

    Michael Pittman Jr. under 32.5 receiving yards at -115. The book had him at 26.5 last Sunday and he finished with 16 yards on 2 catches. Now he's at 32.5, six yards higher, for a receiver who sits behind Metcalf and Wilson in targets and averages 4 looks a game. That's a number I'm happy to go against.

    The weak spot in this Pittsburgh offense is yardage to wide receivers. Rodgers ranks last in the league in yards per attempt throwing to them at 5.9, and the offense ranks 29th in EPA per play over three games. Cleveland's front is set up to make that worse. It ranks 3rd in pressure rate and 4th in quick pressure, and Mason Graham has 4 sacks from the interior going against a Pittsburgh right side that has played one game together, with rookie Max Iheanachor making his first start at tackle last week. Quick pressure takes away the downfield shots and turns targets into short gains, and the plays that have produced chunk yardage for Pittsburgh have gone to Washington and Wilson. On four targets, Pittman needs one long catch to clear this, which is exactly the throw this matchup is built to take away. Last season in Indianapolis his typical game landed in the 20s, with his average pulled up by three big games of 79, 95 and 115.

    The case against is that Cleveland has been generous to wideouts: 458 yards and 5 touchdowns to the position in three games, more than 150 a game. In Week 1 Pittman turned 3 catches into 58 yards, so he has shown he can get over this on light volume, and with Tyson Campbell questionable the Browns could be thinner at corner. This card and my receptions under ride on the same read of his role, so a big night from Pittman beats them both.

Every prop from this day is on the archive page.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NFL game this dayThe NFL recordToday's NFL picksEvery sport this day