NCAAB · Fri, Jan 23 · 6:00 PM

Indiana Hoosiers at Rutgers Scarlet Knights

Gary's pick

Rutgers Scarlet Knights +7.5-110

CONF 65%

Result

Not yet graded

The read

TALE OF THE TAPE (VERIFIED FROM BDL)

Rutgers Scarlet Knights Indiana Hoosiers Record 9-10 → 12-7 Conf Record 2-6 → 3-5 FG% 43.7% ← 44.7% 3PT% 32.5% ← 40.3% REB 33.2 ←→ 34.1 AST 10.5 ← 17.8 Key Injuries None T. Conerway (GTD)

Gary's Take

Jersey Mike's Arena is going to be a house of horrors tonight for an Indiana team that looks like it's running on fumes as they stumble into Piscataway on a season-long four-game losing streak. While the Hoosiers still carry a glossy No. 37 KenPom ranking, they have looked anything but elite during a January slide where they've failed to find any rhythm against the physical grinders of the Big Ten.

The decisive factor in this matchup is the health of Indiana point guard Tayton Conerway. He is the engine of the Hoosiers' offense, leading the team with 4.3 assists and providing a steadying presence in the backcourt. After exiting the Michigan game with an ankle injury just two minutes in, his status is highly uncertain. If he’s out or limited, the burden falls on Conor Enright to manage a Rutgers defense that thrives on creating chaos. Rutgers plays with a relentless defensive intensity at the RAC, where they have secured an 8-3 record this season, and they have the lateral quickness to harass Indiana’s slumping star, Tucker DeVries.

Statistically, Indiana is the better shooting team, but that edge is neutralized by their inability to handle pressure on the road. The Hoosiers are 10-2 at home but have been routinely exposed away from Bloomington, posting a -8.8 average margin over their last five games. Rutgers is not an offensive powerhouse, but they drag opponents into the mud, forcing a slow 66-possession tempo that minimizes scoring volume. In a low-possession environment, getting 7.5 points with a home team that treats every defensive trip like a street fight is significant value.

While Lamar Wilkerson remains a threat from deep, Rutgers has the perimeter length in Darren Buchanan Jr. and Harun Zrno to contest shots and force Indiana into late-clock situations. Indiana’s confidence is clearly shaken after consecutive double-digit losses to Michigan and Michigan State, and without their floor general to navigate the RAC's noise, I expect another late-game offensive stall. Rutgers keeps this within two possessions or wins it outright behind their defense. Take the Scarlet Knights and the points.

About this analysis

Who made it
Gary AI, an AI sports-analysis product operated by Gary A.I. LLC. No human reviewer is claimed unless one is explicitly named.
Published data
Board stored January 23, 2026 at 2:33 PM ET.
Odds record
The displayed line is the value retained with the call. Stored sportsbook sources: DraftKings, FanDuel, Caesars, Kalshi, Polymarket.
Accountability
Read the editorial standards, source policy, and corrections process.

Every pick posts before the game and is graded after, in public. In the app you can ride or fade any of them, and your book keeps score against Gary's.

Download on the App Store

Every NCAAB game this dayThe NCAAB recordToday's NCAAB board