Skip to content
GARY A.I.Get the app
NCAAF · Sat, Sep 26 · 7:00 PM

Kansas State Wildcats at Cincinnati Bearcats

O/U 55.5 · SPREAD Kansas State Wildcats -5.5

GARY'S PICK
Kansas State -6.5
NCAAF@ Cincinnati· -106

Kansas State
-6.5

-106 · LOST · KSU 26 · CIN 31

Cincinnati

The pick & result

Published pick
Kansas State Wildcats -6.5 -106
Published odds
-106
Result
Lost
Final score
26-31

Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.

The line

BETMGM · 35 moves
MarketOpened
Sep 20 3:42 PM
Close
Sep 26 6:43 PM
Move
SPREADKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)Kansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)Holds
TOTAL52.5 (-110)55.5 (-102)+3
MONEYLINEKansas State Wildcats -235Kansas State Wildcats -235Holds
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENSep 20 3:42 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)52.5 (-110)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +200
Sep 20 4:43 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)53.5 (-110)Kansas State Wildcats -250 · Cincinnati Bearcats +210
Sep 20 7:44 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-110)53.5 (-110)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +200
Sep 20 8:44 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)53.5 (-110)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +200
Sep 20 10:44 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)53.5 (-112)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +200
Sep 20 11:44 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)53.5 (-112)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 6:00 AMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-110)53.5 (-110)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 21 10:01 AMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)54.5 (-112)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 21 11:01 AMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)54.5 (-112)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 1:02 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 2:02 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-110)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 3:02 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-108)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 4:03 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 6:03 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 21 10:06 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-112)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 22 8:30 AMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 22 9:31 AMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +200
Sep 23 8:59 AMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 23 11:04 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-112)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 23 3:05 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 23 4:06 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 23 5:06 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-118)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +195
Sep 24 6:00 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-110)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 24 1:52 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-110)55.5 (-102)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 24 3:54 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-115)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -250 · Cincinnati Bearcats +210
Sep 24 6:24 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-110)55.5 (-105)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 25 11:01 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-110)55.5 (-102)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 26 10:03 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-108)55.5 (-108)Kansas State Wildcats -225 · Cincinnati Bearcats +188
Sep 26 10:34 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-108)55.5 (-108)Kansas State Wildcats -225 · Cincinnati Bearcats +185
Sep 26 10:54 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-110)54.5 (-118)Kansas State Wildcats -225 · Cincinnati Bearcats +188
Sep 26 11:04 AMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-115)55.5 (-108)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 26 5:10 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-118)55.5 (-102)Kansas State Wildcats -225 · Cincinnati Bearcats +188
Sep 26 6:02 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-108)55.5 (-102)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 26 6:12 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-118)55.5 (-108)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
Sep 26 6:33 PMKansas State Wildcats -6 (-110)55.5 (-108)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190
CLOSESep 26 6:43 PMKansas State Wildcats -6.5 (-112)55.5 (-102)Kansas State Wildcats -235 · Cincinnati Bearcats +190

The read

Nippert Stadium hosts an unbeaten matchup under the lights as conference play begins. Cincinnati gets the home stage, while Kansas State makes its first road trip under Collin Klein.

I’m backing Kansas State because its defensive front offers the clearest way to take this game out of the opponent’s preferred rhythm. Cincinnati’s outside-zone offense has been effective, but Kansas State has stopped 28.0% of opposing carries at or behind the line and recorded 30 tackles for loss. Cincinnati’s offensive success rate falls from 58.6% on standard downs to 33.9% on passing downs. I expect that disruption to create possessions where JC French IV’s quick throws cannot consistently recover the lost ground.

Avery Johnson presents a different problem for Cincinnati’s defense. Its staff specifically identified containing his perimeter runs as a priority. With Rodney Fields Jr. and Joe Jackson contributing on the ground, I like Kansas State’s chances of making Cincinnati defend the running game while preserving opportunities for Jaron Tibbs and Josh Manning. Kansas State’s 43.1% passing-down success rate also gives me more confidence in its ability to extend possessions when the initial play fails.

Cincinnati’s strongest answer is its offensive line and finishing ability. Its 11.4% offensive stuff rate shows that negative runs have been relatively uncommon, and its 5.435 points per scoring opportunity exceed Kansas State’s 4.864. Kansas State has also allowed damaging plays when opponents do succeed. Those are meaningful obstacles to covering this number.

The opponent-adjusted picture still supports the matchup advantage I’m buying. SP+ places Kansas State’s offense 17th and defense 33rd, compared with Cincinnati’s 30th and 62nd. Both opening schedules were weak, so I put more weight on that broader assessment than the raw defensive rankings. My bet is that Kansas State’s front interrupts enough Cincinnati possessions, while Johnson’s offense sustains enough of its own, to cover -6.5.

Injuries noted

Kansas State Wildcats: Blake Barnett (out) — Backup quarterback listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report; reporting said he was on crutches and expected to miss the next few weeks.; Jacob Knuth (questionable) — Backup quarterback listed questionable on the initial Big 12 availability report.; Dillon Duff (questionable) — Backup quarterback listed questionable on the initial Big 12 availability report.; Ja'Son Prevard (out) — Safety ruled out on the initial Big 12 availability report.; Oliver Miller (out) — Offensive lineman ruled out on the initial Big 12 availability report.

Cincinnati Bearcats: Aiden Pastoriza (out) — Offensive lineman listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game.; DaMari Witherspoon (out) — Tight end listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game.; Pierce Ayers (out) — Wide receiver listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game.; Filip Maciorowski (questionable) — Inside linebacker listed questionable on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game.

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Avery Johnson is KSU's projected starter

    7.41 Y/A

    Avery Johnson is KSU's projected starting quarterback. Current-week reporting expects Johnson to make his 30th consecutive start; he was not among Kansas State's quarterbacks carrying an availability designation. 2026 line: 608 passing yards, 69.5% completions, 7.41 yards per attempt, 6-2 TD-INT over 3 games.

  • JC French IV is CIN's confirmed starter

    7.77 Y/A

    JC French IV is CIN's confirmed starting quarterback. The September 25 official K-State game report states that the Georgia Southern transfer won Cincinnati's starting job. 2026 line: 614 passing yards, 77.2% completions, 7.77 yards per attempt, 5-0 TD-INT over 3 games.

PACE & SCRIPT

  • KSU: 10 points allowed per game to CIN's 18.7

    8.7 PPG

    KSU is at 10 points allowed per game over 3 games; CIN is at 18.7 over 3 games. Those are this season's games through Sep 25. Last season KSU was at 26.7 over 12 games and CIN at 25.6 over 13 games.

MISMATCH

  • KSU: 68.3% on third down to CIN's 54.3%

    68.3 VS 54.3

    Kansas State has converted 68.3% of its third downs through 3 games, and Cincinnati 54.3%. Last season they were at 37.2% and 38.7%. Both rates are far above last year and will almost certainly come down, so neither offense should count on them. Expect more punts than either team's early numbers suggest.

COVERAGE

  • KSU: 86.7 passing yards allowed per game to CIN's 207

    120.3 YPG

    Kennesaw State has given up 86.7 passing yards a game over 3 games, while Cincinnati sits at 207. That's a very low figure, and with no opponent detail on the sheet, it's worth asking whether teams simply chose to run on Kennesaw State. Numbers this extreme from three games tend to drift up, so size any read on this pass defense for a step up in competition at Cincinnati.

REPLACEMENT

  • Aiden Pastoriza (OL) is out for CIN

    OUT

    Offensive lineman listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game. Avery Johnson could be Kansas State’s only healthy quarterback at Cincinnati (2026-09-24)

  • Oliver Miller (OL) is out for KSU

    OUT

    Offensive lineman ruled out on the initial Big 12 availability report. Avery Johnson could be Kansas State’s only healthy quarterback at Cincinnati (2026-09-24)

  • Ja'Son Prevard (S) is out for KSU

    OUT

    Safety ruled out on the initial Big 12 availability report. Avery Johnson could be Kansas State’s only healthy quarterback at Cincinnati (2026-09-24)

  • DaMari Witherspoon (TE) is out for CIN

    OUT

    Tight end listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game. Avery Johnson could be Kansas State’s only healthy quarterback at Cincinnati (2026-09-24)

  • Pierce Ayers (WR) is out for CIN

    OUT

    Wide receiver listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report for this game. Avery Johnson could be Kansas State’s only healthy quarterback at Cincinnati (2026-09-24)

  • Blake Barnett (QB) is out for KSU

    OUT

    Backup quarterback listed out on the initial Big 12 availability report; reporting said he was on crutches and expected to miss the next few weeks. Avery Johnson could be Kansas State’s only healthy quarterback at Cincinnati (2026-09-24)

SITUATIONAL

  • KSU: 29.7 penalty yards per game to CIN's 66.3

    36.7 YDS

    Kansas State is one of the cleaner teams around at 29.7 penalty yards a game, and it was also disciplined last season at 38.3. Cincinnati is at 66.3, almost identical to 65.1 last season, so the gap reflects who both teams are. In a road game, Kansas State avoiding free yards while Cincinnati gives some away is a steady edge that tends to show up in drive extensions.

  • KSU: 68.3% third-down conversion rate to CIN's 54.3%

    14 PP

    Kansas State is converting 68.3% of third downs through three games after 37.2% last season, and Cincinnati is at 54.3% after 38.7%. Both teams are running well above their track records, and those rates almost always fall back. Expect both offenses to stall more than they have so far, so be wary of building expectations for long drives on either side.

  • CIN: 2.33 fourth-down attempts per game to KSU's 0.67

    1.67 ATT/G

    KSU is at 0.67 fourth-down attempts per game over 3 games; CIN is at 2.33 over 3 games. Those are this season's games through Sep 25. Last season KSU was at 2.67 over 12 games and CIN at 1.85 over 13 games.

All research from this day

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Daily picks first stored September 26, 2026 at 8:07 AM ET.
Odds record
The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: fanduel, betrivers, draftkings, betmgm, caesars.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Props on this game

1
  • GARY'S PICK
    AVERY JOHNSONRUSHING YARDS OVER 61.5
    NCAAFKansas State· -108

    Avery Johnson
    Rushing Yards over 61.5

    -108 · LOST · ACTUAL 38

    Kansas State

    I’m taking Johnson over 61.5 rushing yards. He has produced 253 yards on 24 carries through three games, clearing this number on his per-game pace without needing unusually heavy volume. Cincinnati has made containing his perimeter runs a priority, but that attention does not eliminate the stress created by Kansas State’s multiple rushing threats. Rodney Fields Jr. and Joe Jackson can occupy the defense between the tackles and preserve designed runs and scramble lanes for Johnson.

    The main concern is game flow: Kansas State can cover without asking Johnson to carry the rushing offense, and quarterback yardage can be volatile. Still, his early efficiency and central role in the matchup give me enough room to play the over at -108.

Every prop from this day is on the archive page.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Get Gary on the App Store

Every NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF picksEvery sport this day