Skip to content
NCAAF · Sat, Sep 5 · 3:45 PM

Oklahoma State Cowboys at Tulsa Golden Hurricane

O/U 59.5 · SPREAD Oklahoma State Cowboys -13.5

GARY'S PICK
NCAAF@ Tulsa Golden Hurricane· -110

Oklahoma State Cowboys
-13.5

-110 · LOST · OKST 10 · TLSA 24

Tulsa Golden Hurricane

The line

FANDUEL · 5 moves
MarketOpened
Sep 4 5:05 AM
Close
Sep 5 7:30 PM
Move
SPREADTulsa Golden Hurricane +13.5 (-110)Tulsa Golden Hurricane -13.5 (-5000)Price
Every move, in order ›
WhenSpreadTotalMoneyline
OPENSep 4 5:05 AMTulsa Golden Hurricane +13.5 (-110)Oklahoma State Cowboys -550 · Tulsa Golden Hurricane +450
Sep 5 5:02 AMTulsa Golden Hurricane +13.5 (-110)Oklahoma State Cowboys -550 · Tulsa Golden Hurricane +440
Sep 5 11:18 AMTulsa Golden Hurricane +13.5 (-110)Oklahoma State Cowboys -580 · Tulsa Golden Hurricane +450
Sep 5 11:54 AMTulsa Golden Hurricane +13.5 (-110)Oklahoma State Cowboys -550 · Tulsa Golden Hurricane +450
Sep 5 4:30 PMTulsa Golden Hurricane +7.5 (-114)Oklahoma State Cowboys -390 · Tulsa Golden Hurricane +280
CLOSESep 5 7:30 PMTulsa Golden Hurricane -13.5 (-5000)

The read

A sold-out H.A. Chapman Stadium hosts an in-state rivalry under punishing afternoon heat. Tulsa opens its second season under Tre Lamb, while Oklahoma State unveils Eric Morris’ rebuilt program.

I’m laying the points because the Cowboys’ most important offensive relationships arrive together. Drew Mestemaker, Caleb Hawkins and Wyatt Young played in Morris’ North Texas offense last season. Oklahoma State has extensive turnover, but its quarterback, primary running back, leading receiver and head coach already have experience producing together. I expect that familiarity to matter immediately.

Mestemaker’s 4,379 passing yards and 34 touchdowns describe the passing component. Hawkins supplied 1,434 rushing yards and 25 rushing touchdowns, while Young caught 70 passes for 1,264 yards and 10 touchdowns. Those are prior-season North Texas numbers, not Oklahoma State projections. Their relevance is the complementary production: this group demonstrated ways to sustain possessions through the air and finish them on the ground. Young’s team-high competitive target share and Hawkins’ leading red-zone carry share also establish who handled important offensive situations.

Tulsa’s strongest answer is to sustain its own drives through Baylor Hayes and an offensive line returning four players who made at least four starts. That could keep this competitive deep into the game. But Tulsa is replacing major rushing and receiving production around Hayes while installing a new offensive coordinator. I put more weight on Oklahoma State retaining those central offensive connections than on Tulsa retaining its quarterback alone. Tulsa’s closing loss to UAB also included 229 rushing yards allowed on 55 attempts—a relevant concern against Hawkins, although one historical game cannot establish today’s run defense.

The obstacle to laying this number is Oklahoma State’s offensive line. Its opening competitions at several positions matter because familiar skill players still need their blocks. Mestemaker’s five sacks and three interceptions against Tulane show how that offense can unravel when protection fails. Tulsa’s covering path becomes much stronger if it creates that disruption while Hayes keeps its own possessions moving; I am not assuming Tulsa can reproduce another opponent’s defensive performance.

My judgment is that Oklahoma State’s established offensive connections will generate enough sustained scoring to separate over four quarters. The assumptions are that the new line functions adequately and the rebuilt defense gets enough stops against Tulsa’s revised supporting cast. The unresolved protection matchup could change this decision: consistent Tulsa pressure would attack the foundation of the bet. I favor Oklahoma State’s multiple demonstrated offensive options at -13.5, with moderate conviction rather than treating the overhaul as a finished product.

The research

The dated measurements the app shows under this card — observations with their sample and source, not predictions.

QUARTERBACK

  • Drew Mestemaker is OKST's returning passer on 2025 numbers

    9.46 Y/A

    Drew Mestemaker (Oklahoma State Cowboys): 2025 season line, thrown for UNT: 4379 passing yards, 68.9% completions, 9.46 yards per attempt, 34-9 TD-INT over 14 games. He is on Oklahoma State Cowboys's active roster this season; the current season has no passing line for him yet.

  • Baylor Hayes is TLSA's returning passer on 2025 numbers

    6.83 Y/A

    Baylor Hayes (Tulsa Golden Hurricane): 2025 season line: 2158 passing yards, 58.9% completions, 6.83 yards per attempt, 12-6 TD-INT over 10 games. He is on Tulsa Golden Hurricane's active roster this season; the current season has no passing line for him yet.

PACE & SCRIPT

  • OKST @ TLSA carries a 34.5 market total

    34.5

    The expectation is a controlled game with limited scoring chances and plenty of drives ending before they become points. It cracks if either side finds explosive gains early and turns the game into a faster back-and-forth.

HEAD-TO-HEAD

  • OKST and TLSA have met once since 2025

    1-0 SERIES

    Tulsa dictated a low-scoring game and held Oklahoma State down on its own field. Tulsa gets the added benefit of hosting this rematch.

REPLACEMENT

  • Elijah Green (CB) is out for TLSA

    OUT

    Tulsa’s other corners have to cover his snaps, with the secondary adjusting its matchups and rotation. OUT means there is no late clearance coming tonight, and Oklahoma State’s offense gets to test that altered defensive group.

  • William Alexander (LB) is out for TLSA

    OUT

    Alexander was ruled out against Oklahoma State while recovering from a sprained ACL. Per Marshall Scott, Pistols Firing, Sep 1.

  • Donovan Green (TE) is questionable for OKST

    QUESTIONABLE

    Green has an undisclosed injury and was reported questionable for the season opener at Tulsa. Per FOX Sports, Sep 5.

  • Oscar Hammond (TE) is questionable for OKST

    QUESTIONABLE

    Hammond has an undisclosed injury and was reported questionable for the season opener at Tulsa. Per FOX Sports / Tyler Waldrep of Pistols Firing, Sep 5.

THE SWEAT

  • THE NUMBER

    OKST 10–24

    Oklahoma State Cowboys -13.5 -110

  • BALL SECURITY

    4 · 1

    Oklahoma State Cowboys -13.5 -110

  • AIR

    241 · 227

    Oklahoma State Cowboys -13.5 -110

  • GROUND

    127 · 134

    Oklahoma State Cowboys -13.5 -110

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Board stored September 5, 2026 at 8:24 AM ET.
Odds record
The displayed line is the value retained with the call. Stored sportsbook sources: caesars, betrivers, fanduel, draftkings, betmgm, fanatics.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. My Book on this website lets you tail or fade listed calls and keeps your record separately labeled; Gary is also available as a native iOS app.

Download on the App Store

Every NCAAF game this dayThe NCAAF recordToday's NCAAF board