Skip to content
GARY A.I.Get the app
NFL · Sun, Sep 20 · 1:00 PM

Pittsburgh Steelers at New England Patriots

O/U 23.5 · SPREAD New England Patriots -16.5 · Gillette Stadium

GARY'S PICK
Steelers +4.5
NFL@ Patriots· -102

Steelers
+4.5

-102 · LOST · PIT 3 · NE 20

Patriots

The pick & result

Published pick
Pittsburgh Steelers +4.5 -102
Published odds
-102
Result
Lost
Final score
3-20

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The line

BETMGM · 42 moves
MarketOpened
Sep 14 6:00 AM
Close
Sep 20 12:55 PM
Move
SPREADNew England Patriots -5 (-110)New England Patriots -4.5 (-105)−½
TOTAL42 (-110)41 (-110)−1
MONEYLINENew England Patriots -235New England Patriots -225+10
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENSep 14 6:00 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)42 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 14 8:01 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)42 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 14 8:31 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-108)42 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 14 11:02 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)42 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 14 12:03 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 14 2:03 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 14 5:03 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 14 8:48 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)42 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 15 6:00 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)42 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 15 6:30 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-105)42 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 15 9:31 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)42 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 15 11:01 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-112)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 15 2:01 PMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 15 4:01 PMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)42 (-112)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 15 5:01 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-108)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 15 6:01 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +190
Sep 15 8:01 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-108)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +190
Sep 15 11:02 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +190
Sep 16 12:02 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-108)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 16 9:31 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 16 7:37 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 17 8:30 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 17 11:31 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 18 10:01 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 18 2:03 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 18 6:05 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 19 5:01 AMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 19 1:38 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 19 5:40 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-105)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 19 8:56 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-110)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 20 12:14 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 20 8:19 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -250 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 20 8:51 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 20 9:29 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +200
Sep 20 10:00 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-108)41.5 (-105)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 20 10:13 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-105)41.5 (-110)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 20 10:41 AMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-105)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +195
Sep 20 12:03 PMNew England Patriots -5.5 (-105)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +190
Sep 20 12:14 PMNew England Patriots -4.5 (-118)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +190
Sep 20 12:25 PMNew England Patriots -5 (-105)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -235 · Pittsburgh Steelers +190
Sep 20 12:35 PMNew England Patriots -4.5 (-118)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -225 · Pittsburgh Steelers +188
Sep 20 12:45 PMNew England Patriots -4.5 (-105)41.5 (-108)New England Patriots -225 · Pittsburgh Steelers +188
CLOSESep 20 12:55 PMNew England Patriots -4.5 (-105)41 (-110)New England Patriots -225 · Pittsburgh Steelers +188

The read

New England opens its home schedule at Gillette Stadium after letting the Seattle opener slip away. Pittsburgh arrives with a win, but both offenses have work to do.

I’m taking the points because Pittsburgh’s defensive approach presents a credible problem for this particular Patriots offense. The Steelers played zone on all 26 Atlanta dropbacks and generated four sacks while blitzing only 7.7%. Atlanta’s depleted quarterback situation limits what that performance proves, but the matchup still matters: Maye struggled with Seattle’s coverage and forced throws late. Watt and Highsmith give Pittsburgh a route to disrupting him without committing extra defenders to the rush.

A.J. Brown’s fresh absence makes New England’s offensive adjustment harder. Its play success rate against Seattle fell from 46.7% with Brown to 35.1% after he left. That does not establish how the offense will perform without him every week, but it puts a real burden on the remaining receivers and the protection. Henderson’s return and New England’s additional preparation time offer answers; I’m not assuming another interception collapse.

Pittsburgh has limitations of its own. Pittman is newly out after contributing 58 receiving yards in the opener, and an offense that converted three of 13 third downs has not earned an assumption of sustained scoring. Carlton Davis III’s absence gives Rodgers an opening against New England’s coverage, but it does not erase Pittsburgh’s offensive concerns.

Those concerns are why I prefer +4.5 to the Steelers moneyline. Maye’s established ability and New England’s stronger opening-game offensive success rate make a Patriots win entirely plausible. Pittsburgh’s defensive matchup gives me enough reason to take the cushion at -102, without requiring its depleted offense to win outright.

Injuries noted

Pittsburgh Steelers: Daequan Hardy (IR) — Undisclosed; Cole Burgess (IR) — Undisclosed; Donte Kent (PUP-R) — The Steelers placed Kent (undisclosed) on the reserve/PUP list Monday, Teresa Varley of the team's official site reports.; Logan Lee (IR) — ir; Jack Driscoll (IR-R) — The Steelers placed Driscoll (undisclosed) on injured reserve Monday with a designation to return, Teresa Varley of the team's official site reports.; DeShon Elliott (IR-R) — ir; Joey Porter Jr. (Out) — Porter (back) wants a long-term contract, regardless of where he will play it out, Jonathan Jones of the Athletic reports.; Drew Allar (Inactive) — Allar (coach's decision) is inactive for Sunday's game against the Falcons.; Gennings Dunker (Inactive) — Dunker (coach's decision) is inactive for Sunday's game against the Falcons.; Will Howard (Inactive) — Howard (coach's decision) is inactive but will serve as the Steelers' emergency third quarterback against the Falcons on Sunday.; Kevin Jobity Jr. (Inactive) — inactive; Gabriel Rubio (Inactive) — Rubio (coach's decision) is inactive for Sunday's game against the Falcons.; Troy Fautanu (Questionable) — Fautanu (ankle) is officially listed as questionable for Sunday's game at New England, Brooke Pryor of ESPN.com reports.; Michael Pittman Jr. (Out) — Pittman (foot) has been ruled out for Sunday's game at New England, Burt Lauten of the Steelers' official site reports.

New England Patriots: Harold Landry III (PUP-R) — Landry (undisclosed) was moved to the reserve/PUP list by the Patriots on Sunday.; Brenden Schooler (NFI-R) — nfi-r; Jeremiah Webb (IR) — Arm; Julian Hill (IR) — Knee; Myles Montgomery (IR) — ir; Bryce Baringer (IR) — The Patriots placed Baringer (undisclosed) on injured reserve Monday.; Ben Brown (Questionable) — questionable; Marcus Bryant (IR-R) — The Patriots placed Bryant (ankle) on injured reserve with a designation to return Sunday.; TreVeyon Henderson (Questionable) — Head coach Mike Vrabel said Henderson (ankle) will "do some more" at Wednesday's practice, Mark Daniels of MassLive.com reports.; Khalil Jacobs (IR) — The Patriots placed Jacobs (undisclosed) on injured reserve Monday.; Efton Chism III (Inactive) — Chism (coach's decision) is inactive for Wednesday's game against the Seahawks.; Erick Hunter (Inactive) — inactive; Behren Morton (Inactive) — Morton (coach's decision) is inactive but will serve as the Patriots' emergency third quarterback for Wednesday's game against the Seahawks.; Karon Prunty (Inactive) — inactive; Walter Rouse (Inactive) — inactive; A.J. Brown (IR) — Brown, who was officially placed on injured reserve Saturday, is expected to miss about six weeks due to a right high-ankle sprain, Ian Rapoport of NFL Network reports.; Dametrious Crownover (Out) — Crownover (knee) has been ruled out ahead of Sunday's game against the Steelers.; Carlton Davis III (Out) — Davis (neck) has been ruled out ahead of Sunday's game against the Steelers.; Dre'Mont Jones (Questionable) — Jones (foot) is listed as questionable for Sunday's game against the Steelers.; Robert Spillane (Questionable) — Spillane (knee) was a limited participant in Wednesday's practice.

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Drake Maye is the projected starting quarterback for NE

    5.39 Y/A

    In his first 2026 game, Drake Maye threw for 178 passing yards, completed 69.7% of his passes and averaged 5.39 yards per attempt. His 1-3 touchdown-to-interception line comes from a one-game sample, so the relationship between completion rate and per-throw production is still an early read.

  • Aaron Rodgers is the projected starting quarterback for PIT

    5.53 Y/A

    In his first 2026 game, Aaron Rodgers threw for 221 passing yards, completed 60% of his passes and averaged 5.53 yards per attempt. His 1-0 touchdown-to-interception line comes from a one-game sample, so the relationship between completion rate and per-throw production is still an early read.

TRENCHES

  • NE's front holds runners to 23 fewer yards per game

    23 YPG

    PIT is at 120 rushing yards allowed per game over 1 game; NE is at 97 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

PASS RUSH

  • PIT's rush gets home 2 more times per game

    2 SACKS

    PIT is at 4 sacks recorded per game over 1 game; NE is at 2 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

  • NE's pocket leaks 5 fewer yards per game

    5 YDS

    PIT is at 15 sack yards lost per game over 1 game; NE is at 10 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

PACE & SCRIPT

  • PIT @ NE carries a 23.5 market total

    23.5

    PIT @ NE carries a 23.5 total, 15 points below the 38.5 median across 15 posted slate games. That places the matchup materially below the slate’s central scoring expectation; a departure would require combined scoring to exceed that 23.5 setting.

  • PIT is scoring +10 points per game

    10 PPG

    PIT is at 20 points per game over 1 game; NE is at 10 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • NE holds the ball 5:24 longer per game

    5:24 TOP

    PIT is at 28:53 time of possession per game over 1 game; NE is at 34:17 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

TURNOVERS

  • PIT's defense takes the ball away 2 more times per game

    2 TO

    PIT recorded two takeaways in one 2026 game through September 19, while NE recorded none. The one-game sample provides no supplied context on the offenses or turnover opportunities each defense faced.

  • NE puts 1 fewer fumbles on the ground per game

    1 FUM

    PIT is at 1 fumbles lost per game over 1 game; NE is at 0 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

MISMATCH

  • PIT's ball security against NE's giveaways — 3 turnovers a game to PIT's 1

    1 VS 3

    PIT recorded 1 turnover per game while NE recorded 3, over 1-game samples. Turnovers are the matchup’s widest listed split, but the facts do not show how either offense or defense created them.

COVERAGE

  • PIT's defense surrenders 1.7 fewer yards a snap

    1.7 Y/P

    PIT allowed 4.2 yards per play in one 2026 game through September 19, compared with NE's 5.9. One opposing-team box does not establish how PIT's result holds against different offensive styles.

  • PIT's secondary gives up 70 fewer passing yards per game

    70 YPG

    PIT is at 118 passing yards allowed per game over 1 game; NE is at 188 over 1 game. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-19.

HEAD-TO-HEAD

  • PIT lead the series with NE since 2025

    1-0 SERIES

    PIT's only meeting with NE since 2025 was a 21-14 win at NE on Sep. 21, 2025. There is no earlier result in the supplied series sample for comparison.

REPLACEMENT

  • Mike Onwenu (G) is doubtful for NE

    DOUBTFUL

    Onwenu broke his right ankle during Sunday's game against the Steelers, Adam Schefter of ESPN reports. Reported Sep 20.

  • Drew Allar (QB) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    Allar (coach's decision) is inactive for Sunday's game against the Patriots, Teresa Varley of the Steelers' official site reports. Reported Sep 20.

  • Will Howard (QB) is inactive for PIT

    INACTIVE

    Howard (coach's decision) is inactive as the Steelers' emergency third quarterback for Sunday's game against the Patriots, Teresa Varley of the team's official site reports. Reported Sep 20.

  • Rico Dowdle (RB) is questionable for PIT

    QUESTIONABLE

    Dowdle has been ruled out for the remainder of Sunday's game against the Patriots, Brooke Pryor of ESPN.com reports. He finished with seven carries for 22 yards and two catches for 22 yards on two targets. Reported Sep 20.

SITUATIONAL

  • NE has 4 more days of rest

    7d vs 11d

    NE enters with 11 days of rest and a bye behind it. PIT has had 7 days since its last game, leaving a 4-day spacing gap in PIT @ NE.

  • PIT's passing game is +38 yards per game

    38 YPG

    PIT is at 206 team passing yards per game over 1 game; NE is at 168 over 1 game. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-19.

  • PIT (1-0) at NE (0-1)

    -10 PT GAP

    PIT is 1-0, +7 points on the year, has won 1 straight this season. NE is 0-1, -3 points on the year, has lost 1 straight this season. PIT is 0-0 on the road; NE is 0-0 at home.

AFTER GARY

  • PIT +4.5 → +4.5

    GARY +0.72PP

    FANDUEL · SAME BOOK · PRE-KICK

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Daily picks first stored September 17, 2026 at 4:28 PM ET.
Odds record
The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: draftkings, caesars, fanduel, betrivers, betmgm, fanatics.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Props on this game

4
  • GARY'S PICK
    RICO DOWDLERECEIVING YARDS UNDER 51.5
    NFLPittsburgh Steelers· -113

    Rico Dowdle
    Receiving Yards under 51.5

    -113 · CASHED · ACTUAL 22

    Pittsburgh Steelers

    I’m taking under 51.5 receiving yards at -113. Dowdle caught two of five targets for only six yards in the opener, and he averaged 19.6 receiving yards across nine games in 2025, staying below this number eight times.

    His role is substantial, but it is split between rushing, protection and short backfield targets rather than built to produce 52 receiving yards. The strongest counter is Michael Pittman Jr.’s fresh absence: Pittsburgh threw 40 times last week, and Dowdle’s five targets show he could inherit some of the vacated work.

    Even with that potential bump, this line asks for nearly triple his 2025 average.

  • GARY'S PICK
    DARNELL WASHINGTONRECEIVING YARDS OVER 12.5
    NFLPittsburgh Steelers· -115

    Darnell Washington
    Receiving Yards over 12.5

    -115 · LOST · ACTUAL 7

    Pittsburgh Steelers

    I’m playing over 12.5 receiving yards at -115. Washington cleared this line in eight of 10 games in 2025 and opened this season with 18 yards on two catches.

    He played 44 snaps in Week 1, and Pittman’s absence should preserve Pittsburgh’s heavy two-tight-end usage. New England also blitzed on 44.4% of Seattle’s dropbacks, creating a reason for Rodgers to use his large tight end as a short answer.

    The concern is Washington’s limited receiving role: he drew only two targets in the opener, and Pittsburgh ran on 47.6% of his snaps. One missed connection could sink a low-volume over.

  • THE LONG SHOT
    DK METCALFANYTIME TD OVER 0.5
    NFLPittsburgh Steelers· +230

    DK Metcalf
    Anytime TD over 0.5

    +230 · LOST · ACTUAL 0

    Pittsburgh Steelers

    I’m taking Metcalf to score at +230. He received 10 targets and a 27% target share in Week 1 while leaving the field only for kneel-downs.

    With Pittman ruled out today, Metcalf is the clear first option whenever Pittsburgh reaches scoring range, and Carlton Davis III’s absence removes another experienced Patriots corner from the matchup. The strongest objection is Christian Gonzalez, who erased Jaxon Smith-Njigba when directly covering him in the opener.

    Metcalf also converted his 10 Week 1 targets into only four catches for 40 yards, so the volume has not yet become efficient production.

  • THE LONG SHOT
    HUNTER HENRYANYTIME TD OVER 0.5
    NFLNew England Patriots· +250

    Hunter Henry
    Anytime TD over 0.5

    +250 · LOST · ACTUAL 0

    New England Patriots

    I’m betting Henry to score at +250. With A.J. Brown unavailable, Henry remains one of Maye’s established targets in the condensed part of the field.

    The matchup also carries specific evidence: Henry caught eight passes for 90 yards and both New England touchdowns against Pittsburgh last season. At this price, one red-zone opportunity can be enough. The contrary case is meaningful.

    Henry drew only three targets and finished with 26 yards in the opener, while Pittsburgh held Atlanta to 118 net passing yards and never allowed a red-zone snap. Last year’s meeting is useful, but it is still only one game under different weekly circumstances.

Every prop from this day is on the archive page.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NFL game this dayThe NFL recordToday's NFL picksEvery sport this day