Rutgers Scarlet Knights at Northwestern Wildcats
O/U 58.5 · SPREAD Northwestern Wildcats -14.5 · Ryan Field, Evanston, IL
The pick & result
- Published pick
- Rutgers Scarlet Knights +15.5 -106
- Published odds
- -106
- Result
- Lost
- Final score
- 14-42
Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.
The line
BETMGM · 48 moves| Market | Opened Oct 18 1:02 PM | Close Sat 11:53 AM | Move |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Northwestern Wildcats -17.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-110) | −2½ |
| TOTAL | 57.5 (-112) | 58.5 (-120) | +1 |
| MONEYLINE | Northwestern Wildcats -1000 | Northwestern Wildcats -750 | +250 |
Every move, in order ›
| When | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| OPENOct 18 1:02 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -17.5 (-105) | 57.5 (-112) | Northwestern Wildcats -1000 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +675 |
| Oct 18 2:02 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-108) | 57.5 (-112) | Northwestern Wildcats -900 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +650 |
| Oct 18 4:03 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -900 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +650 |
| Oct 18 5:03 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-110) | 58.5 (-112) | Northwestern Wildcats -800 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +600 |
| Oct 18 6:03 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-110) | 58.5 (-112) | Northwestern Wildcats -800 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +600 |
| Oct 18 8:04 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -800 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 18 9:04 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -800 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +600 |
| Oct 18 10:04 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -800 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 19 6:00 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -800 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +600 |
| Oct 19 8:31 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 19 11:31 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 19 12:31 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 19 3:31 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 19 7:01 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 20 12:55 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 20 2:46 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 20 3:17 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 57.5 (-115) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 20 4:17 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 57.5 (-125) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 20 5:17 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 20 6:17 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 20 9:17 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 21 6:01 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 21 10:32 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 21 5:02 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-115) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 21 5:32 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-108) | 58.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Oct 21 6:03 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Oct 21 6:19 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Thu 10:58 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Thu 11:28 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Thu 11:58 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Thu 2:59 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-110) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Fri 4:45 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-110) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Fri 12:02 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16.5 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Fri 1:32 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-112) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Fri 2:02 PM | Northwestern Wildcats -16 (-108) | 58.5 (-110) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 4:45 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15.5 (-110) | 58.5 (-115) | Northwestern Wildcats -700 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 6:30 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-110) | 58.5 (-115) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 7:30 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-118) | 58.5 (-112) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 8:00 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15.5 (-108) | 59.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 8:30 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15.5 (-108) | 59.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| Sat 9:00 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-108) | 59.5 (-105) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 9:41 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-108) | 59.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 9:51 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-110) | 58.5 (-112) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 11:00 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-110) | 58.5 (-115) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 11:13 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-108) | 58.5 (-115) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 11:23 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -14.5 (-110) | 58.5 (-120) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 11:33 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-108) | 58.5 (-115) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
| Sat 11:43 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-108) | 59.5 (-108) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +575 |
| CLOSESat 11:53 AM | Northwestern Wildcats -15 (-110) | 58.5 (-120) | Northwestern Wildcats -750 · Rutgers Scarlet Knights +550 |
The read
Northwestern comes home ranked No. 24, the first time it has met Rutgers as a ranked team, and is chasing a fifth straight home win. Judged by the scoreboards, 15.5 looks cheap. Judged by how these teams actually move and stop the ball, it doesn't.
Northwestern's margins have had help. Aidan Chiles hasn't thrown an interception in six games. The Wildcats' only giveaways all year are lost fumbles against Penn State and Colorado, and the defense has taken the ball away in five of six games. Some of that is real ball security, but it won't keep coming at that rate. Look at Michigan State, a 2-5 team: the yardage was close, and so was the 24-21 final.
Rutgers' 2-4 record runs the other way. The Scarlet Knights were even in yardage with No. 16 USC and lost 35-42, with a pick-six in the middle of it. They lost 21-28 at Boston College behind four interceptions and gave the ball away four times against UMass. With Dylan Lonergan at quarterback and KJ Duff (741 yards, 9 TD) to throw to, they've scored 21 or more in every game but Indiana.
Northwestern isn't whole either. Robert Fitzgerald (49 tackles, 2 INT) and Brendan Flakes are doubtful, the linebacker room is thin, and three offensive linemen are out. That line gave up five sacks at Michigan State.
The case for the Wildcats is real: Rutgers can't stop the run. Indiana ran for 329, UMass for 200 and USC for 184, and Chip Kelly's offense put 413 on the ground against Penn State. Lonergan's interceptions, three against UMass and two against USC, are the clearest way this gets out of hand.
What doesn't move me: the ranking, the Homecoming talk, a mild 60-degree day, or an 11 a.m. Central kick that's noon on Rutgers' clocks. Rutgers' running-back questions don't either, since Clay Thevenin ran for 109 at Maryland.
Northwestern should win, probably on the ground, by about two touchdowns. This number prices the scoreboards more than the football. I'll take the points, as a lean.
Injuries noted
Rutgers Scarlet Knights: Kaj Sanders (out for season) — Defensive back; Schiano confirmed season-ending absence. Condition undisclosed.; Zahmir Dawud (out for season) — Defensive back; Schiano confirmed season-ending absence. Condition undisclosed.; Kevin Levy (out) — Starting defensive back; Schiano hopes for a return soon. Condition undisclosed.; Antwan Raymond (questionable) — Running back; condition undisclosed.; Ja'shon Benjamin (questionable) — Running back; condition undisclosed.; Jourdin Houston (questionable) — Wide receiver; condition undisclosed.; Ty Morris (questionable) — Linebacker; condition undisclosed.; Keshon Griffin (questionable) — Defensive lineman; condition undisclosed.; Ben Rothhaar (probable) — Tight end; condition undisclosed.; Sage Clawges (probable) — Defensive back; condition undisclosed.
Northwestern Wildcats: Ezomo Oratokhai (out for season) — Offensive lineman; Friday report lists season-ending absence. Condition undisclosed.; Callen Campbell (out) — Defensive lineman; condition undisclosed.; Chris Petrucci (out) — Tight end; condition undisclosed.; Daniel Anderson (out) — Running back; condition undisclosed.; David Anchondo (out) — Offensive lineman; condition undisclosed.; Jacob Miller (out) — Offensive lineman; condition undisclosed.; Jason Reynolds II (out) — Linebacker; condition undisclosed.; Josh Fussell (out) — Defensive back; condition undisclosed.; Luke Dehnicke (out) — Tight end; condition undisclosed.; Max Mohring (out) — Linebacker; condition undisclosed.; Qayvier Johnson (out) — Linebacker; condition undisclosed.; Brendan Flakes (doubtful) — Defensive lineman; condition undisclosed.; Robert Fitzgerald (doubtful) — Defensive back; condition undisclosed.; Amare Jordan (probable) — Linebacker; upgraded from questionable on Friday. Condition undisclosed.
The research
The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.
QUARTERBACK
Dylan Lonergan is RUTG's confirmed starter
8.39 Y/ADylan Lonergan is RUTG's confirmed starting quarterback. WRSU Rutgers Radio's October 22 report from team media availability explicitly identifies Lonergan as Rutgers QB1 entering the Northwestern game. 2026 line: 1066 passing yards, 58.3% completions, 8.39 yards per attempt, 10-6 TD-INT over 5 games.
Aidan Chiles is NU's projected starter
10.06 Y/AAidan Chiles is NU's projected starting quarterback. Northwestern's October 23 Rutgers preview discusses Chiles as its quarterback and quotes David Braun discussing his connection with Alex Honig. An explicit October 24 starting announcement was not retrieved. 2026 line: 1398 passing yards, 70.5% completions, 10.06 yards per attempt, 9-0 TD-INT over 6 games.
TRENCHES
NU: 137.5 rushing yards allowed per game to RUTG's 185.7
48.2 YPGRUTG is at 185.7 rushing yards allowed per game over 6 games; NU is at 137.5 over 6 games. Those are what each defense has allowed in this season's games through Oct 23.
PACE & SCRIPT
NU: 17 points allowed per game to RUTG's 31.8
14.8 PPGNorthwestern is allowing 17 a game, better than last season's 19.8, while Rutgers is giving up 31.8 for the second straight year. The Rutgers number is stable across two seasons, so it is a real weakness. Northwestern's defense sets the terms here, and this matchup leans toward Northwestern controlling a lower-scoring game.
RUTG @ NU carries a 58.5 market total
58.5Rutgers at Northwestern carries 58.5, 7 points above the median, so the market expects both offenses to get into the end zone often. Nothing on the sheet says why. Stalled drives that end in field goals, or a clock-control plan from either side, would keep it under. Think about whether both teams need to score well, or whether one carrying the load can get it there.
MISMATCH
NU: 0.33 turnovers a game to RUTG's 1.83
0.33 VS 1.83Northwestern has given the ball away 0.33 times a game over 6 games, a sharp drop from 1.62 last season. Rutgers went the opposite way, up to 1.83 from 0.92. Turnover rates swing a lot over six games, so both numbers are likely to drift back toward last season. For this game, Rutgers has to protect the ball on the road, because extra possessions are the easiest way for a careful Northwestern team to separate.
REPLACEMENT
Kaj Sanders (DB) is out for the season for RUTG
OUT FOR SEASONDefensive back; Schiano confirmed season-ending absence. Condition undisclosed. Rutgers Football Injury Report: Initial Report ahead of the Northwestern game (2026-10-22) Rutgers Head Coach Greg Schiano Talks No.24 Northwestern Game Week (2026-10-23)
Zahmir Dawud (DB) is out for the season for RUTG
OUT FOR SEASONDefensive back; Schiano confirmed season-ending absence. Condition undisclosed. Rutgers Football Injury Report: Initial Report ahead of the Northwestern game (2026-10-22) Rutgers Head Coach Greg Schiano Talks No.24 Northwestern Game Week (2026-10-23)
Ezomo Oratokhai (OL) is out for the season for NU
OUT FOR SEASONOffensive lineman; Friday report lists season-ending absence. Condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Kevin Levy (DB) is out for RUTG
OUTStarting defensive back; Schiano hopes for a return soon. Condition undisclosed. Rutgers Football Injury Report: Initial Report ahead of the Northwestern game (2026-10-22) Rutgers Head Coach Greg Schiano Talks No.24 Northwestern Game Week (2026-10-23)
Callen Campbell (DL) is out for NU
OUTDefensive lineman; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Chris Petrucci (TE) is out for NU
OUTTight end; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Daniel Anderson (RB) is out for NU
OUTRunning back; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
David Anchondo (OL) is out for NU
OUTOffensive lineman; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Jacob Miller (OL) is out for NU
OUTOffensive lineman; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Jason Reynolds II (LB) is out for NU
OUTLinebacker; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Josh Fussell (DB) is out for NU
OUTDefensive back; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Luke Dehnicke (TE) is out for NU
OUTTight end; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Max Mohring (LB) is out for NU
OUTLinebacker; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Qayvier Johnson (LB) is out for NU
OUTLinebacker; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Robert Fitzgerald (DB) is doubtful for NU
DOUBTFULDefensive back; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
Brendan Flakes (DL) is doubtful for NU
DOUBTFULDefensive lineman; condition undisclosed. Rutgers vs Northwestern — Big Ten availability, Friday 8:00 PM report (2026-10-23)
SITUATIONAL
RUTG: 3.17 fourth-down attempts per game to NU's 1
2.17 ATT/GRutgers goes for it on fourth down 3.17 times a game over 6 games, Northwestern just once. Rutgers was at 2.83 last season, so the aggressive streak is part of who they are, while Northwestern dropped from 2.23. Expect Rutgers to stay on the field in short-yardage spots, which adds swing to drives and scoring.
TEAM RECORD
Big Ten game: RUTG 1-2, NU 2-1 in conference
CONFERENCEThese two share the Big Ten. RUTG is 1-2 against it, NU is 2-1. 2026 standings through 2026-10-24.
About this analysis
- Who made it
- Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
- Published data
- Daily picks first stored October 24, 2026 at 8:11 AM ET.
- Odds record
- The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: draftkings, fanduel, betrivers, fanatics, betmgm, caesars.
- Accountability
- Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.
Get Gary on the App StoreEvery NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF picksEvery sport this day