Skip to content
GARY A.I.Get the app
NFL · Sun, Sep 20 · 4:25 PM

Washington Commanders at Dallas Cowboys

O/U 57.5 · SPREAD Dallas Cowboys -16.5 · AT&T Stadium

GARY'S PICK
Commanders +4.5
NFL@ Cowboys· -114

Commanders
+4.5

-114 · LOST · WSH 20 · DAL 37

Cowboys

The pick & result

Published pick
Washington Commanders +4.5 -114
Published odds
-114
Result
Lost
Final score
20-37

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The line

BETMGM · 49 moves
MarketOpened
Sep 14 6:00 AM
Close
Sep 20 4:17 PM
Move
SPREADDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -4 (-105)Price
TOTAL50 (-110)51.5 (-108)+1½
MONEYLINEDallas Cowboys -190Dallas Cowboys -210−20
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENSep 14 6:00 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -190 · Washington Commanders +160
Sep 14 8:01 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-112)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -190 · Washington Commanders +160
Sep 14 8:31 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -200 · Washington Commanders +160
Sep 14 10:01 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -190 · Washington Commanders +160
Sep 14 10:32 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-110)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -190 · Washington Commanders +160
Sep 14 11:02 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-110)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -200 · Washington Commanders +160
Sep 14 11:32 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-110)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -200 · Washington Commanders +165
Sep 14 2:03 PMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-110)50.5 (-112)Dallas Cowboys -200 · Washington Commanders +165
Sep 14 5:03 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 14 7:36 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 14 11:18 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 6:00 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 8:30 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 9:31 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 11:01 AMDallas Cowboys -3.5 (-110)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 2:01 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 3:01 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -220 · Washington Commanders +180
Sep 15 4:01 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 15 9:02 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 15 11:02 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 16 6:00 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50 (-118)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 16 12:31 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 16 1:31 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 16 2:31 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -220 · Washington Commanders +180
Sep 16 5:18 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 16 9:08 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 16 10:38 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 16 11:38 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 17 7:30 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 17 12:02 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 17 12:32 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-112)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 17 1:32 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 17 6:45 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 18 1:02 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 18 2:03 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 18 8:07 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 19 8:30 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 19 10:11 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 19 4:09 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 19 8:12 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)50.5 (-112)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 19 8:56 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 20 12:44 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)51 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 20 6:00 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 20 8:51 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 20 11:22 AMDallas Cowboys -4 (-108)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 20 12:03 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-110)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 20 1:35 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
Sep 20 3:06 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)51 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +170
Sep 20 3:16 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)51 (-110)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175
CLOSESep 20 4:17 PMDallas Cowboys -4 (-105)51.5 (-108)Dallas Cowboys -210 · Washington Commanders +175

The read

Dallas opens its home schedule with both teams coming off division losses. Washington arrives after falling a two-point conversion short in Philadelphia; the Cowboys return from a game in which their offense barely saw the field after halftime.

I’m taking Washington with the points because Dallas’s defensive problems give the Commanders a credible way to stay competitive. The Cowboys allowed a 60.0% success rate against New York, including 54.5% on early downs. That was sustained movement, not simply a handful of costly breakdowns. Washington’s running game and Jayden Daniels’s mobility can test the containment and communication issues documented in Dallas’s opener.

Dallas now loses DeMarvion Overshown, whose absence is tagged FRESH after he played 74% of its opening defensive snaps. That makes it harder to count on an immediate defensive correction. Washington’s offense remains uneven, but its 132 rushing yards against Philadelphia and two late touchdown drives provide a workable foundation against this particular opponent.

Washington’s defense offers another reason to take the cushion. It allowed a 35.3% success rate and forced seven Philadelphia punts. The concern is substantial: explosive concessions undermined those stops, and Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens can punish similar mistakes. Frankie Luvu’s FRESH absence also changes that defense, while Chig Okonkwo’s FRESH absence removes an offensive contributor. This is no clean injury advantage for Washington.

Those vulnerabilities are why I prefer +4.5 to the +180 moneyline. I trust Washington’s opportunities against Dallas’s defense more than I trust Washington to finish an outright win. Dallas has a credible offensive rebound case, but covering requires enough defensive improvement to create separation. At -114, I’m backing the Commanders to keep that task difficult.

Injuries noted

Washington Commanders: Deatrich Wise Jr. (PUP-R) — Wise (undisclosed) was placed on the reserve/PUP list on Sunday.; Trey Amos (IR-R) — Amos (ankle) was placed on injured reserve Sunday with a designation to return.; Jeremy McNichols (IR-R) — The Commanders placed McNichols (quadriceps) on injured reserve with a designation to return Sunday, Zach Selby of the team's official site reports.; Laremy Tunsil (IR) — The Commanders placed Tunsil (triceps) on injured reserve Monday.; Dorance Armstrong (Questionable) — Armstrong (knee) was a limited participant at the Commanders' practice Wednesday.; Jer'Zhan Newton (IR) — The Commanders placed Newton (pectoral) on injured reserve Monday.; Ricky Barber (Inactive) — inactive; Treylon Burks (Inactive) — Burks (coach's decision) is inactive for Sunday's game against the Eagles.; Athan Kaliakmanis (Inactive) — Kaliakmanis (coach's decision) is inactive but will serve as the Commanders' emergency third quarterback against the Eagles on Sunday.; Luke McCaffrey (Inactive) — McCaffrey (coach's decision) is inactive for Sunday's game against the Eagles.; Tanoa Togiai (Inactive) — inactive; Frankie Luvu (Out) — Luvu (groin) won't play in Sunday's game against the Cowboys, Tashan Reed of The Washington Post reports.; Chig Okonkwo (Out) — Okonkwo (hamstring) won't play Sunday at Dallas, Tashan Reed of The Athletic reports.; Jordan Magee (IR) — The Commanders placed Magee (hamstring) on injured reserve Wednesday, Zach Selby of the team's official site reports.; Tyler Owens (Questionable) — Owens (ankle) is questionable to return to Sunday's game against the Eagles, Ben Standig of Big 100 Washington D.C. reports.; K'Lavon Chaisson (Questionable) — questionable; Jaylin Lane (Questionable) — Lane (groin) was a limited participant at practice Thursday.; Charles Omenihu (Questionable) — questionable; Odafe Oweh (Questionable) — Oweh (calf) was a limited participant at the Commanders' practice Wednesday.; Daron Payne (Questionable) — questionable; Javon Kinlaw (Questionable) — questionable

Dallas Cowboys: Princeton Fant (IR) — ir; Matt Hennessy (IR) — ir; Kelvin Gilliam Jr. (IR) — Gilliam (triceps) reverted to Dallas' injured reserve Tuesday, Tommy Yarrish of the team's official site reports.; Marist Liufau (IR-R) — Liufau (forearm) was placed on injured reserve by the Cowboys on Sunday with a designation to return, Nick Eatman of the team's official website reports.; Devin Moore (IR-R) — ir; DJ Rogers (IR) — Rogers (knee) reverted to the Cowboys' injured-reserve list Monday, Joe Hoyt of The Dallas Morning News reports.; Tyler Smith (IR) — The Cowboys placed Smith (thumb) on injured reserve Wednesday.; Malik Davis (IR) — The Cowboys placed Davis (hip) on injured reserve Saturday, Adam Schefter of ESPN reports.; Israel Abanikanda (Inactive) — inactive; Camden Brown (Inactive) — inactive; Caelen Carson (Inactive) — inactive; Ajani Cornelius (Inactive) — inactive; Tyrus Wheat (Inactive) — inactive; DeMarvion Overshown (Out) — Overshown (hamstring) has been ruled out ahead of Sunday's game against the Commanders, Tommy Yarrish of the Cowboys' official site reports.; Malik Hooker (Out) — Hooker (forearm) has been ruled out ahead of Sunday's game against the Commanders, Tommy Yarrish of the Cowboys' official site reports.; James Houston (Questionable) — questionable

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Marcus Mariota is the projected starting quarterback for WSH

    7.47 Y/A

    In 2025, Marcus Mariota threw for 1695 passing yards, completed 61.2% of his passes and averaged 7.47 yards per attempt. His 10-7 touchdown-to-interception line puts that prior-season passing production in the context of his ball security over the same sample.

  • Dak Prescott is the projected starting quarterback for DAL

    5.15 Y/A

    In his first 2026 game, Dak Prescott threw for 175 passing yards, completed 64.7% of his passes and averaged 5.15 yards per attempt. His 2-1 touchdown-to-interception line comes from a one-game sample, so the relationship between completion rate and per-throw production is still an early read.

TRENCHES

  • WSH's front holds runners to 29 fewer yards per game

    29 YPG

    WSH is at 136 rushing yards allowed per game over 1 game; DAL is at 165 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

PASS RUSH

  • DAL's offense takes 1 fewer sacks per game

    1 SACKS

    WSH is at 1 sacks taken per game over 1 game; DAL is at 0 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH's rush gets home 1 more time per game

    1 SACKS

    WSH is at 3 sacks recorded per game over 1 game; DAL is at 2 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

PACE & SCRIPT

  • WSH holds the ball 10:00 longer per game

    10:00 TOP

    WSH is at 33:20 time of possession per game over 1 game; DAL is at 23:20 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH @ DAL carries a 57.5 market total

    57.5

    WSH @ DAL’s 57.5 total sits 19 points above the 38.5 median across 15 posted slate games. It is the slate’s most extreme high-total setting; the expectation would crack only if combined scoring fell well short of 57.5.

  • WSH runs +15 more plays per game

    15 PLAYS

    WSH is at 67 offensive plays per game over 1 game; DAL is at 52 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH's defense gives up 4 fewer points per game

    4 PPG

    WSH is at 24 points allowed per game over 1 game; DAL is at 28 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

TURNOVERS

  • DAL's defense takes the ball away 1 more time per game

    1 TO

    WSH is at 0 takeaways per game over 1 game; DAL is at 1 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH commits 1 fewer turnovers per game

    1 TO

    WSH is at 0 turnovers committed per game over 1 game; DAL is at 1 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH throws 1 fewer picks per game

    1 INT

    WSH is at 0 interceptions thrown per game over 1 game; DAL is at 1 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

RED ZONE

  • WSH allows a red-zone scoring rate 33.3 percentage points lower

    33.3 PP

    WSH is at 66.7% red-zone scoring allowed over 1 game; DAL is at 100% over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

MISMATCH

  • DAL on the money downs — 72.7% on third down to WSH's 33.3%

    72.7 VS 33.3

    The widest gap on this matchup's tape: 3rd down % — WSH 33.3, DAL 72.7, over 1 and 1 game samples.

COVERAGE

  • WSH allows a third-down conversion rate 39 percentage points lower

    39 PP

    WSH is at 42.9% third downs allowed over 1 game; DAL is at 81.8% over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH's secondary gives up 47 fewer passing yards per game

    47 YPG

    WSH is at 182 passing yards allowed per game over 1 game; DAL is at 229 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

HEAD-TO-HEAD

  • DAL lead the series with WSH since 2025

    2-0 SERIES

    DAL won both meetings with WSH since 2025, 30-23 at WSH on Dec. 25, 2025 and 44-22 at home on Oct. 19, 2025. The latest matchup was tighter than the earlier 22-point DAL win.

REPLACEMENT

  • Jayden Daniels (QB) is out for WSH

    OUT

    Daniels is out for WSH at DAL, reported Sep. 20. No replacement or offensive-workload details accompany the designation.

  • Athan Kaliakmanis (QB) is inactive for WSH

    INACTIVE

    Kaliakmanis (coach's decision) is inactive but will serve as the Commanders' emergency third quarterback against the Cowboys on Sunday. Reported Sep 20.

  • Jaylin Lane (WR) is questionable for WSH

    QUESTIONABLE

    Lane (groin) was a limited participant at practice Thursday. Reported Sep 17.

  • Dorance Armstrong (DE) is questionable for WSH

    QUESTIONABLE

    Armstrong (knee) was a limited participant at the Commanders' practice Wednesday. Reported Sep 16.

SITUATIONAL

  • WSH gives away 45 fewer penalty yards per game

    45 YDS

    WSH is at 45 penalty yards per game over 1 game; DAL is at 90 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • WSH (0-1) at DAL (0-1) — a division game

    -6 PT GAP

    WSH is 0-1, -2 points on the year, has lost 1 straight this season. DAL is 0-1, -8 points on the year, has lost 1 straight this season. WSH is 0-1 on the road; DAL is 0-0 at home. Both live in the NFC EAST.

TEAM RECORD

  • NFC EAST game: WSH 0-1, DAL 0-1 in the division

    DIVISION

    Washington and Dallas are each 0-1 in NFC East play in the current 2026 standings through September 19. With identical division records, this split does not separate either team within the NFC East entering WSH @ DAL.

AFTER GARY

  • WSH +4.5 → +4.5

    NO MOVE

    FANDUEL · SAME BOOK · PRE-KICK

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Daily picks first stored September 17, 2026 at 4:28 PM ET.
Odds record
The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: draftkings, caesars, fanduel, betrivers, betmgm, fanatics.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Props on this game

3
  • GARY'S PICK
    JAYDEN DANIELSPASSING YARDS UNDER 221.5
    NFLWashington Commanders· -113

    Jayden Daniels
    Passing Yards under 221.5

    -113 · CASHED · ACTUAL 96

    Washington Commanders

    I'm taking Daniels under 221.5 passing yards at -113. He threw for 164 yards on 34 attempts against Philadelphia, and he has cleared this line in only two of his last eight regular-season appearances when the 2026 opener is included.

    Washington has built this offense around a balanced rushing attack, play-action and Daniels' mobility; it ran for 132 yards in Week 1 and operated below expectation in pass rate. Dallas' inability to stop the run gives Washington another reason to lean on Jacory Croskey-Merritt instead of asking Daniels to win through volume.

    The strongest contrary evidence is Dallas allowing 230 passing yards and three passing touchdowns to Jaxson Dart while repeatedly busting coverages. Daniels also could be forced into additional attempts if Washington trails.

  • THE LONG SHOT
    JACORY CROSKEY-MERRITTANYTIME TD OVER 0.5
    NFLWashington Commanders· +120

    Jacory Croskey-Merritt
    Anytime TD over 0.5

    +120 · LOST · ACTUAL 0

    Washington Commanders

    I'm taking Croskey-Merritt to score an anytime touchdown at +120. He handled 16 carries in the opener, led Washington with 63 rushing yards and received the goal-line finish on the Commanders' first touchdown drive.

    The matchup supports another scoring opportunity: Dallas surrendered 165 rushing yards and a rushing touchdown in Week 1, and Croskey-Merritt ran for 105 yards and two touchdowns in his last meeting with the Cowboys. The strongest contrary evidence is the one-game sample for his current role.

    Rachaad White remains involved, while Daniels can keep the ball near the goal line, so Washington's rushing touchdowns are not reserved for one player.

  • THE LONG SHOT
    CEEDEE LAMBANYTIME TD OVER 0.5
    NFLDallas Cowboys· +110

    CeeDee Lamb
    Anytime TD over 0.5

    +110 · CASHED · ACTUAL 2

    Dallas Cowboys

    I'm taking Lamb to score an anytime touchdown at +110. He led Dallas with eight targets in the opener and caught Prescott's first touchdown pass, reinforcing his position as the primary option when the field compresses.

    Washington allowed three passing touchdowns against Philadelphia and conceded several coverage-breaking gains, while Dallas should have more possessions at home than it managed in Week 1. The strongest contrary evidence is the limited current-season sample and Dallas' crowded scoring distribution.

    George Pickens, Jake Ferguson and Javonte Williams all command opportunities, and Lamb produced only 44 yards in the opener despite his touchdown.

Every prop from this day is on the archive page.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NFL game this dayThe NFL recordToday's NFL picksEvery sport this day