BYU Cougars at UCF Knights
O/U 43.5 · SPREAD BYU Cougars -7.5 · FBC Mortgage Stadium, Orlando, FL
The pick & result
- Published pick
- BYU Cougars -7.5 +100
- Published odds
- +100
- Result
- Lost
- Final score
- 31-39
Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.
The line
BETMGM · 69 moves| Market | Opened Oct 18 1:02 PM | Close Sat 3:26 PM | Move |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | Holds |
| TOTAL | 46.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-118) | −3 |
| MONEYLINE | BYU Cougars -300 | BYU Cougars -300 | Holds |
Every move, in order ›
| When | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| OPENOct 18 1:02 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | 46.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -300 · UCF Knights +250 |
| Oct 18 2:02 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-108) | 46.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Oct 18 4:03 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 44.5 (-112) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +220 |
| Oct 18 5:03 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 44.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 18 6:03 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-110) | 44.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 18 7:04 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 44.5 (-105) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 18 8:04 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 44.5 (-105) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +220 |
| Oct 18 9:04 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-105) | 44.5 (-105) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +220 |
| Oct 18 10:04 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-110) | 44.5 (-105) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 6:00 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 43.5 (-115) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 10:31 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 11:31 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-110) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 2:31 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-110) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +200 |
| Oct 19 6:31 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-118) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 8:31 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-102) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 9:01 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-118) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 10:24 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 19 10:55 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +220 |
| Oct 20 6:00 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 8:38 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 12:15 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 1:15 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-118) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 1:46 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-108) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 4:17 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 4:47 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 5:47 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 6:17 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 6:47 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 20 8:17 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 12:18 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 8:30 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-108) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 10:01 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-120) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 10:32 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 1:02 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 3:32 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 5:32 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 6:03 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-112) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 6:19 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 7:51 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Oct 21 11:22 PM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Thu 9:00 AM | BYU Cougars -6.5 (-115) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -250 · UCF Knights +210 |
| Thu 5:53 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-108) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +220 |
| Fri 12:55 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-105) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +220 |
| Fri 1:32 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -300 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 2:02 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 3:02 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Fri 4:00 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 4:20 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 4:49 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 5:51 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-105) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -300 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 6:51 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Fri 7:30 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-105) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 12:05 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-115) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Sat 8:00 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-120) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Sat 9:41 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-115) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Sat 9:51 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-120) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Sat 10:11 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-115) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Sat 10:21 AM | BYU Cougars -7 (-112) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -285 · UCF Knights +230 |
| Sat 12:00 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 12:34 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-110) | 43.5 (-108) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +225 |
| Sat 1:04 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-120) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 1:24 PM | BYU Cougars -7 (-110) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -275 · UCF Knights +225 |
| Sat 1:35 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-105) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 1:45 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-105) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -300 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 2:16 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-105) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 2:26 PM | BYU Cougars -8 (-108) | 43.5 (-110) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 2:36 PM | BYU Cougars -8 (-108) | 43.5 (-112) | BYU Cougars -300 · UCF Knights +250 |
| Sat 2:46 PM | BYU Cougars -8 (-108) | 43.5 (-118) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| Sat 3:16 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-108) | 43.5 (-118) | BYU Cougars -295 · UCF Knights +240 |
| CLOSESat 3:26 PM | BYU Cougars -7.5 (-110) | 43.5 (-118) | BYU Cougars -300 · UCF Knights +240 |
The read
No. 2 BYU flies 1,900 miles into a Homecoming crowd in Orlando, six days after an emotional win over Notre Dame, to face a UCF team that's had 13 days to get ready. The setting is loud, but the football underneath it points one way.
UCF has been outgained by every FBS team on its schedule. That includes a TCU offense that ranks 123rd in scoring and still threw for 310 on the Knights. Third downs are the leak: 4-of-14 at Houston, 3-of-10 against TCU, 4-of-13 at Pitt. BYU has played the tougher slate in Notre Dame, Arizona, Iowa State and TCU, and won the line of scrimmage nearly everywhere. It scored 28 on a Notre Dame defense that allows 13.4 and held an offense averaging 41.1 to 24.
The matchup sharpens it. Outside of Georgia State, UCF has run for 20, 73, 106 and 110 yards against FBS defenses, and BYU hasn't allowed more than 115 on the ground to anyone. That leaves Keyone Jenkins throwing short and accurate, needing long drives that this third-down offense rarely finishes. Going the other way, UCF's secondary has given up 304, 282 and 310 through the air. DJ Bell and RJ Jackson Jr. are out, and nobody has reported Sincere Edwards' status. Bear Bachmeier threw for 329 and ran for 109 against Iowa State. LJ Martin missed BYU's last two games, and the Cougars still ran for 177 and 121.
What I'm ignoring: the Notre Dame hangover talk, Homecoming, Scott Frost's "shoot our shot," and the TCU common-opponent comparison. UCF beat TCU by 8 and BYU beat TCU by 7, and TCU outgained both. The UCF quarterback question doesn't move me either. Alonza Barnett III's FBS start produced 7 points at Pitt.
The real risk is turnovers. BYU managed 62 passing yards at TCU and has given the ball away in three of five FBS games. UCF's two FBS wins came with four and three takeaways. That's how the Knights stay inside the number, but it's single-game luck, not the better team. BYU is better on both sides of the ball against a tougher schedule, closer to double digits better on this field than a touchdown and a hook.
Injuries noted
BYU Cougars: LJ Martin (out) — RB #4 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Kyle Sfarcioc (questionable) — OL #64 listed Questionable on the Big 12 Update 2 report
UCF Knights: Taevion Swint (out) — RB #4 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; DJ Bell (out) — DB #5 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Duane Thomas Jr. (probable) — WR #7 listed Probable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Caleb Rollerson (out) — WR #13 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Alonza Barnett III (questionable) — QB #14 listed Questionable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Lewis Carter (out) — LB #20 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Jayden Jennings (probable) — LB #38 listed Probable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Bruno Dall (probable) — EDG #41 listed Probable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Kyle Hicks (probable) — LS #44 listed Probable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Trenton Turner (probable) — DT #54 listed Probable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Jacob Maiava (questionable) — OL #55 listed Questionable on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Owen Spell (out) — OL #61 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; Tyler Gibson (out) — OL #75 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report; RJ Jackson Jr. (out) — DT #95 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report
The research
The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.
QUARTERBACK
Bear Bachmeier is BYU's confirmed starter
8.27 Y/ABear Bachmeier is BYU's confirmed starting quarterback. KSL's October 19 report reproduces BYU's depth chart for the October 24 UCF game, listing Bachmeier first at quarterback ahead of Treyson Bourguet and Enoch Watson. 2026 line: 1257 passing yards, 65.8% completions, 8.27 yards per attempt, 9-2 TD-INT over 6 games.
Keyone Jenkins is UCF's projected starter
6.78 Y/AKeyone Jenkins is UCF's projected starting quarterback. October 22 reporting expects Jenkins to make his fifth consecutive start against BYU. No retrieved team announcement confirms the starter. Alonza Barnett III remains questionable in the October 23 availability update. 2026 line: 780 passing yards, 71.3% completions, 6.78 yards per attempt, 8-3 TD-INT over 5 games.
PACE & SCRIPT
BYU @ UCF carries a 43.5 market total
43.5BYU at UCF is posted at 43.5, 8 points below the slate median, so the market expects a low-scoring game where every possession counts. The sheet has no injury or matchup notes to explain it. Short fields from turnovers or a long return score would push it the other way fastest. On a low number like this, a single non-offensive touchdown changes the math a lot.
MISMATCH
BYU: 56.5% on third down to UCF's 36.1%
56.5 VS 36.1BYU is converting 56.5% of third downs over 6 games, up from 42% last season. UCF sits at 36.1%, near its 33.9% last year. BYU's rate is high for a six-game sample and likely to come down, but staying on the field keeps drives alive and wears a defense out. UCF's defense has to get off the field on third down, or the Knights will see far fewer possessions at home.
REPLACEMENT
LJ Martin (RB) is out for BYU
OUTRB #4 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
Taevion Swint (RB) is out for UCF
OUTRB #4 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
DJ Bell (DB) is out for UCF
OUTDB #5 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
Caleb Rollerson (WR) is out for UCF
OUTWR #13 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
Lewis Carter (LB) is out for UCF
OUTLB #20 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
Owen Spell (OL) is out for UCF
OUTOL #61 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
Tyler Gibson (OL) is out for UCF
OUTOL #75 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
RJ Jackson Jr. (DT) is out for UCF
OUTDT #95 listed Out on the Big 12 Update 2 report Big 12 availability report (Update 2, published 2026-10-23 21:00:00 CT) (2026-10-23)
SITUATIONAL
BYU: 56.5% third-down conversion rate to UCF's 36.1%
20.4 PPBYU is converting 56.5% of its third downs, way above last season's 42%, and that kind of rate tends to fall back. UCF is a little better than last year's 33.9%. BYU staying on the field controls the clock, but expect that number to cool, which narrows the edge a bit.
UCF has 7 more days of rest
7d vs 14dBYU plays on a normal week of rest while UCF gets two full weeks at home after its bye. The extra seven days give UCF time to heal bumps and install a few wrinkles specific to BYU, while BYU prepares on the standard weekly schedule. The edge is real but modest, since a regular week is routine for every team. Use it as a tiebreaker in a close read, leaning slightly toward the rested home side.
TEAM RECORD
Big 12 game: BYU 3-0, UCF 1-2 in conference
CONFERENCEThese two share the Big 12. BYU is 3-0 against it, UCF is 1-2. 2026 standings through 2026-10-24.
About this analysis
- Who made it
- Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
- Published data
- Daily picks first stored October 24, 2026 at 8:11 AM ET.
- Odds record
- The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: draftkings, fanduel, betrivers, betmgm, caesars, fanatics.
- Accountability
- Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.
Get Gary on the App StoreEvery NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF picksEvery sport this day