Buffalo Bulls at Penn State Nittany Lions
O/U 68.5
The pick & result
- Published pick
- Buffalo Bulls +39.5 -110
- Published odds
- -110
- Result
- Lost
- Final score
- 13-55
Odds are the American price printed with this pick, not a current offer. Wins, losses and pushes remain on the public record; a missing grade is not a win.
The line
BETMGM · 37 moves| Market | Opened Sep 13 4:46 PM | Close Sep 19 11:50 AM | Move |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPREAD | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-108) | Penn State Nittany Lions -39 (-110) | −½ |
| TOTAL | 47.5 (-110) | 47.5 (-120) | Price |
Every move, in order ›
| When | Spread | Total | Moneyline |
|---|---|---|---|
| OPENSep 13 4:46 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-108) | 47.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 14 1:03 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-108) | 48.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 15 12:01 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -40 (-110) | 49.5 (-112) | — |
| Sep 15 4:01 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -40.5 (-110) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 16 2:31 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 48.5 (-115) | — |
| Sep 16 3:32 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 50.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 17 1:32 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 50.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 17 2:02 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 50.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 17 3:02 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 50.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 17 3:32 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 50.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 17 5:31 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 17 5:41 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-110) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 17 5:51 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-110) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 17 6:01 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-120) | 49.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 17 6:11 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 17 7:21 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-120) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 18 5:01 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 18 12:01 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-110) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 18 12:32 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-110) | — |
| Sep 18 3:03 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 18 3:33 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 18 5:20 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 18 7:34 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 18 10:32 PM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 12:32 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 7:30 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 19 8:00 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41.5 (-108) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 9:41 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-110) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 9:52 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-110) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 10:11 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -41 (-110) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 10:22 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-110) | 49.5 (-105) | — |
| Sep 19 10:32 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-110) | 49.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 19 10:42 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-115) | 48.5 (-102) | — |
| Sep 19 10:53 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39 (-115) | 48.5 (-108) | — |
| Sep 19 11:03 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39.5 (-112) | 48.5 (-102) | — |
| Sep 19 11:24 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39 (-110) | 48.5 (-102) | — |
| Sep 19 11:30 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39 (-110) | 47.5 (-118) | — |
| CLOSESep 19 11:50 AM | Penn State Nittany Lions -39 (-110) | 47.5 (-120) | — |
The read
It’s a noon kickoff at Beaver Stadium, with Penn State closing its nonconference schedule and Buffalo arriving after a road loss at FIU. The Bulls bring uncertainty at quarterback into a demanding setting.
I’m backing Buffalo’s ability to interrupt enough possessions to stay inside this number. Its defense has allowed a 34.9% success rate through two games. That needs the context of its opponents, but it gives the Bulls a credible foundation: they have forced unsuccessful plays. Penn State’s passing offense presents a tougher assignment, yet its own difficulty finishing possessions creates an opening for those stops to matter.
Against Temple, Penn State’s opening possession unraveled through a penalty, a sack and a missed field goal. Another opportunity ended on downs after an interception return set up first-and-goal. Matt Campbell identified blocking, timing and run execution as the problems. Those details matter here because Becht can play well and Penn State can control the game while still leaving scoring opportunities unfinished. Buffalo’s case depends on making the favorite complete its drives.
There is also a demonstrated connection for Buffalo to build around. Jason Wright, reported likely to start, threw both of its touchdown passes to Chance Morrow at FIU. One scoring possession followed a defensive takeaway, and Wright’s 13-of-27 performance does not establish dependable offense. Still, Morrow has caught all five Buffalo touchdown passes this season. My judgment is that this connection gives the Bulls a plausible source of points even if sustained drives remain difficult.
The danger is substantial. Becht has seven touchdown passes without an interception, while Buffalo ranks 98th in defensive explosiveness allowed. Penn State can punish the Bulls badly when their defense does break. Buffalo’s 32.7% offensive success rate also raises the risk of repeatedly handing possession back.
I expect Penn State’s advantages to show. At this price, though, I put more weight on Buffalo forcing some stalled possessions and contributing enough offense through Morrow than on Penn State consistently turning control into touchdowns. That is the case for taking the points, with measured confidence given Buffalo’s vulnerability to explosive plays.
Injuries noted
Penn State Nittany Lions: Max Granville (out for season) — Defensive end sustained a season-ending injury in practice; Penn State plans to redistribute his edge snaps among Alexander McPherson, Ikenna Ezeogu, Yvan Kemajou and Caleb Bacon.; Cam Smith (questionable) — Linebacker missed the Temple game, returned to practice Tuesday and was called questionable for Buffalo by head coach Matt Campbell.; Gabe Burkle (limited) — Tight end returned from a torn ACL against Temple on a snap limit; offensive coordinator Taylor Mouser said he hoped the restrictions could be removed for Buffalo.
The research
The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.
QUARTERBACK
Jason Wright is BUF's confirmed starter
6.85 Y/AJason Wright is BUF's confirmed starting quarterback. Elijah Holmes was ruled out with a knee injury on game day, and the attributed report states Wright will start in his absence. 2026 line: 185 passing yards, 48.1% completions, 6.85 yards per attempt, 2-1 TD-INT over 1 games.
Rocco Becht is PSU's confirmed starter
11.98 Y/ARocco Becht is PSU's confirmed starting quarterback. Penn State's Buffalo-week game notes and coverage identify Becht as the quarterback leading the offense; no current report reviewed indicated a competition or availability concern. 2026 line: 539 passing yards, 75.6% completions, 11.98 yards per attempt, 7-0 TD-INT over 2 games.
TRENCHES
PSU is +49 rush yards per game
49 YPGBUF is at 102 rushing yards per game over 2 games; PSU is at 151 over 2 games. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-18.
PACE & SCRIPT
PSU's defense gives up 20.5 fewer points per game
20.5 PPGBUF is at 25 points allowed per game over 2 games; PSU is at 4.5 over 2 games. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-18.
BUF @ PSU carries a 68.5 market total
68.5BUF @ PSU's 68.5 FanDuel total is 13 points above the 55.5 median across 45 posted slate games, setting an above-median aggregate scoring expectation. The fact sheet offers no further evidence on what would challenge that setup.
PSU is scoring +15.5 points per game
15.5 PPGBUF is at 20.5 points per game over 2 games; PSU is at 36 over 2 games. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-18.
TURNOVERS
PSU commits 2 fewer turnovers per game
2 TOBUF is at 2 turnovers committed per game over 2 games; PSU is at 0 over 2 games. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-18.
MISMATCH
PSU's ball security against BUF's giveaways — 2 turnovers a game to PSU's 0
0 VS 2The widest gap on this matchup's tape: turnovers / g — BUF 2, PSU 0, over 2 and 2 game samples.
COVERAGE
PSU's secondary gives up 190 fewer passing yards per game
190 YPGBUF is at 295 passing yards allowed per game over 2 games; PSU is at 105 over 2 games. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-18.
PSU allows a third-down conversion rate 14.4 percentage points lower
14.4 PPBUF is at 36.1% third downs allowed over 2 games; PSU is at 21.7% over 2 games. Those come from the opposing team boxes in the games each side has already played this 2026 season, through 2026-09-18.
REPLACEMENT
Max Granville (DE) is out for the season for PSU
OUT FOR SEASONDefensive end sustained a season-ending injury in practice; Penn State plans to redistribute his edge snaps among Alexander McPherson, Ikenna Ezeogu, Yvan Kemajou and Caleb Bacon. Penn State Week 3 Injury Report: Latest Updates, Who's Out, Who's Up Next (2026-09-15) Weekly Press Conference - Head Coach Matt Campbell (Buffalo) (2026-09-15)
Elijah Holmes (QB) is out for BUF
OUTStarting quarterback was ruled out against Penn State with the knee injury suffered in Week 2. Elijah Holmes Fantasy College Football News & Stats (2026-09-19)
SITUATIONAL
PSU gives away 41.5 fewer penalty yards per game
41.5 YDSBUF is at 74 penalty yards per game over 2 games; PSU is at 32.5 over 2 games. Those are current-2026 team-game results through 2026-09-18.
About this analysis
- Who made it
- Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
- Published data
- Daily picks first stored September 19, 2026 at 7:42 AM ET.
- Odds record
- The pick receipt shows the price printed in the published ticket. The matchup market and line ladder provide separate market context. Stored sportsbook sources: fanduel, draftkings, betmgm, fanatics, betrivers, caesars.
- Accountability
- Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.
Props on this game
1- GARY'S PICKKOBY HOWARDRECEIVING YARDS OVER 61.5
I’m taking Howard over 61.5 receiving yards. He has produced 229 yards on nine catches through two games, showing the ability to clear this number through explosive gains rather than requiring heavy volume.
That fits the vulnerable part of Buffalo’s defense. The Bulls have forced unsuccessful plays at a respectable rate, but they rank 98th in defensive explosiveness allowed. Howard is the Penn State receiver best positioned to punish the breakdowns that do occur, and Becht’s efficient start gives him a strong chance of delivering catchable opportunities downfield.
The primary risk is game script. Penn State could build an early lead and shift toward the run before Howard accumulates enough work. Still, he needs only a few productive targets to reach 62 yards, and I prefer that path to laying a heavier price on Becht’s passing-yardage over.
Every prop from this day is on the archive page.
Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.
Get Gary on the App StoreEvery NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF picksEvery sport this day