Skip to content
GARY A.I.Get the app
NCAAF · Sat, Oct 17 · 12:00 PM

Ohio State Buckeyes at Indiana Hoosiers

O/U 49.5 · SPREAD Ohio State Buckeyes -2.5 · Memorial Stadium (Bloomington, IN), Bloomington, IN

GARY'S PICK
Indiana +3.5
NCAAFvs Ohio State· -124

Indiana
+3.5

-124 · LOST · OSU 19 · IU 15

Ohio State

The pick & result

Published pick
Indiana Hoosiers +3.5 -124
Published odds
-124
Result
Lost
Final score
19-15

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The line

BETMGM · 58 moves
MarketOpened
Oct 11 3:03 PM
Close
Oct 17 11:12 AM
Move
SPREADOhio State Buckeyes -4 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -2.5 (-108)−1½
TOTAL50.5 (-110)49.5 (-108)−1
MONEYLINEOhio State Buckeyes -190Ohio State Buckeyes -150+40
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENOct 11 3:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -4 (-108)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -190 · Indiana Hoosiers +155
Oct 11 4:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)51.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 11 5:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-115)51.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -160 · Indiana Hoosiers +135
Oct 11 7:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 11 8:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-118)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 11 9:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)51.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 11 10:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-110)51.5 (-112)Ohio State Buckeyes -190 · Indiana Hoosiers +155
Oct 11 11:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-110)51.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -190 · Indiana Hoosiers +155
Oct 12 12:04 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)51.5 (-105)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 12 6:00 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 12 8:01 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 12 9:00 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +138
Oct 12 11:32 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +140
Oct 12 12:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-102)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +138
Oct 12 1:33 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +140
Oct 12 4:34 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +140
Oct 12 5:34 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)51.5 (+100)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +140
Oct 12 6:36 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-118)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +140
Oct 12 11:06 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -165 · Indiana Hoosiers +140
Oct 13 6:00 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 13 7:00 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 13 9:31 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-118)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +155
Oct 13 11:01 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-110)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 13 2:32 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 13 4:55 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 13 5:32 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 14 8:20 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 14 10:32 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 14 11:02 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 14 11:32 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-118)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 14 12:03 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-115)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 14 6:38 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +155
Oct 14 7:08 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-108)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 14 7:38 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 15 9:31 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 15 10:01 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -185 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 15 10:31 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 15 11:01 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 15 1:32 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +150
Oct 15 5:00 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 15 8:51 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 16 8:01 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3.5 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -175 · Indiana Hoosiers +145
Oct 16 11:32 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -155 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 16 2:02 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -155 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 16 4:32 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
Oct 16 7:41 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -160 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 16 9:01 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -155 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 16 9:31 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -160 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 16 10:31 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -155 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 16 11:31 PMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
Oct 17 12:01 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -160 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 17 9:31 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-108)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -155 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 17 9:41 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-105)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -155 · Indiana Hoosiers +130
Oct 17 9:51 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-102)50.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
Oct 17 10:21 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (+100)50.5 (-105)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
Oct 17 10:31 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (-102)50.5 (-105)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
Oct 17 10:41 AMOhio State Buckeyes -3 (+100)50.5 (-105)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
Oct 17 10:51 AMOhio State Buckeyes -2.5 (-108)49.5 (-110)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125
CLOSEOct 17 11:12 AMOhio State Buckeyes -2.5 (-108)49.5 (-108)Ohio State Buckeyes -150 · Indiana Hoosiers +125

The read

Bloomington hosts a top-five Big Ten showdown at noon. No. 5 Indiana is unbeaten, and No. 4 Ohio State comes in as the road favorite. The number says the Buckeyes are clearly better. This season's tape says it's a coin flip, and I'm taking the points.

This game turns on the ground, and both sides of it lean Indiana. Ohio State's run game has been ordinary against real fronts: 3.0 a carry at Texas and 3.4 at Iowa. Now it faces a defense that held Northwestern to 1.2 and Rutgers to 1.7. The Buckeyes do it without Ja'Kobi Jackson and with a patched right side of the line. That pushes Julian Sayin into obvious passing downs, exactly where Indiana's four-man rush does its damage: 20 sacks and 49 tackles for loss with almost no blitzing. Flip it around, and Ohio State's run defense gave up 6.0 a carry to Illinois and 57% rushing success to Texas. Now it sees Turbo Richard and Lee Beebe Jr., both healthy, in an offense that runs for 221.3 yards a game.

Then there's ball security. Indiana has one giveaway all season, and Josh Hoover hasn't thrown an interception. Ohio State has 6 giveaways, and Sayin has 5 picks. In a game this tight, that matters.

The market is also chasing the last two weeks. Ohio State looked great against Iowa and Maryland. Indiana looked shaky at Nebraska: outgained, and needing two late Nick Marsh touchdowns. But that came on the road against the 17th-ranked scoring defense in the country. Ohio State's blowout came against the 127th. Good teams that look bad for a week tend to bounce back. Indiana is 4-0 at home, allowing 9.8 points a game. Ohio State's scoring drops from 50.5 at home to 27 on the road.

The risk is real. Jeremiah Smith gets a secondary that allowed 9.8 yards per attempt to Northwestern and Rutgers. And the Buckeye defense is built to erase the big plays Indiana leaned on last week. If Smith gets loose, Ohio State covers.

But this looks like a field-goal game, and the hook is worth paying for, even at -124. Indiana +3.5.

Injuries noted

Ohio State Buckeyes: Austin Siereveld (out) — Starting offensive lineman ruled out against Indiana with a non-football illness.; Ja'Kobi Jackson (out) — Running back ruled out after a foot injury against Maryland.; Leroy Roker III (out) — Rotational safety listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified.; Khmari Bing (out) — Safety listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified.; Amari Valerio-Hudson (out) — Wide receiver listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified.; Jaxon Powell (out) — Offensive lineman listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified.; Anthony Rogers (out) — Running back nicknamed Turbo downgraded to out Friday for Indiana; condition unspecified.; Brock Boyd (doubtful) — Freshman wide receiver listed doubtful against Indiana; condition unspecified.; Brenten Jones (questionable) — Walk-on defensive back nicknamed Inky listed questionable against Indiana; condition unspecified.

Indiana Hoosiers: Khobie Martin (doubtful) — Running back listed doubtful for Ohio State in the October 16 preview's Thursday availability update; recovering from a broken forearm sustained in Week 1.; Andrew Barker (out) — Tight end listed out in the October 16 preview's Thursday availability update. This conflicts with the questionable designation in the October 14 initial report; a definitive game-day resolution was not retrieved.

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Julian Sayin is OSU's projected starter

    10.87 Y/A

    Julian Sayin is OSU's projected starting quarterback. The October 16 game preview explicitly lists Sayin among the projected starters for October 17; this establishes a projection, not a confirmed game-day lineup. 2026 line: 1772 passing yards, 71.2% completions, 10.87 yards per attempt, 17-2 TD-INT over 6 games.

  • Josh Hoover is IU's projected starter

    10.57 Y/A

    Josh Hoover is IU's projected starting quarterback. The October 16 game preview explicitly lists Hoover among the projected starters for October 17; this establishes a projection, not a confirmed game-day lineup. 2026 line: 1364 passing yards, 68.2% completions, 10.57 yards per attempt, 17-0 TD-INT over 6 games.

TRENCHES

  • IU: 222.2 rushing yards per game to OSU's 163.8

    58.3 YPG

    Indiana runs for more than Ohio State, and this is no fluke: Indiana was at 212.9 last season and Ohio State at 154.4, so both are close to who they were. This game pits Indiana's ground-first identity at home against an Ohio State team that runs less. If Indiana can keep running, it shortens the game and limits Ohio State's possessions, which matters when thinking about the total and the underdog margin.

TURNOVERS

  • IU: 0.17 turnovers committed per game to OSU's 1

    0.83 TO

    Indiana has turned it over just 0.17 times per game through 6 games, while Ohio State is at 1. Indiana was careful last season too at 0.5 over 16 games, so the ball security is real, though a rate this low tends to rise. Ohio State at 0.79 last season has been a bit looser, and in a game between strong teams, the side less likely to gift possessions carries an edge at home.

MISMATCH

  • OSU: 337.8 pass yards a game to IU's 241.3

    337.8 VS 241.3

    Ohio State throws for 337.8 yards a game over six games, up from 268.2 last season. Indiana is at 241.3, almost exactly its 239.1 from a year ago, so its passing looks steady. Ohio State's jump is large but it came from a strong base, so a high number should mostly hold. Indiana needs to keep Ohio State's offense off the field with its own sustained drives.

REPLACEMENT

  • Austin Siereveld (OL) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Starting offensive lineman ruled out against Indiana with a non-football illness. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Ja'Kobi Jackson (RB) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Running back ruled out after a foot injury against Maryland. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Leroy Roker III (S) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Rotational safety listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Khmari Bing (S) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Safety listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Amari Valerio-Hudson (WR) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Wide receiver listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Jaxon Powell (OL) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Offensive lineman listed out against Indiana; condition unspecified. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Anthony Rogers (RB) is out for OSU

    OUT

    Running back nicknamed Turbo downgraded to out Friday for Indiana; condition unspecified. Ohio State Injury Report: Austin Siereveld and Ja’Kobi Jackson Out, Brock Boyd Doubtful vs. Indiana; Five Other Starters Returning to Action (2026-10-16)

  • Andrew Barker (TE) is out for IU

    OUT

    Tight end listed out in the October 16 preview's Thursday availability update. This conflicts with the questionable designation in the October 14 initial report; a definitive game-day resolution was not retrieved. Game preview: IU football set to host Ohio State in historic clash (2026-10-16) Initial Availability Report for Indiana-Ohio State Game (2026-10-14)

SITUATIONAL

  • OSU: 337.8 team passing yards per game to IU's 241.3

    96.5 YPG

    OSU is at 337.8 team passing yards per game over 6 games; IU is at 241.3 over 6 games. Those are this season's games through Oct 16. Last season OSU was at 268.2 over 14 games and IU at 239.1 over 16 games.

  • No. 4 Ohio State at No. 5 Indiana

    #4 VS #5

    These two are nearly even in the eyes of voters: Ohio State has 1508 points and Indiana has 1461, and Indiana is the one holding a first-place vote. Indiana is 6-0 and rose two spots, while Ohio State is 5-1 and moved up one. The 4 and 5 rankings undersell how close this looks, and Indiana is at home. Bettors should price this as a coin-flip kind of matchup rather than lean on the brand name.

TEAM RECORD

  • Big Ten game: OSU 3-0, IU 3-0 in conference

    CONFERENCE

    These two share the Big Ten. OSU is 3-0 against it, IU is 3-0. 2026 standings through 2026-10-17.

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Daily picks first stored October 17, 2026 at 8:07 AM ET.
Odds record
The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: fanduel, betrivers, draftkings, fanatics, betmgm, caesars.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF picksEvery sport this day