Skip to content
GARY A.I.Get the app
NCAAF · Sat, Oct 3 · 7:00 PM

BYU Cougars at TCU Horned Frogs

O/U 47.5 · SPREAD BYU Cougars -5.5

GARY'S PICK
TCU +5.5
NCAAFvs BYU· -104

TCU
+5.5

-104 · LOST · BYU 17 · TCU 10

BYU

The pick & result

Published pick
TCU Horned Frogs +5.5 -104
Published odds
-104
Result
Lost
Final score
17-10

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The line

BETMGM · 39 moves
MarketOpened
Sep 27 5:03 PM
Close
Oct 3 6:50 PM
Move
SPREADBYU Cougars -6.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -5.5 (-110)−1
TOTAL51.5 (-102)48.5 (-110)−3
MONEYLINEBYU Cougars -235BYU Cougars -210+25
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENSep 27 5:03 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-112)51.5 (-102)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 27 6:03 PMBYU Cougars -7 (-108)48.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 27 7:05 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)49.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +190
Sep 27 9:05 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)49.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Sep 27 11:05 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)48.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Sep 28 12:05 AMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-105)49.5 (-105)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Sep 28 8:01 AMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-108)49.5 (-105)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +190
Sep 28 1:46 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 28 2:16 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -250 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 28 3:17 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 28 5:18 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-112)48.5 (-105)BYU Cougars -250 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 28 7:18 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 28 8:18 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -250 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 29 7:30 AMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 29 12:03 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)47.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -250 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 29 2:04 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)47.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +200
Sep 30 11:32 AMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-110)47.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -235 · TCU Horned Frogs +195
Oct 1 2:03 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Oct 1 5:04 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 1 5:35 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Oct 1 8:36 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 1 9:06 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 1 11:07 PMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-108)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 2 5:00 AMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-108)47.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Oct 2 9:00 AMBYU Cougars -6.5 (-108)47.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 2 5:21 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 8:31 AMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 10:28 AMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 10:58 AMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 1:30 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Oct 3 4:13 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-115)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 5:04 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-108)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 5:20 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)47.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 5:30 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 5:59 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)48.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 6:09 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)48.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +188
Oct 3 6:19 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)48.5 (-108)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 6:29 PMBYU Cougars -6 (-110)48.5 (-112)BYU Cougars -225 · TCU Horned Frogs +185
Oct 3 6:40 PMBYU Cougars -5.5 (-108)48.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -210 · TCU Horned Frogs +170
CLOSEOct 3 6:50 PMBYU Cougars -5.5 (-110)48.5 (-110)BYU Cougars -210 · TCU Horned Frogs +175

The read

Saturday night under the lights in Fort Worth. A top ten BYU team comes off a bye and walks into Amon G. Carter Stadium, where a TCU team that lost at UCF a week ago has allowed 9.7 points per game at home.

BYU's case is real and I respect it. The Cougars average 0.448 points added per play with a 59.9% success rate, and they finish what they start at 5.435 points per scoring opportunity. SP+ rates them 16.3 to TCU's 8.2. I still want the points, because the BYU offense on the field tonight is different from the one that built those numbers.

Those numbers came against a schedule that ranks 116th, behind a full offensive line. That line is no longer intact: - Andrew Gentry, the starting right tackle, had ankle surgery this week. - Ethan Thomason and Caden McKee are also out. - A freshman platoon takes over at right tackle.

That line now meets the best front BYU has seen this year. TCU has allowed 344 rushing yards across four games. It stuffs 21.1% of runs, and opponents convert power runs at a 0.5625 rate. TCU's front seven havoc rate of 0.117 is higher than BYU's 0.091, and Ansel Din-Mbuh has 3 sacks from the interior.

BYU is a running team: 262.7 rushing yards a game, with LJ Martin at 7.8 a carry. Their identity runs straight into TCU's strength. If the Frogs win early downs, BYU has to live on passing downs, and that is where this offense becomes more ordinary.

The two defenses separate on the numbers too: - TCU allows -0.121 points per play and 0.925 explosiveness. Those are the best defensive marks in this game. - BYU's defense allows -0.061 and 1.182.

That 1.182 is the softest number either team carries, and BYU is without cornerback Jonathan Kabeya and safety Raider Damuni. Jaden Craig likes to push the ball downfield, with Ed Small at 371 receiving yards and Kari Ashley at 266 yards and 3 touchdowns. That is TCU's route to points.

The risk is on the TCU offense, and I am not ignoring it: - Against the Tar Heels, Craig threw for 175 yards. At UCF it was 306 yards with two interceptions. Neither game produced a touchdown pass. - TCU succeeds on just 21.8% of passing downs. - It scores 3.433 points per scoring opportunity, and tonight it plays without kicker Kyle Lemmermann and linemen Devan Robison and Creece Brister.

That is why this is a spread ticket and the +180 stays in my pocket. I need TCU to stay inside the number, which I expect if their defense holds up against this line; I don't need them to win outright.

The market has moved toward this view. The line opened at BYU -7.5 and the total fell from 50.5 to 47.5. In a game priced for points to be scarce, 5.5 carries real weight, and -104 is a better price than laying -118 with a favorite whose offensive line is being rebuilt this week.

Injuries noted

BYU Cougars: Jonathan Kabeya (out) — Cornerback; initial TCU-game designation reiterated October 2; condition unspecified.; Raider Damuni (out) — Safety; condition unspecified in the availability list.; Sione Moa (out) — Running back; condition unspecified.; Siale Esera (out) — Linebacker; remains sidelined following injury against Arizona.; Caden McKee (out) — Offensive lineman; condition unspecified.; Andrew Gentry (out) — Starting right tackle; recovering from surgery earlier in game week.; Ethan Thomason (out) — Offensive tackle; injury unspecified; a return later this season is expected.; Brody Laga (out) — Kickoff specialist; condition unspecified.; Kevin Doe (probable) — Cornerback; condition unspecified.

TCU Horned Frogs: Michael Short (out) — Linebacker; initial BYU-game report, condition unspecified.; Devondre McGee (out) — Cornerback; condition unspecified.; Joe Pitchford (out) — Running back; condition unspecified.; Kyle Lemmermann (out) — Kicker; condition unspecified.; Devan Robison (out) — Offensive lineman; condition unspecified.; Creece Brister (out) — Offensive lineman; condition unspecified.; Cooper Reid (out) — Wide receiver; condition unspecified.; Zach Chapman (questionable) — Edge rusher; Dykes expressed optimism about playing, but the report remains questionable.; Perry Cole Jr. (questionable) — Defensive tackle; condition unspecified.

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Jaden Craig is TCU's confirmed starter

    9.16 Y/A

    Jaden Craig is TCU's confirmed starting quarterback. TCU's October 1 preview for the October 3 BYU game explicitly identifies Harvard transfer Craig as its starting quarterback. 2026 line: 1209 passing yards, 68.2% completions, 9.16 yards per attempt, 7-3 TD-INT over 4 games.

  • Bear Bachmeier is BYU's confirmed starter

    10.35 Y/A

    Bear Bachmeier is BYU's confirmed starting quarterback. KSL's September 28 report reproduces BYU's TCU-week depth chart, listing Bachmeier first at quarterback without an OR designation. 2026 line: 642 passing yards, 71.0% completions, 10.35 yards per attempt, 6-1 TD-INT over 3 games.

TRENCHES

  • BYU: 262.7 rushing yards per game to TCU's 138.8

    123.9 YPG

    BYU is running for 262.7 a game, but that comes from just 3 games, against 178.1 last season. TCU at 138.8 over 4 games sits close to its 131.4 from last season. BYU's run game should still be the stronger unit on the road, but expect its pace to settle closer to last season's level.

PACE & SCRIPT

  • BYU: 44 points per game to TCU's 29.3

    14.8 PPG

    BYU is scoring 44 a game, but that comes from only three games, and last season it sat at 31.4 over 14. TCU is at 29.3, almost exactly last year's 30.7, so its number looks steady. Expect BYU's scoring to drift back toward last season's level on the road, which makes the full-game total and BYU team total the places where the early number can mislead.

MISMATCH

  • BYU: 262.7 rush yards a game to TCU's 138.8

    262.7 VS 138.8

    BYU is running for 262.7 a game over 3 games, well above last season's 178.1, while TCU sits at 138.8, close to its 131.4 from last season. TCU's number looks like who they are, and BYU's three-game surge is likely to cool some. If BYU can still lean on the run on the road, they control the clock and keep TCU's offense waiting on the sideline.

COVERAGE

  • TCU: 24.5% third downs allowed to BYU's 43.6%

    19.1 PP

    TCU allows opponents to convert 24.5% of third downs over four games, while BYU allows 43.6% over three. TCU gets off the field, and BYU has struggled to. BYU's number comes from only three games, so it could shift quickly with one strong outing. At home, TCU's third down edge could mean more possessions, which is a useful way to think about drives and the total.

REPLACEMENT

  • Cooper Reid (WR) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Wide receiver; condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Jonathan Kabeya (CB) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Cornerback; initial TCU-game designation reiterated October 2; condition unspecified. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02)

  • Raider Damuni (S) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Safety; condition unspecified in the availability list. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02)

  • Sione Moa (RB) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Running back; condition unspecified. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02)

  • Siale Esera (LB) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Linebacker; remains sidelined following injury against Arizona. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02) KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Caden McKee (OL) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Offensive lineman; condition unspecified. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02)

  • Andrew Gentry (OL) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Starting right tackle; recovering from surgery earlier in game week. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02) KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Creece Brister (OL) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Offensive lineman; condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Ethan Thomason (OL) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Offensive tackle; injury unspecified; a return later this season is expected. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02) KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Brody Laga (PK) is out for BYU

    OUT

    Kickoff specialist; condition unspecified. BYU Sport Nuts: BYU's Eight Absences Create Three TCU Pressure Points (2026-10-02)

  • Michael Short (LB) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Linebacker; initial BYU-game report, condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Devondre McGee (CB) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Cornerback; condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Joe Pitchford (RB) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Running back; condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Kyle Lemmermann (PK) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Kicker; condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

  • Devan Robison (OL) is out for TCU

    OUT

    Offensive lineman; condition unspecified. KSL Sports: BYU football availability report entering road clash at TCU (2026-09-30)

SITUATIONAL

  • BYU has 7 more days of rest

    14d vs 7d

    BYU had the bye and comes in on 14 days of rest, while TCU is on a normal 7-day turnaround and gets to stay home. That extra week lets BYU heal up and prepare specifically for TCU, which offsets some of the burden of playing on the road. The two edges pull in opposite directions here. Weigh BYU's rest against TCU's home field rather than leaning on either alone.

  • BYU: 61.3% third-down conversion rate to TCU's 43.4%

    17.9 PP

    BYU is at 61.3% third-down conversion rate over 3 games; TCU is at 43.4% over 4 games. Those are this season's games through Oct 2. Last season BYU was at 42% over 14 games and TCU at 47.4% over 13 games.

TEAM RECORD

  • Big 12 game: BYU 1-0, TCU 0-1 in conference

    CONFERENCE

    These two share the Big 12. BYU is 1-0 against it, TCU is 0-1. 2026 standings through 2026-10-03.

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Daily picks first stored October 3, 2026 at 8:09 AM ET.
Odds record
The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: draftkings, fanduel, fanatics, betmgm, betrivers, caesars.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF picksEvery sport this day